you can't really compare the two they are so different, opposites in shakira's musical scale both are good at what they do, no doubt HDYD is superior lyrically its a thoughtful and challenging a great fusion song by shakira who is master at combining sounds into one track

 

but i have to choose and so i went for hips too its got alot of dimension for a commmercial track this is not simplistic like many commercial tracks and because of this its hard to get bored of

 

i love the production great use of sample, the way it switches from english to spanish language the contrast of wyclefs and shakira's voice and at 2:28 of the song this wonderful instrumental part is unexpected in the video its the part when shakira dances in white, the subtle political elements of wyclef's rap, this is a classic in the making sounds very good loud...a song for summer very feel good and great to dance to too :yahoo:

Edited June 25, 200620 yr by perfecto

BUMP - Anymore votes before I close this?

Hips Dont Lie..Love It. :D