Posted May 28, 201015 yr For people seemed to prefer this idea to Texas. Once again, I have placed my faith in the infallible Wikipedia for the list. I have included Identify for it had a video, Scars which WAS going to be a single up until last month, and buzz singles Wild About It, Want, Glorious, Counting Down The Days, Beauty On The Fire, Wishing I Was There and whatever other commercial mishaps Natalie would like to dismiss as a buzz single. Usual rules, score from 0 to 10. You can also have ONE -1, and ONE 11. The list 00 Torn 00 Big Mistake 00 Wishing I Was There 00 Smoke 00 Identify 00 That Day 00 Wrong Impression 00 Beauty On The Fire 00 Shiver 00 Counting Down The Days 00 Glorious 00 Wild About It 00 Want 00 Scars
May 28, 201015 yr Author 09 Torn 11 Big Mistake 07 Wishing I Was There 08 Smoke 06 Identify 04 That Day 10 Wrong Impression 08 Beauty On The Fire 09 Shiver 09 Counting Down The Days 06 Glorious 05 Wild About It 10 Want 06 Scars
May 28, 201015 yr 10 Torn 08 Big Mistake 08 Wishing I Was There 07 Smoke 06 Identify 07 That Day 09 Wrong Impression 07 Beauty On The Fire 10 Shiver 08 Counting Down The Days 09 Glorious 07 Wild About It 09 Want 07 Scars If only we got the original version of Scars... it could have been the best thing on Come To Life by a considerable difference. I think I've been quite harsh with my scoring but when she's great she really is great and I've acknowledged that so... Poor Natalie though. For years she's been such an almost artist. Almost a great album. Almost a high profile artist. Almost top 87 with Want.
May 28, 201015 yr Author Oh I've been harsh aswell - I don't REALLY believe That Day to be a 4/10, but there's no point me giving all the songs 8 or 9s as we'll just end up with every song in a tied position! I don't think I ever heard the original version of Scars, only the acoustic. Is there a link somewhere? Being a blandie, I would class White Lillies Island as a great album but I doubt many would agree! Even the Counting Down The Days album now I think about it - I still wish she'd released Satisfied and Perfectly, even though they'd have clearly been #47 smashes.
May 28, 201015 yr OH GOD ACTUALLY I'm not sure if I prefer Shiver to Torn. I love them both SO MUCH. What to do? Edit: I've brought Torn down to a measly 10. And yes, she performed Scars live in 2008 at some festival after which a clip of the studio version leaked. It had a much better arrangement and melody than the album version. Here: mxzUzWlwEqs
May 28, 201015 yr 06.5 'Torn' 00 'Big Mistake' 00 'Wishing I Was There' 00 'Smoke' 00 'Identify' 00 'That Day' 00 'Wrong Impression' 00 'Beauty On The Fire' 00 'Shiver' 00 'Counting Down The Days' 00 'Glorious' 00 'Wild About It' 10 'Want' 07 'Scars' Edited May 29, 201015 yr by Theo Commander
May 28, 201015 yr Seriously Theo? Not rating 'Shiver' or 'Torn' at least? Please tell me that's because you can't remember them... (although wtf at the thought of that in itself haha :P)
May 28, 201015 yr Theo is like six remember. He wasn't even a sperm when Torn was released.But still. 'Torn' is still played regularly on alot of stations.
May 28, 201015 yr Author It's like one of us not knowing 'Like A Prayer' or 'Heart Of Glass' or whatever. Unfathomable. 'Torn' is a pop classic.
May 28, 201015 yr 10 Torn 08 Big Mistake 09 Wishing I Was There 07 Smoke 05 Identify 10 That Day 08 Wrong Impression 06 Beauty On The Fire 11 Shiver 10 Counting Down The Days 08 Glorious 07 Wild About It 08 Want 06 Scars Oooh I've gone a bit loon-esque havent I. But she has one damn fine back catalogue though. Shiver in particular was the highlight of the first 6 months of 2005. Edit: Theo honestly. You go down more & more in my estimation with each passing day. Someone should buy you Natalie's GH for your birthday.
May 28, 201015 yr 11 Torn 06 Big Mistake 05 Wishing I Was There 07 Smoke 06 Identify 08 That Day 08 Wrong Impression 07 Beauty On The Fire 10 Shiver 10 Counting Down The Days 09 Glorious 07 Wild About It 08 Want 08 Scars
May 28, 201015 yr Author OH GOD ACTUALLY I'm not sure if I prefer Shiver to Torn. I love them both SO MUCH. What to do? Edit: I've brought Torn down to a measly 10. And yes, she performed Scars live in 2008 at some festival after which a clip of the studio version leaked. It had a much better arrangement and melody than the album version. Here: mxzUzWlwEqs OMG what was the silly bitch thinking? That clip sounds absolutely fantastic, why on earth did she change it to the acoustic dreary-athon? It's like every move she makes has been expertly designed to shoot her fading career down in flames.
May 28, 201015 yr 10 Torn 07 Big Mistake 07 Wishing I Was There 06 Smoke ?? Identify 08 That Day 09 Wrong Impression 06 Beauty On The Fire 11 Shiver 08 Counting Down The Days 07 Glorious ?? Wild About It 06 Want 06 Scars
May 28, 201015 yr 11 Torn 07 Big Mistake 10 Wishing I Was There 08 Smoke 07 Identify 08 That Day 09 Wrong Impression 10 Beauty On The Fire 10 Shiver 08 Counting Down The Days 05 Glorious 07 Wild About It 09 Want 08 Scars
May 28, 201015 yr I know right, Shoat? Truly shocking. And Jonjo, I don't think Adam ALLOWS .5s - if he does then I'd like to go back and re-do my Corrs rate JUST BECAUSE.
May 29, 201015 yr Author I have no problems with .5s. Jark, you may re-edit The Corrs votes, but it won't make any difference because I'm not going back!
May 29, 201015 yr Seriously Theo? Not rating 'Shiver' or 'Torn' at least? Please tell me that's because you can't remember them... (although wtf at the thought of that in itself haha :P) lulz. When 'Want' was out, Aled told me to listen to loads of her previous material, and I found it all quite boring. :(
May 29, 201015 yr oh shame I'd much prefer a Texas rate :( 10 Torn 09 Big Mistake 08 Wishing I Was There 11 Smoke ?? Identify 05 That Day 09 Wrong Impression 08 Beauty On The Fire -1 Shiver ?? Counting Down The Days 08 Glorious ?? Wild About It 06 Want 08 Scars
Create an account or sign in to comment