Posted November 7, 200915 yr If this had been the top 12 would you have liked this years x factor more or less? GROUPS De-Tour Harmony Hood Project A Over 25's Treyc Cohen Nicole Lawrence Daniel Pearce Boys Ethan Boroian Daniel Fox Duane Lamonte Girls Nicole Jackson Stacey McClean Despina Pilavakis and who would you have supported to win and who do you think would have won? Discuss :o I would have been supporting Treyc and Nicole I think and maybe Harmony Hood. It's hard to say who would have won out of this twelve......it would probably have been one of the boys.
November 7, 200915 yr That would've been a shockingly poor top 12, I reckon Stacey McClean would've won hands down, perhaps Ethan second and Despina third if that was the top 12. Daniel Pearce probably would've done well too. Edited November 7, 200915 yr by nickthenoodle
November 8, 200915 yr that would be SUCH a bad #12, though Louis would have had a better set of groups than he did this year! (bar Ms Frank, ofc). Simon would have the strongest groups, as he does now. Dannii/Cheryl would be the same they are now, with quite talented/pretty irrelevant
November 8, 200915 yr Overs would be x100 better. Boys aswell probably, all 3 that were rejected probably would have been better than Lloyd or Rikki. Groups would still have been weak. Miss Frank were hands down the best group this year. We never really got to see much of those girls really did we, so you know they'd probably have had potential aswell.
November 8, 200915 yr Over 25s and Boys would have been better. The rest FAR worse. Agreed although Ethan was quite weak in singing but his hotness would have guaranteed Top 3 each week :kink:
November 8, 200915 yr what a poor top 12 that would've been! Probably would've been a fight between Ethan (would've been popular with the voters) and Stacey. the Overs and groups would'nt have stood a chance
Create an account or sign in to comment