December 1, 200915 yr Siobhan - dnt remember her at all keisha - 8/10 shes good but ok live like she is so out of tune when she sings about u now! amelle - 9/10 when she wants to be she can be amazing heidi - 7/10 she is good but is horrific when she has to move and sing at the same time mutya - 8/10 like amelle she can be good when she wants to be jade - 9/10 amazing singer lol
December 1, 200915 yr Siobhan - 10/10 absolutely fantasic voice esp New Year / So You Say Amelle - 9.5/10 again fantastic voice really nice tone to it. Mutya - 9/10 similar to Amelles - nice tone to it Jade - 8.5/10 not heard a lot from her but so far strong and pure Keisha - 7/10 strong voice but very whiney at times Heidi - 6.5/10 good voice but very shrill at times
December 2, 200915 yr Shanghai Nobody - 10/10 . Perfect to me. Her solo stuffs just make me loves her more. :wub: Mutya Buena - 9.5/10. Favorite voice of the Babes. Sounds great Keisha Buchanan - 8.5/10. Amelle Berrabah - 9/10. I love her husky voice :P Heidi Range - 8/10. Just good. She likes to use falsetto voice IMO. Jade - 8/10.
December 2, 200915 yr How on earth can you rate Siobhan 1/10? She has the most classy voice out of all of them. :wub:
December 2, 200915 yr Author How on earth can you rate Siobhan 1/10? She has the most classy voice out of all of them. :wub: Someone with sense. Thank you. Some of you are just rating on your favourites, which is not what I asked. Siobhan is a better singer, technically speaking, than Heidi. Her voice has more range and depth to it. How the hell they think Heidi is better is beyond me. She can hold a tune, but she's pretty limited (or so it appears from what we've heard of her). Maybe they haven't heard her 'Ghosts' album. I dunno. But ignore the tone, Siobhan, the music style, etc and listen to how she uses her voice, it's obvious this girl isn't a 1/10. WTF?!
December 2, 200915 yr Surely rating someones voice includes whether you like their tone of voice or not. But 1/10 is stupid no one in the world is a 1/10.
December 2, 200915 yr Someone with sense. Thank you. Some of you are just rating on your favourites, which is not what I asked. Siobhan is a better singer, technically speaking, than Heidi. Her voice has more range and depth to it. How the hell they think Heidi is better is beyond me. She can hold a tune, but she's pretty limited (or so it appears from what we've heard of her). Maybe they haven't heard her 'Ghosts' album. I dunno. But ignore the tone, Siobhan, the music style, etc and listen to how she uses her voice, it's obvious this girl isn't a 1/10. WTF?!Technically Siobhan is excellent. I'm not the biggest siobhan fan, but she got a 9.7 from me just for her sheer talent.
December 2, 200915 yr Author Surely rating someones voice includes whether you like their tone of voice or not. But 1/10 is stupid no one in the world is a 1/10. I was asking on a technical basis though. Someone can have a nice tone but not be a great vocalist. Or you may not like someone's tone, but they could be a terrific vocalist regardless.
December 3, 200915 yr Mutya - 9,5/10 ... Her voice has this amazing quality that convince you she means every word she sings. She has her off days, but in 95% of the cases she is spot-on. Siobhan - 9,5/10 ... Shiv's voice has matured a lot since the early days. She's gotten much much better than she used to be, and her voice has this vulnerability to it which really gets to me sometimes. Keisha - 9/10 ... She's usually spot on, but I think she overdoes the ad-libs. I prefer her lower singing voice. Heidi - 7/10 ... On record she can sound amazing, but live she's inferior to all the other 'babes. Amelle - 8,5/10 ... She's got a nice deep voice and very good control over it. Jade - 8/10 ... In my opinion, she's good, but her voice is very ordinary. I like my 'babes with more unusual voices. She is a great singer, though.
December 3, 200915 yr siobhan 8/10 - Great voices her solo stuff really shows it off mutya 10/10 - Her voice is just fantastic, was listening to some old live stuff and ger bits are always perfect keisha 7/10 - Voice has nice bits to it but can be a bit squeaky heidi 7/10 - I love her voice on record and sometimes live but she really looses it sometimes amelle 8/10 - Love her husky voice but messes up sometimes. I think she could be great jade 9/10 - Technically very good, love her live more than recorded though :cheer:
December 3, 200915 yr Mutya - 9,5/10 ... Her voice has this amazing quality that convince you she means every word she sings. She has her off days, but in 95% of the cases she is spot-on. Even when she quite clearly can;t be arsed she pulls it out the bag :wub:
December 3, 200915 yr Siobhan is a better singer, technically speaking, than Heidi. Her voice has more range and depth to it. How the hell they think Heidi is better is beyond me. She can hold a tune, but she's pretty limited (or so it appears from what we've heard of her). Maybe they haven't heard her 'Ghosts' album. I dunno. But ignore the tone, Siobhan, the music style, etc and listen to how she uses her voice, it's obvious this girl isn't a 1/10. WTF?! If Heidi had solo stuffs too, IMO Siobhan's would be better than Heidi.
December 3, 200915 yr the reson i put 1/10 is because i havnt herd much of her il redo my things after hearing all the babes.. siobhan 7/10 havnt heard much of her but good sound in her voice reli nice tone mutya 8/10 very nice voice and has great vocals keisha 5/10 her voice just isn to my lickin but its ok heidi 7/10 has a great voice but can be screechy at times amelle 9/10 luv her stong voice and great vocals jade 10/10 AMAZING VOCALS and very powerful voice!!!
December 6, 200915 yr * Siobhan Donaghy - 10 * Keisha Buchanan - 7 * Mutya Buena - 7 * Heidi Range - 5 * Amelle Berrabah - 8 * Jade Ewen - 7
December 11, 200915 yr I was asking on a technical basis though. Someone can have a nice tone but not be a great vocalist. Or you may not like someone's tone, but they could be a terrific vocalist regardless. Well not everyone on here are blimmin vocal coaches, and they will take into consideration the tone etc.
December 11, 200915 yr Author Well not everyone on here are blimmin vocal coaches, and they will take into consideration the tone etc. You don't have to be a vocal coach to appreciate a good singer...
December 13, 200915 yr * Siobhan Donaghy - 6 * Keisha Buchanan - 6 * Mutya Buena - 9 * Heidi Range - 7 * Amelle Berrabah - 8 * Jade Ewen - 10
February 8, 201015 yr * Siobhan Donaghy - 8 * Keisha Buchanan - 8 * Mutya Buena - 9 * Heidi Range - 6 * Amelle Berrabah - 10 * Jade Ewen - 10
