surprised at the Mdice/Kathaldazia hate going on :o both tracks are sublime, up there with the BJSC all time greats

Haha, I'm not. :o Some people simply won't like your entry. There are a few fans of Robyn who I'm surprised who have said they don't like it though...hmm, perhaps it's Royksopp.

Haha, I'm not. :o Some people simply won't like your entry. There are a few fans of Robyn who I'm surprised who have said they don't like it though...hmm, perhaps it's Royksopp.

 

it feels more typical Robyn than typical Royksopp to me...I can't fathom how you could like With Every Heartbeat and Dream On but not like The Girl & The Robot!?! All three are beautiful and haunting string-laden pop

Fortunia and Britmasu have very good entries from my semi- along with Spizil.

Thank you :w00t:

I've just listened to The Girl & The Robot again...and I just can't get into it. I just find it okay, nothing that jumps out at me, however Not A Love Song certainly didnt jump out at me, and it won.

 

You see, I'm not a big Robyn fan anyway.

Thank you :w00t:

 

Britmasu might be being a little bit underrated...Mandy Moore hasn't produced anything so good for about 10 years :lol:

Britmasu might be being a little bit underrated...Mandy Moore hasn't produced anything so good for about 10 years :lol:

 

:lol: Actually her covers album was quite good. But I do love ICBYHEDOTW (needs a shorter title though!) :lol:

well, With Every Heartbeat is simply phenominal so i wouldn't rate The Girl and The Robot that high but I think it's on par with Robyn's other singles for being very very good ^_^

Yeah, I haven't really seen members comment on my entry, Mandy's new one, so I was wondering what people were thinking of the song! Didn't seem like people were giving it great odds but I think it's one of her best in a while. Hopefully it qualifies!

 

I'm glad people seem to be liking it though. I hope Britmasu's first entry doesn't totally bomb. :lol:

Edited April 4, 200916 yr by Unusual Me

How can people possibly like that 'Wind It' song?! :lol: It's one of the worst in that semi, I only disliked one song more while voting...

Yeah, I haven't really seen members comment on my entry, Mandy's new one, so I was wondering what people were thinking of the song! Didn't seem like people were giving it great odds but I think it's one of her best in a while. Hopefully it qualifies!

 

I'm glad people seem to be liking it though. I hope Britmasu's first entry doesn't totally bomb. :lol:

 

I can actually see it being a bit of a dark horse...

 

Tom K

How can people possibly like that 'Wind It' song?! :lol: It's one of the worst in that semi, I only disliked one song more while voting...

Uhm, maybe because not everybody has the exact same taste as you.. Seeing you're literally biased to almost everything that's indie or alternative, nobody expected you to like a pop dance song like 'Wind It' .. It's pretty obvious which person will hate which song and which will love it. I'm not suprised at all at the likes of you and Ben not liking Jody, neither will you be suprised at say the likes of Rich or maybe Aled not liking your songs. I get it's just your opinion, but you don't have to go around bashing another person's entry which is liked by those who are more likely to find it appealing because it's more the sort of genre they like, where you obviously won't because it's less the sort of genre you like..

I really like Wind It but theres something missing in chorus which makes me not to give high points :P

Stop revealing your points and make Kath even more sad :(

well we are in semis right...my votes for final will change :P

But still :(

 

And this comes from the one who keep telling Frahliso FTW! :kink:

For every person who hates a song, there is usually someone who either likes or loves it. Kath, I have only listened to the 15 seconds bit in the SF1 recap, but it sounds like it will do well.

I really like Wind It but theres something missing in chorus which makes me not to give high points :P

Oof. Botanikka ftw. :P It is quite a long song and the intro builds and verses do build up the songs appeal more than the chorus, but that's what made me fall inlove with the song to begin with and adds a sort of want to listen to it more and more for the average outside listenener.. One thing is certain though, for a minute 16 year old, her voice does pack quite a punch :lol: <3

 

For every person who hates a song, there is usually someone who either likes or loves it. Kath, I have only listened to the 15 seconds bit in the SF1 recap, but it sounds like it will do well.

I do hope so ey, but comments like ''how can anyone possibly like Wind It'' are a bit worrying and certainly revive what happened to Rich and 'Headhunted' where the love/hate became pretty vocal. But then again there were people bashing Agnes =/

So it could turn out any way, it's just I think it's a bit difficult to predict Jody's result with the vocal response it's received - positive and negative.

I do hope so ey, but comments like ''how can anyone possibly like Wind It'' are a bit worrying and certainly revive what happened to Rich and 'Headhunted' where the love/hate became pretty vocal. But then again there were people bashing Agnes =/

So it could turn out any way, it's just I think it's a bit difficult to predict Jody's result with the vocal response it's received - positive and negative.

 

Like, you said, people came out of the woodwork for Agnes, didnt trouble her. The only reason its getting this response is because it is being put in the limelight as a possible winner. I bet nearly every song in this contest, has people who love, people who hate it. So, I wouldn't panic really...it's only become vocal because of how people think it could win

Oof. Botanikka ftw. :P It is quite a long song and the intro builds and verses do build up the songs appeal more than the chorus, but that's what made me fall inlove with the song to begin with and adds a sort of want to listen to it more and more for the average outside listenener.. One thing is certain though, for a minute 16 year old, her voice does pack quite a punch :lol: <3

I do hope so ey, but comments like ''how can anyone possibly like Wind It'' are a bit worrying and certainly revive what happened to Rich and 'Headhunted' where the love/hate became pretty vocal. But then again there were people bashing Agnes =/

So it could turn out any way, it's just I think it's a bit difficult to predict Jody's result with the vocal response it's received - positive and negative.

 

 

I agree that the verses are :wub:

 

anyway I will be really happy only if I qualify...Haffi stole a lot of Petros fans :arrr: