Jump to content

Featured Replies

How can people prefer the utter blandfest that is 'Say It' over 'Rude Boy'?! :mellow:
I think you meant one of two things...

 

Either:

 

'Sell Me Candy' over 'Rude Boy'

OR

'Say It' over 'Fire Bomb'

 

:P

  • Replies 36
  • Views 4.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

 

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

I think you meant one of two things...

 

Either:

 

'Sell Me Candy' over 'Rude Boy'

OR

'Say It' over 'Fire Bomb'

 

:P

Yeah, Say It over Fire Bomb. LOL! :P

 

Say It is so boring. :(

  • 1 month later...

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

Umbrella vs. Mad House (who's gonna choose MH???) easy

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn easy

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard really tough...

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love really tough again

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101 really tough again

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette really tough again

Say It vs. Fire Bomb easy

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs I hate both, Lemme Get That is less terrible

Rehab vs. G4L easy

Question Existing vs. Te Amo :wub: EASYYYYYYY

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song tough again

I prefer Rated R

Edited by Gagafan Goulding

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

 

GGGB: 6

RR: 7

 

Both brilliant albums!

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

 

GGGB - 6, RR 7

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

  • 1 month later...

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

 

GGGB - 6

Rated R - 7

 

:D

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

 

Rated R - 8

GGGB - 5

 

The 2nd half of Rated R is much much stronger than the 2nd half of GGGB :)

 

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

 

GGGB ownage

  • 2 weeks later...

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song (it's a draw) :P

 

So GGGB=5

RR=9

 

I still don't know whether I prefer GGGB or Rated R overall, I think GGGB is just that bit better..
  • 4 weeks later...

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

 

GGGB 8

RR 5

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard VERY close, but 'Hard' was amaaazing live

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L Another REALLY hard one, amongst my faves

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

 

GGGB: 6 /// RR: 7

 

I'd say Rated R is the better album overall.

GGGB has more hits, but Rated R is a more cohesive collection.

Umbrella vs. Mad House

Push Up On Me vs. Wait Your Turn

Don't Stop The Music vs. Hard

Breakin' Dishes vs. Stupid In Love

Shut Up And Drive vs. Rockstar 101

Hate That I Love You vs. Russian Roulette

Say It vs. Fire Bomb

Sell Me Candy vs. Rude Boy

Lemme Get That vs. Photographs

Rehab vs. G4L

Question Existing vs. Te Amo

Good Girl Gone Bad vs. Cold Case Love

Cry vs. The Last Song

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.