October 24, 201014 yr Okay, starting from week 3 :naughty: 01 Matt Cardle 02 Treyc Cohen 03 Mary Byrne 04 Katie Waissel 05 Rebecca Ferguson 06 Diva Fever 07 Belle Amie 08 Cher Lloyd 09 Wagner 10 Paije Richardson 11 Storm Lee 12 John Adeleye 13 One Direction 14 Aiden Grimshaw 15 F.Y.D. 16 Nicolo Festa Edited October 24, 201014 yr by Mason
October 24, 201014 yr 1 - Katie Waissel (5-2-1) 2 - Rebecca Ferguson (1-1-2) 3 - Belle Amie (2-3-3) 4 - Paije Richardson (3-7-4) 5 - Mary Byrne (4-5-5) 6 - Aiden Grimshaw (11-13-6) 7 - Wagner (8-6-7) 8 - John Adeleye (12-9-8) 9 - Cher Lloyd (9-4-9) 10 - Matt Cardle (6-8-10) 11 - Treyc Cohen (10-12-11) 12 - One Direction (16 [last] -14 [last] -12 [last]) OUT Diva Fever (13-10) Storm Lee (7-11)
October 24, 201014 yr Overall ranking after week 3: 01 (01) Rebecca Ferguson 02 (02) Matt Cardle 03 (03) Mary Byrne 04 (04) TreyC Cohen 05 (06) Belle Amie 06 (05) Cher Lloyd 07 (08) Katie Waissel 08 (10) Aiden Grimshaw 09 (09) 1 Direction 10 (11) Paije Richardson 11 (12) Wagner OUT: 07 John Adeleye
October 24, 201014 yr Wow, you need to get over the fact that people can have conflicting opinions. I think it's odd that you think she has no personality. DEAL. Practice what you preach -_- OH and, she even said herself tonight she doesn't have a "great personality".
October 24, 201014 yr No she didn't. When did she say 'I don't have a great personality'? Anyway my current ranking probably goes something like this... 01 TreyC 02 Cher 03 Aiden 04 Katie 05 Matt 06 Paije 07 Mary 08 1 Direction 09 Rebecca 10 Belle Amie 11 Wagner That's a seriously good top 7.
October 24, 201014 yr 01 Rebecca 02 Cher 03 Aiden 04 TreyC 05 Paije 06 Matt 07 Mary - 08 1 Direction 09 Wagner 10 Belle Amie 11 Katie (she's talented, but my GOD she's by far the most unlikeable contestant ever to come out of the X Factor) I concur with Jark - there are definitely seven proper stand-outs this year. However, I can't really pick a favourite easily...
October 24, 201014 yr 01. Matt 02. Aiden 03. Rebecca (I don't think she's come close to proving just HOW good she can be yet though) 04. Wagner - YES it's a bandwagon joke vote, but he's not as punchable as Jedward 05. Mary 06. TreyC ----------- 07. Katie 08. Paije ----------- 09. One Direction 10. Belle Amie 11. Cher Lloyd I don't think I'm EVER going to be a Cher Lloyd fan I'm afraid. I just find something DEEPLY unpleasant about her; from that AWFUL snarl of hers, to her chavved up attitude, to her see-through attempts to style herself as Mini Cherly, to her claiming credit for writing and composing tracks that are already YEARS old. The rapping is passable but not exceptional, the singing dreadful. A second rate Alesha Dixon for 2010, just without any semblance of likability. Simon and Cherly proclaiming her to be the future of music does NOT help matters, because if they're right, we're all buggered. I'm also REALLY not feeling the groups right now. Belle Amie's acting like c**ts at this early stage does NOT suggest they'll be setting the world alight anytime soon, espcially if they also insist on being so mediocre on stage. One Direction are another act I'm just destined NEVER to like being essentially Bieber x 5. Last night was particularly dreadful; they need to stop entrusting solo sections and ad libs to Ethnic One, who really is f***ing ATROCIOUS. All over the place and incapable of keeping in tune. He should stand there, look pretty, and THAT'S IT. On a positive note, Paije and Katie are improving every week and could easily join the series leaders if they carry on like that. I never expected that Paije would be one of the highlights last night.
October 24, 201014 yr Yes, Paije pulled out the big guns last night in a way I don't think anybody expected, but then the song choice was pretty inspired and the arrangement was gorgeous. I think if I download anything from the three shows so far that will be it (along perhaps with Aiden's Mad World). I don't agree about Rebecca sadly. She has absolutely zero personality - less than zero. Now it's a talent contest but that lack of personality translates into an equal lack of stage presence which makes her performances stone bore central. I find my eyes wandering from the TV and I don't with the others. She's got the voice but she's no star. I'd rather have Cher or Katie's attitude (which actually I quite like) than Rebecca's total lack of.
October 24, 201014 yr Yes, Paije pulled out the big guns last night in a way I don't think anybody expected, but then the song choice was pretty inspired and the arrangement was gorgeous. I think if I download anything from the three shows so far that will be it (along perhaps with Aiden's Mad World). I don't agree about Rebecca sadly. She has absolutely zero personality - less than zero. Now it's a talent contest but that lack of personality translates into an equal lack of stage presence which makes her performances stone bore central. I find my eyes wandering from the TV and I don't with the others. She's got the voice but she's no star. I'd rather have Cher or Katie's attitude (which actually I quite like) than Rebecca's total lack of. I've downloaded Paije's Killing Me Softly (say what you will, but I LOVED the arrangement), Rebecca's Why Don't You Do Right? (proper jazzy confection), and the ever sexual Diamonds Are Forever. WONDERFUL. On the latter point, I'd say she's slowly coming out of her shell. Goodness knows she's no Cher when it comes to attitude but I'd say she's at a Leona level - obviously not the most exciting of people but the talent's good enough to make up for it.
October 24, 201014 yr Quite. Leona is proof that personality, whilst useful, isn't QUITE necessary. It will be a hindrance performing live obviously, but Rebecca having no stage presence isn't going to stop her sounding pretty damn amazing on a record. Which is why I totally disagree with Jark's "personality over voice" comment. When it comes to buying records or listening on the radio, I know which one out of Rebecca and Cher I'm more likely to favour.
October 24, 201014 yr 01 TreyC (01-05-01) 02 Katie (06-02-02) 03 Rebecca (01-01-03) 04 Belle Amie (04-03-04 05 Matt (07-04-05) 06 Cher (09-07-06) 07 Aiden (03-08-07) 08 Mary (05-06-08) 09 Paije (08-12-09) 10 John (13-10-10) 11 Wagner (11-13-11) 12 One Direction (12-11-12) I didn't think anyone was particularly amazing this week tbh :(.
October 24, 201014 yr I don't agree about Rebecca sadly. She has absolutely zero personality - less than zero. Now it's a talent contest but that lack of personality translates into an equal lack of stage presence which makes her performances stone bore central. I find my eyes wandering from the TV and I don't with the others. She's got the voice but she's no star. I'd rather have Cher or Katie's attitude (which actually I quite like) than Rebecca's total lack of. Yes, Rebecca just doesn't engage me at all. Cher is not the best singer but She commands attention with her stage presence and attitude. I look forward to seeing Cher's performance most as a result.
October 25, 201014 yr 1 One Direction (1-1-1-1) 2 Katie Waissel (5-2-2-2) 3 Matt Cardle (4-6-4-3) 4 Mary Byrne (8-5-3-4) 5 Treyc (xx-3-5-5) 6 Wagner (xx-10-7-6) 7 Cher Lloyd (6-4-6-7) 8 Aiden Grimshaw (7-7-8-8) 9 Rebecca Ferguson (10-11-10-9) 10 Belle Amie (2-8-9-10) 11 Paije (xx-12-12-11) ----------------------------------- OUT 11 John Adeleye
October 25, 201014 yr 1. Rebecca (1-1-1-1-1-1) 2. TreyC (2-2-2-2-2) Can't believe she was in the bottom 2! 3. Cher (2-5-3-3-3-3) 4. Mary (3-4-5-4-4-4) 5. Paije (8-8-7-5) 6. Aiden (5-3-3-5-5-6) 7. One Direction (6-6-6-6-6-7) 8. Matt (8-11-10-9-8-8) 9. Belle Amie (7-14-12-13-11-10) 10. Wagner (12-11-11-9-9) 11. Katie (11-13-13-12-10) Out - John (12-16-14-14-12-12)
October 25, 201014 yr No she didn't. When did she say 'I don't have a great personality'? Anyway my current ranking probably goes something like this... 01 TreyC 02 Cher 03 Aiden 04 Katie 05 Matt 06 Paije 07 Mary 08 1 Direction 09 Rebecca 10 Belle Amie 11 Wagner That's a seriously good top 7. xtra factor lovely. xx
October 25, 201014 yr 03. Rebecca (I don't think she's come close to proving just HOW good she can be yet though) Totally agree.
October 25, 201014 yr 01 Rebecca 02 Wagner 03 Treyc 04 Tesco Mary 05 Aidan 06 Matt 07 Paije 08 Wand Erection 09 Belle Amie 10 Cher 11 Katie As much as I wanted to I couldnt bring myself to put Wagner at #1 but still, him very much so for the win. I actually really like my top 8 at the moment, and the bottom 2 I no longer hate *that* much.
October 25, 201014 yr 01 Matt 02 One Direction 03 Katie 04 Belle Amie 05 Aidan 06 Tesco Mary 07 Cher 08 Treyc 09 Rebecca 10 Paige 11 Wagner
October 27, 201014 yr 01 Rebecca 02 Wagner 03 Tesco Mary the rest are rubbish (hahah - the top3 are rubbish too just a little more bearable) 04 Katie 05 Treyc 06 Paige 07 Matt 08 Aidan 09 Belle Amie 10 Cher 11 One Direction
October 27, 201014 yr So, a bit late, but here are my ranking for last Saturday show : 01 (01) Rebecca Ferguson [01-01-01-01] 02 (04) Katie Waissel [05-03-04-02] 03 (03) Cher Lloyd [02-02-03-03] 04 (08) Aiden Grimshaw [07-07-08-04] 05 (10) Mary Byrne [06-05-10-05] 06 (02) Matt Cardle [11-11-02-06] 07 (07) Belle Amie [04-10-07-07] 08 (05) Treyc [**-06-05-08] 09 (09) Paije [**-04-09-09] 10 (13) Wagner [**-14-13-10] 11 (14) 1Direction [12-15-14-11] 12 (12) John Adeleye [09-13-12-12] Diva Fever [**-09-06-OUT] Storm Lee [08-12-11-OUT] F.Y.D [10-16-OUT] Nicolo Festa [03-08-OUT] Edited October 27, 201014 yr by Bert for Lashes
Create an account or sign in to comment