Posted February 9, 200916 yr If you had to choose between the two, which Comic Relief Single is worse, Girls Aloud/Sugababe's cover of Aerosmith's/Run-D.M.C.'s 'Walk This Way' or the Saturdays version of Depeche Mode's 'Just Can't Get Enough'?
February 9, 200916 yr "Walk This Way" right now, The Saturdays have made a decent attempt at the song but it could be better. After listening to it I feel "this song isn't that good to start with" but I know there's another version I like so maybe it could be better.
February 9, 200916 yr Girls Aloud + Sugababes. It's worse, plus they made a hash out of what was originally a decent song, it's not as if The Saturdays had a lot to work with covering one of Depeche Mode's most shoddy tracks.
February 9, 200916 yr Author Girls Aloud + Sugababes. It's worse, plus they made a hash out of what was originally a decent song, it's not as if The Saturdays had a lot to work with covering one of Depeche Mode's most shoddy tracks. Exactly, Depeche Mode is quite a simple song. They could have either made a simple cover, or used it to their advantage and gone all out for it making it into a completely whole new song. But it's sounds like some Cascada-knock off, and it's impossible to find knock off shit if you ask me. :lol:
February 9, 200916 yr Exactly, Depeche Mode is quite a simple song. They could have either made a simple cover, or used it to their advantage and gone all out for it making it into a completely whole new song. But it's sounds like some Cascada-knock off, and it's impossible to find knock off shit if you ask me. :lol: Hands off Cascada Mr ^_^
February 9, 200916 yr I'm not going to vote, but I will comment. I like all three groups, but Saturdays have made such an impact on me in such a short time. They are easily my favourite. Based on three listens to the Sats, I'd say it is worse. Only Vulnerable on their album is worse than this for them, they can do much better - but it could really grow on me!
February 9, 200916 yr Walk This Way was a full-scale train wreck with credibility amongst the casualties. Just Can't Get Enough is a minor derailment but there will still have to be an inquiry! It’s hard to tell which track was intended to be the comedy one…
February 9, 200916 yr SO HARD :cry: If this song beats Kelly to #1 i swear i will cry. Edited February 9, 200916 yr by Joao.
February 9, 200916 yr Sugaloud for me. I kinda like both though ... neither are exactly trying to be credible, it's just good fun for comic relief, I do think Sats' will have more appeal though.
February 9, 200916 yr I like both :lol: Can't Get Enough is better than Walk This Way though which was the low point of both girlgroups careers as far as im concerned. Well until Sugababes recorded Girls that is.
February 10, 200916 yr Cant Get Enough by a thousand miles, worst song of the decade so far. Walk Is Way isn't a quarter as bad as people say. I like it :P
February 10, 200916 yr i havnt heard the saturdays yet but i will add for me the best comic relief was right said fred stick it out which was 1994 i think
February 10, 200916 yr girls aloud/sugababes 'walk this way' simply because they trashed a decent song, whereas the sats only ruined an already p*** poor track.
February 10, 200916 yr Walk This Way by a country mile, that song was the musical equivalent of blasphemy, totally destroyed a great original track
February 10, 200916 yr heard the saturdays today and not so keen on it so it got my vote although sugaaloud isnt good either
February 10, 200916 yr They're both pretty bad. I don't get why bands just do covers now for these charity songs. Surely they could get Xenomania or someone to knock out a new tune in about the same time.
Create an account or sign in to comment