Watching Cheryl 'live' on sport relief now and guess what- shes miming!! :o shock horror :lol:

 

ouch! she hit some bad notes there as well

 

She wasn't miming at all :wacko:

How can you say that when it wasn't souding like the CD and you could hear her breathing every now and then?

 

She was fabulous :wub:

That 'The Promise' performance is worse than I remember - Cheryl is shocking at parts and thank god they have Nadine in that group (and Nicola and Sarah to a lesser extent).

:cheer: @ the Sugababes turning their head from side to side!

That would be because the original babes never believed in dance routines. Neither did 2.0. They let the music do the talking.

 

 

Their Greatest Hits tour was purely about the vocals and it was one hell of a show without them having to dance or wear a million costumes.

Ah yes the TOTP performance :wub: Legendary.

 

The girls didn't understand the fuss about them singing live when they first appeared, they thought that everyone could sing live. They broke the mould for pop acts and are partially to blame for the amount of stick artists get for miming. 1.0 refused to appear if they couldn't sing live. :wub:

 

Much like one of my favourite artists, Kelly Llorenna, the white Beverley Knight, except with far less class :lol: Her TOTP performances may have been beyond cringeworthy at times (the raincoat ensemble for Tell It To My Heart :drama:) and she's far from vocally perfect but at least she was always live, unlike the rest of the artists performing on the same evening usually.

You are aware that made no sense whatsoever :mellow: She mimed and yet hit bum notes? :huh:

 

the pre recorded version that she mimed had some bad notes in it

 

like FFTL at the BRITs was mimed, but you could still hear some flat notes in the pre recorded version

the pre recorded version that she mimed had some bad notes in it

 

like FFTL at the BRITs was mimed, but you could still hear some flat notes in the pre recorded version

I'm pretty sure it was live :unsure:

She wasn't miming at all :wacko:

How can you say that when it wasn't souding like the CD and you could hear her breathing every now and then?

 

She was fabulous :wub:

 

im pretty sure it was a pre-recorded version, FFTL at the BRITs wasnt the CD

 

oh well if she wasnt, she still hit some bad notes- looked hot though :naughty:

This wasn't pre-recorded vocals, this was live.

 

Just like the CIN performance of FFTL, people were like "it's too good to be live" but then it appeared to be live because while dancing she forgot to put her mic in front of her mouth at the begining of a sentence and you could hear that is was live and not pre-recorded :P

 

Just accept the fact she's good live.

Wonderful, we get to listen to her singing flat, because it was recorded that way. Wonderful :rolleyes:

 

I would think it sounds awful, because they are singing flat. I prefer acts that sing in key, but if you like bands or singers that are out of key, then that's just fine.

 

Please tell me you are just trying to wind me up and not be musically ignorant!

 

FFS in standard notation, a sharp symbol raises the pitch of the natural note by a half-step; a flat symbol lowers it by a half-step. It is a standard practise for musical acts to harmonise either instrumentally or vocally on either side of the standard notation.

 

For example take a record regarded by many music critics as the greatest record ever made:

 

 

When this was recorded in early 1967 by The Beatles it was deliberately recorded in two takes, the first a deliberately predominantly flat vocal take and secondly recorded deliberately in a predominantly sharp vocal take by John Lennon. That is one of the reasons why it sounds so great today. It just would not sound anywhere near as good if John had recorded his vocal on the natural pitch notation.

 

If you have grown up not being able to appreciate this and have only grown up with the spoon fed vaciousness of reality music talent shows were they are supposed to sing on the natural note and if they don't they get slaughtered (like Diana Vickers or those with much longer memories Susanne Manning did) then I feel sorry for you, as when I hear say a Fleet Foxes record I hear something with stunning vocal harmonies, I think that is tragic if you actually think that makes it a bad record just because they are harmonising properly in natural, flat and sharp notes.

 

I'm pretty sure it was live :unsure:

 

maybe it was live but it looked lip synced

 

anyway, like I said- bad notes

 

maybe it was live but it looked lip synced

 

anyway, like I said- bad notes

I don't think it looked lip-synced either, I was watching to check if she was or not :lol: And I'm not surprised she hit some bad notes tbh, she's not known to have a particularly strong voice, and yet she did all that dancing on top of singing live, so I thought she did a damn good job ^_^

maybe it was live but it looked lip synced

 

anyway, like I said- bad notes

 

Once again there is a contradiction. If it was pre-recorded, surely they would autotune it a tad so there is no 'bad notes'. But then again you're gonna say they leave the bad notes so it sounds "live". But what's the point of pre-recorded vocals if you put bad notes in it? :lol:

 

I've yet to hear those big bad notes though... :naughty:

This wasn't pre-recorded vocals, this was live.

 

Just like the CIN performance of FFTL, people were like "it's too good to be live" but then it appeared to be live because while dancing she forgot to put her mic in front of her mouth at the begining of a sentence and you could hear that is was live and not pre-recorded :P

 

Just accept the fact she's good live.

 

alright already!

 

and no I refuse to accept that 'fact' as it is not a fact, it is your opinion - and from what Ive seen and heard, I do not find her good live

Once again there is a contradiction. If it was pre-recorded, surely they would autotune it a tad so there is no 'bad notes'. But then again you're gonna say they leave the bad notes so it sounds "live". But what's the point of pre-recorded vocals if you put bad notes in it? :lol:

 

I've yet to hear those big bad notes though... :naughty:

 

'down, down' sounded off tune imo

 

 

 

 

Alright, alright, fair enough if some people don't enjoy her performances ^_^

 

This is one of my fav performance of GA on tour, and from 2:50 to end it just shows how Cheryl gives it all performance wise :wub:

 

 

And love the warning "You might have trick me once, I'll never let you trick me twice"... Ashley should have listened to it! :lol:

Alright, alright, fair enough if some people don't enjoy her performances ^_^

 

thank you for saying the right thing

 

thank you for saying the right thing

It only took 3 pages. :lol:

 

Nice to see you Loon down enough to appreciate not everyone likes her vocals Bert

It only took 3 pages. :lol:

 

Nice to see you Loon down enough to appreciate not everyone likes her vocals Bert

 

What's the point of you getting personnal again and calling me a loon? :wacko:

I've always been fine with people not liking her. I remind you it all started when I said something about Sugababes and you couldn't take it so... :huh:

Edited March 19, 201015 yr by Bert for Lashes

Unless i hallucinated you responded to an off the cuff remark i made about Cheryl :mellow:

 

And calling you a loon is hardly personal, your reputation precedes you on BJ

:teresa: I also dislike Leona. She makes me want to go deaf.