Found this on a blog, was wondering which everyone prefered! The only thing they have in common is the title and that they're both emotional songs.

 

For the record, I loved Kelly Clarkson's last album, "My December." Everyone was all, "This isn't her usual pop sound, I refuse to listen" but that mentality only undermines the concept of artists taking risks and trying new things. Plus, you missed out on killer tracks like, "Hole," "Irvine," "Judas" and "Sober."

 

I was reminded of this today because a new song from Pink, also called "Sober," hit the Web and like the rest of the tracks I've heard off her upcoming album, it makes me want to chop off my hair, bleach it and join her army of disenchanted youths!

 

http://blogs.nypost.com/popwrap/archives/2...challenges.html

I think we've already done this in the Pop forum but anyway i voted for Pink's song.

P!nk's. I like Kelly's a lot but P!nk's is really special.

Kelly is so far better!

I voted for Kellys although P!nks is my #1 song atm.

IMO...

 

Kelly's is far better! :heart:

 

I do love P!nks don't get me wrong... but I prefer Kelly's :heart:

Kelly's Sober is IMMENSE. One of my fave songs of all time.

Kelly's for me :wub:

Kelly's by far :heart:

Kelly's sober is a song I can listen to over and over again and it never loses its appeal. As good as P!nk's sober is, I can't say the same for it.

Pink's is better

Kelly's!

Kelly's for me.

Although I do like Pink's alot.

It was already done in the pop forum, and Kelly won with a landslide

Pinks is good, but Kelly's is SO much better. :wub:

 

At the bridge towards the end, her voice is just amazing...gives me chills.

BTW have you guys seen this fanmade video? It's amazing!

 

thats good indeed :o

cool vid :)

 

Kelly's Sober is a real gem on MD so i went for that, the ending is just :wub:

P!nk's is amazing too, a difficult choice

I voted for Kelly's, even though P!nk's is great. :wub:

Pink's. I love Kelly's but it only really gets amazing near the end, Pink's is amazing throughout IMO. :)