Really the only Spice Girl with voal ability worth talking about. The solo career probably wont be getting her any top 40 hits in the UK anytime soon but im glad her & Emma were placed highest of the Spice Girls.

Mel C only #10? :( she's the greatest girlband member of all time! I guess she'd be a lot higher if looks had been factored out...

I know Mel C should be in front of Emma imo, but ahh well. I will reveal a couple more tomorrow

YAY! so pleased Emma is highest! she was honestly the idol of my childhood :D

While Melanie C has my favourite solo Spice Girl single, I much prefer Emma's material on the whole. She has a weaker voice, but her tone appeals to me so much more than Melanie's. Emma's always been the best looking Spice Girl too, the others have certainly improved with age, but Emma was always very pretty. Her personality is a bit too sweet, but she can be honest. Melanie C has always been my least favourite personality wise, for selfish reasons, I reckon we could have got another Spice Girls album if she wasn't too busy trying to be a solo star. (albeit a successful one, at the time)

 

So yeah, happy Emma is the highest Spice Girl. I could never decide if I liked Victoria or Emma better, they've always been my favourite two.

Has Kerry Katona already been?

Has Kerry Katona already been?

 

:lol: yeah she wad #49

And now the joint one...

9. Nicole Scherzinger (The Pussycat Dolls) - [346 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/nicole-scherzinger.jpg

 

The highest Pussycat Doll comes in with 346 points, think she woul be higher if it wasnt for the personality, I do like her but I think she is overated tbh..

 

Appearance = 132

Personality = 84

Voice = 130

Total = 346

 

Also at #9 its

 

9. Kimberley Walsh (Girls Aloud) - [346 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/kimberley-walsh.jpg

 

The Mid placed GA member, exactly where I expected her to be, imo the best looking and best personality, but probably one of the worst vocalists (she came 2nd overall on personality and joint 4th on apperance)

Appearance = 130

Personality = 124

Voice = 92

Total = 346

 

Edited January 27, 201015 yr by Lukuzz

Nicole she should be #1 :angry: (:lol:)

 

Jade better than Nicole? Only on buzzjack :(

 

 

Much love for the Kimba :wub: :wub:

now all we need is Nadie to come higher than Cheryl and everything will be fine :D except for Nicola coming last out of GA :/

 

I think Nicole Scherzinger's appearance is slightly overrated there :kink:

8. Emma Bunton (Spice Girls) - [347 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/emma_bunton.jpg

 

The #1 Spice Girl (although only getting 2 more points than Mel C) Although she is not my personal fave I can see why she is up here, the other 4 have all got 1 or 2 things going for them whilst I think Emma has a bit of all 3..

 

Appearance = 125

Personality = 115

Voice = 107

Total = 347

 

Love Emma Bunton. :wub: Some of her solo stuff was great!

 

LOL @ Jade still to come. Imagine if she was #01 ... :heehee:

Nicole really should have been much lower. Bit stumped that Kimberly is lower than Cheryl though, just hoping Nadine can beat her.

 

Loving Jade in the top 7 :)

7. Jade Ewen (Sugababes) - [352 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/jadeewen.jpg

 

So here she is, the one everyones been talking about, yeah I never expected her to get this high but there is no denying that she is stunning, has an amazing voice and is also very lovely, I'm actually glad she has done this well!

 

Appearance = 117

Personality = 100

Voice = 135

Total = 352

 

 

Only 6 remaining now - 2 Girls Aloud, 2 Destiny's Child, 1 Mis-Teeq and 1 Sugababe!

Jade coming so high after so little time in a girl group is bad. However, she does have all three going for her (like you said).

 

Love that performance on Radio 1 Live Lounge. Harmonies gel really well together and they make the song likeable!

Jade coming so high after so little time in a girl group is bad. However, she does have all three going for her (like you said).

 

Love that performance on Radio 1 Live Lounge. Harmonies gel really well together and they make the song likeable!

 

I know its a great performance

the song's already likeable, it's genius :smoke:

 

shockingly high for Jade, that's a massive score for her voice - not that she's had much chance to really show it off properly on the two Sugababes-by-numbers singles she's featured on so far

I forgot how good Jade was on YCNY, ridiculous to think she was in the bottom 2 the week she sang that :P and that Sugababes Live Lounge is great! I'd forgotten that they were such strong singers. It's a shame they've taken the generic electro-pop route, as much as I liked AAG.