October 21, 201014 yr What does Treyc have in common with Danyl Johnson, I cannot even think of one thing. Purple rain. (I can't remember but he might have done One too? Unless i'm thinking of someone else?) Token long notes all the time. (overdone) Voice but nothing endearing in the personality. To name but a few. :)
October 21, 201014 yr Purple rain. (I can't remember but he might have done One too? Unless i'm thinking of someone else?) Token long notes all the time. (overdone) Voice but nothing endearing in the personality. To name but a few. :) The terms clutching at straws and scrapping the barrel for similarities spring to mind.They sound nothing alike and their personalities are nothing alike. To name a few :P Edited October 21, 201014 yr by marrb
October 21, 201014 yr Cher Rebecca Matt Treyc Aiden Belle Aime Paige Mary Wagner 1 Direction John Katie
October 22, 201014 yr The terms clutching at straws and scrapping the barrel for similarities spring to mind.They sound nothing alike and their personalities are nothing alike. To name a few :P Exactly, neither of them have personalities. That's part of my point. Their sound is very similar it's shown in them singing two of the same songs as each other. Each week Danyul had a token long/high note with his mouth WIDE open, over singing songs (some of which are meant to be soft, subtle, poigniant songs). Treyc, so far has had a token long/high notes on each song, with her mouth WIDE open, over singing songs (some of which are meant to be soft, subtle, poigniant songs) It's just my opinion. It's not clutching at straws when there is striking similarites and I never stated it as fact, it's a thought that ran through MY head. ;)
October 23, 201014 yr Cher - Original and I am really excited to hear what she would produce as an artist :heart: Aiden - Genuinely mental but mesmerising Mary - Very emotional despite essentially being a pub singer Matt - Has had the best selection of songs so far and nailed them, he is as dull as dishwasher however and would be a flop winner Treyc - Really wanted her through but as yet is not distinctive enough Rebecca - Very pleasent but I haven't been blown away as yet Paige - The best is yet to come... I hope Katie - The most annoying person ever, so up herself but at times entertaining. Belle Aime - The bitchiness is the only thing memorable about them so far. If they're gonna be a serious group they need to geta style of their own 1 Direction - Cute but really just terrible, I think JLS and The Wanted have all spectrums covered with regards to boybands Wagner - Not even funny. John - Who?
October 23, 201014 yr I think it's quite clear that TreyC has personality. What an odd accusation. Anyway my ranking: Treyc - QUEEN OF LIFE Aiden - I absolutely worship him. Such beauty. Such vulnerability. I want to spoon him. FOREVER Mary - She has such PRESENCE on stage. She's quite majestic! Clearly not going to win but I'm now glad she made it through and I'm sure she'll have some sort of career out of this. Cher - Needs to avoid becoming a one trick pony but to my surprise her perf of Just Be Good To Me was actually quite fantastic. And she CAN hold a note well enough. Katie - she's been very solid so far and I love her voice but the song choices need to improve. Matt - I'm sure he's a nice guy but I'm put off by the fact that he seems old before his time. However the When Love Takes Over perf WAS amazing and won me round a bit. Rebecca - hopefully the best is still to come. She has no personality though and not much stage presence either so I don't have high hopes, but her tone of voice is pretty. 1 Direction - quite endearing and most of them seem to be able to sing decently (except for the Asian one, but he's cute as hell so it's okay) Paije - He's not going much further. He probably looks the least professional on stage - Brian Friedman must have a nightmare of a time trying to choreograph him! Belle Amie - I've only put them this far up the list by default though. They were so good at boot camp that it really is shocking how poor they've been in the live shows so far. John - Crushingly dull Wagner - Vom Overall it's a pretty strong bunch I reckon. If my top 4 there were to make the final 6 along with 1 Direction and Matt then I reckon it could be anybody's for the win.
October 23, 201014 yr I think it's quite clear that TreyC has personality. What an odd accusation. Anyway my ranking: Treyc - QUEEN OF LIFE Just because you're loving her doesn't make my opinion wrong :rolleyes: I know nothing about her, I just remember whinging about cher and katie not being her BFF's.
October 23, 201014 yr Wow, you need to get over the fact that people can have conflicting opinions. I think it's odd that you think she has no personality. DEAL.
October 23, 201014 yr 01. Matt Cardle / 04-03-03-01- 02. Rebecca Ferguson / 07-07-02-02- 03. Aiden Grimshaw / 02-01-07-03- 04. Treyc Cohen / 02-04-04- 05. Cher Lloyd / 03-04-09-05- 06. Katie Waissel / 12-13-13-06- 07. Bell Amie / 01-08-01-07- 08. One Direction / 05-09-05-08- 09. Mary Byrne / 08-05-06-09- 10. Paije Richardson / 06-08-10- 11. John Adeleye / 06-11-10-11- 12. Wagner / 16-14-12- --- Nicolo Festa / 11-10-x F.Y.D. / 09-12-x Storm Lee / 10-14-11- Diva Fever / 15-12-
October 23, 201014 yr After the 3rd live show: 01. Matt Cardle [2-1] 02. Aiden Grimshaw [3-2] 03. Katie Waissel [12-3] 04. Mary Byrne [4-4] 05. Cher Lloyd [16-5] 06. Wagner Carrilho [5-6] 07. Rebecca Ferguson [7-7] 08. Treyc Cohen [14-8] 09. John Adeleye [13-9] 10. Paije Richardson [15-10] 11. One Direction [9-11] 12. Belle Amie [7-12] OUT Storm Lee [1-OUT] F.Y.D [6-OUT] Diva Fever [10-OUT] Nicolò [11-OUT]
October 23, 201014 yr 01 01 Matt 02 02 Cher 03 05 Katie 04 06 Wagner 05 03 One Direction 06 08 Rebecca 07 10 Aiden 08 07 Mary 09 04 Belle Amie 10 09 TreyC 11 12 Paije 12 11 John :zzz: Edited October 23, 201014 yr by chart wizard
October 23, 201014 yr 01. Matt 02. Cher 03. Paije 04. Katie 05. Mary 06. TrayC 07. Rebecca 08. Belle Amie 09. Aiden 10. One Direction 11. John 12. Wagner
October 23, 201014 yr THIS WEEKS 01. Katie Waissel (11-8-3-1) :cheer: Av: 6 02. Mary Byrne (2-1-2-2) Av: 2 03. Matt Cardle (1-2-1-3) Av: 2 04. John Adelaye (4-7-4-4) Av:5 05. Paije Richardson (X-10-7-5) Av: 7 06. Rebecca Ferguson (5-12-8-6) Av: 8 07. One Direction (10-16-9-7) Av: 11 08. Treyc Cohen (X-9-6-8) Av: 8 09. Belle Amie (6-15-11-9) Av:10 10. Cher Lloyd (8-6-12-10) Av: 9 11. Wagner (X-14-14-11) Av: 13 12. Aiden Grimshaw (12-5-13-12) Av: 11 OUT Diva Fever (X-11-10) Av: 11 out of 14 Storm Lee (7-4-5) Av: 6 out of 14 FYD (9-13) Av: 11 out of 16 Nicolo Festa (3-3) Av: 3 out of 16 Edited October 23, 201014 yr by Leonardo2505
October 23, 201014 yr 01. Matt Cardle / 04-03-03-01- 02. Rebecca Ferguson / 07-07-02-02- 03. Aiden Grimshaw / 02-01-07-03- 04. Treyc Cohen / 02-04-04- 05. Cher Lloyd / 03-04-09-05- 06. Katie Waissel / 12-13-13-06- 07. Bell Amie / 01-08-01-07- 08. One Direction / 05-09-05-08- 09. Mary Byrne / 08-05-06-09- 10. Paije Richardson / 06-08-10- 11. John Adeleye / 06-11-10-11- 12. Wagner / 16-14-12- --- Nicolo Festa / 11-10-x F.Y.D. / 09-12-x Storm Lee / 10-14-11- Diva Fever / 15-12- exactly the same has this
October 23, 201014 yr Matt Cher One Direction Paije Rebecca TreyC Belle Amie John Mary Aiden Katie Wagner 5/5, 4/5, 3/5, 2/5, 1/5 :zzz: I look forward to Cher's performance most and always enjoy Matt's vocal.
October 24, 201014 yr 1 1 Matt Cardle (even if he was a little weird for me tonight) 2 3 Paije Richardson (:wub: To quote some whore, no regrets, just love.) 3 4 Rebecca Ferguson (I finally got her tonight, I've thought she was good but personality free for awhile) 4 5 TreyC Cohen (gurl is FIERCE :heart:) 5 2 Mary Byrne (disappointed in her for doing the audition song again, have they really run out of torch songs) 6 6 Katie Waissel (I don;t like that song much, but she pulled it off and FINALLY showed some personality) 7 8 Wagner (I know, I know, but he's growing on me like a WEED) 8 7 Belle Amie (not as good as GA) 9 10 John Adeleye (Zoom is :wub: John is :zzz:) 10 11 1 Direction (I hate them, but they did Pink justice, and were less vile than the two below0 11 10 Cher Lloyd :puke2: 12 12 Aiden Grimshaw :wacko:
October 24, 201014 yr New ranking after last night: 1. Aiden 2. Treyc 3. Rebecca 4. Mary 5. Matt 6. Katie 7. Cher 8. Paije 9. One Direction 10. John 11. Belle Amie 12. Wagner Edited October 24, 201014 yr by Mattias
October 24, 201014 yr Author 1. Rebecca Ferguson (5-5-3-1) 2. Aiden Grimshaw (4-4-2-2) 3. Matt Cardle (6-8-4-3) 4. One Direction (2-2-1-4) 5. Mary Byrne (10-9-7-5) 6. Cher Lloyd (1-1-5-6) 7. Belle Amie (3-3-6-7) 8. John Adeleye (7-13-10-8) 9. Paije Richardson (10-11-9) 10. Katie Waissel (12-15-12-10) 11. TreyC Cohen (6-9-11) 12. Wagner (16-14-12) F.Y.D (8-7) Nicolo Festa (9-11) Storm Lee (11-14-13) Diva Fever (12-8)
October 24, 201014 yr My ranking for last night: 1. Rebecca Ferguson 2. Matt Cardle 3. Katie Waissel 4. TreyC Cohen 5. Aiden Grimshaw 6. Mary Byrne 7. Cher Lloyd 8. One Direction 9. Paije Richardson 10. John Adeleye 11. Belle Amie 12. Wagner (but I :wub: him...he's hilarious)
October 24, 201014 yr After last night's performances - 1. Rebecca (1-1-1-1-1) Still my #1 but she really needs to improve! 2. TreyC (2-2-2-2) VERY close to being my fave now.. 3. Cher (2-5-3-3-3) I want to see her just sing for once, but she is still great 4. Mary (3-4-5-4-4) Needs to change it up a bit but love her anyways 5. Paije (8-8-7) He was brilliant last night imo, improving every week 6. Aiden (5-3-3-5-5) Going off him a bit, but he's still very good 7. One Direction (6-6-6-6-6) They seem to be slowly turning into a mini westlife, they need better songs! 8. Matt (8-11-10-9-8) I'm liking him more and more, but still hasn't wowed me yet! 9. Wagner (12-11-11-9) I still find him very entertaining, I wanna see him sing a slow song though. 10. Belle Amie (7-14-12-13-11) A huge improvement last night, proved they can actually sing 11. Katie (11-13-13-12-10) She doesn't annoy me as much as she used to, but she aint good. 12. John (12-16-14-14-12) Last night he was vocally very good, but awful song choice and so boring Edited October 24, 201014 yr by Lukuzz
Create an account or sign in to comment