braindeadpj

Don't forget, without ACR, Rein Me In was also sub-40,000 for the 1 week of Choosing Texas and the 2 weeks (so far) of Great Expectations...

Sales only count as they are, DCL is decided based on streams only, so unless it affects the streaming (unlikely), the sales could be massive (again unlikely), but it'd still go to ACR unless streaming increases.

Wouldn't make any difference unless it affected their streaming as that's all that counts towards ACR.

Without saying what the streams for the No. 1 were at the start of the decade, this sentence is meaningless.

Yes and that's the problem, because there are caveats and the OCC do not make it clear that that is the case and block your comments when you try to bring it up.... and the record can be disputed because of the caveats.

Of course that's again with a caveat as even if you exclude everything that happened pre-2014 to match like with like, Last Christmas has still spent 20 unadjusted, though only 12 adjusted weeks at No.1, while Sam and Olivia are currently on only 15 unadjusted weeks, but 19 adjusted weeks... it does look like they'll add to this on Friday unless something extremely major happens...

That could be another way of looking at it. As I said, there are at least three different 'eras' and it's debatable how much should be allowed to follow through. While the pre-1969 and 1969 to 2014 are at least measuring the same thing (sales by different means), the streaming era essentially measures listens and so is extremely different from the prior two eras.

Except it does change the fact. There is an asterisk on its achievement (perhaps two as a) you're not comparing like with like and b) it's only after artifical manipulation by ACR)

In fact there was no official chart until 1969 when BMRB started compiling it from actual sales instead of points based on the rankings of the dealers and thus the criteria now are completely different (not least the method of completion) from when Frankie Laine first set the record. The 'official' charts are the same in (a wrongly assigned) name only. Also Record Mirror started publishing their chart in 1955 before Melody Maker in 1956 (and DISC in 1958 and Record Retailer in 1960). Record Retailer's chart ran to 50 positions from [almost] the start of 1960 and so was 'deemed' official despite having the smallest reach and smallest number of dealer returns... I personally don't think you can compare records pre- and post-streaming as they are entirely different criteria... and you could even go as far as to say there's three different eras - pre-1969 (points from sales ranking), 1969 to 2014 (sales), 2014+ (sales + streams) that shouldn't be compared, though at least the first two are measuring the same thing but by a different means...

Except it's not... While it may be offically, this is only because the OCC are artifically manipulating the chart. Without any artifical manipulation it's only on 15 weeks and so is not the longest running yet - Last Christmas is. Unfortunately this asterisk is not being applied and it should be, but the OCC are stifling this caveat....

It's worse, only 7 of the Top 40!!!

The OCC did not run the charts in 1953 and there's no such thing as an official chart from 1953 no matter what the OCC want you to think, so no, I disagree. There also was not streaming in 1953 so again it's still a fake overturning of the record as you're not comparing like with like and as Hadji says the record has already been broken by Last Christmas which is on 20 weeks...

They should not be comparing pre and post streaming records as its apples and oranges. It'll also be a fake break of the record if it manages it, as has happened with several other records since ACR was instigated, as it's only at 14 not 18 weeks, without ACR.

So Rein Me In is adding around 4,000 more to its total than Man I Need (based on the last 2 weeks). We have 22 (0r 23 if you go by which year the sales were in) weeks left and its 105,000 behind. If everything stays the same, Man I Need wil remain No.1 by ~17,000 (or 13,000 if you count the chart on 1/1/2027)...

The catalogue number shows which album the sales/streams are being applied to. If the catalogue number is for the 2011 box set and not the debut album, then that is what they're applying it to and NOT the debut album.