Insatiable all the way! 'Promise This' is good, but not a patch on the orgasmic track that is Insatiable!!!! :D

I like both, but I love Insatiable.

Where's the both are mediocre option?

I am not keen on Nadine as a person but i have to say Insatiable is so much better then Promise This.

Insaitable, as it's orignial and still pop, Cheryl sounds like those hip-hop wannabies. Sorry cheryl fans but she's not cool at all.

Promise This

 

Insatiable is nothing new and after SO long away, Nadine should have come back with something better.

I'm not exactly a Cheryl lover, but at least she's done something different to Girls Aloud with both albums..

I really like both, but 'Promise This' has the edge for me :)

Insatiable blows chunks on Promise This, even though it's kind of catchy.

 

I hope these two mud wrestle on X-Factor :)

I've gotta say Insatiable. I love both, but Insatiable edges it imo!

wouldnt it be good (as if cheryl would allow it) if the second week on x factor was Girls Aloud songs and Cheryl and Nadine both performed. If Nadine is out the week after it would be good, i suspect Nadine will do strictly the week before her release?!

wouldnt it be good (as if cheryl would allow it) if the second week on x factor was Girls Aloud songs and Cheryl and Nadine both performed. If Nadine is out the week after it would be good, i suspect Nadine will do strictly the week before her release?!

 

I was actually thinking they should do this.

Maybe a girl group theme though, not specifically Girls Aloud.

 

Really would love Nadine to get an X Factor slot, it would be the perfect way to launch her solo career! Also really happy that she's winning this poll :dance:

Insatiable all the way

Insatiable <3

Im not a huge fan of either song at the moment but both are growers but i prefer insatiable.

Nadine vs. Cheryl - Cheryl [insatiable 0 - 1 Promise This]

No Sample vs. Sample - Sample [insatiable 0 - 2 Promise This]

Nadine's vocals vs. Cheryl's vocals - Nadine's vocals [insatiable 1 - 2 Promise This]

Insatiable sounds dated vs. Promise This sounds strange - Promise This sounds strange [insatiable 1 - 3 Promise This]

Music built from scratch vs. Music built around a sample - Music built from scratch [insatiable 2 - 3 Promise This]

Insatiable lyrics vs. Promise This lyrics - Promise This lyrics [insatiable 2 - 4 Promise This]

 

 

Well I guess it's Promise This from me. I admit I think it has less quality than Insatiable, but Insatiable keeps sounding so dated to me I'm getting bored of it.

 

But overall it's My Wicked Heart for me.

How is a use of a sample a winnning point? :unsure:

How is a use of a sample a winnning point? :unsure:

 

For me it is. In this particular case anyway.

Waiting for Nadine's video before a final decision, but having seen Cheryl's video, she's well in front for me at the moment.

do this poll again and im sure cheryl would win now everyone is addicted to her song!

I'm not, 'Insatiable' is still leaps and bounds better and I'm glad it's the rightful winner here. ^_^