November 14, 201014 yr watched tonight's performances out of curiousity. I couldn't resist. :( my ranking: 01: katie - the hate is despicable, this girl has something. 02: aiden - he's got a great voice, and I think he's vocally stronger than joe tbh. plus he's blackpublian so eh. :kink: 03: cher - more versatile than I thought, I like her a lot. -- 04: matt - great singer, if not a bit overrated. don't like his personality though. 05: mary - once again, great vocalist, but I feel she's kind of out of place on the show, she reminds me a whole lot like subo. 06: paije - has his good moments, but can bore me. -- 07: one direction - very overrated by the public. just remind me of JLS only they're younger, so they're probably going to attract more screamy annoying little girl fans if they go far. :( 08: rebecca - just WHAT is the appeal with her? her voice is just average and samey, not to mention she has hardly any personality in her, plus she looks like a sardine. -- 09: wagner - just gtfo already. Ill second all of that :P
November 14, 201014 yr I've only just started doing this :( Based on last night's show 1 1 Matt Cardle 2 3 Cher Lloyd 3 8 Mary Byrne 4 2 Paije Richardson 5 6 One Direction 6 7 Wagner Fiuza-Carrilho 7 10 Katie Waissel 8 5 Rebecca Ferguson 9 9 Aiden Grimshaw OUT: 4 Treyc Cohen I didn't actually rank Katie last week as I couldn't offer an unbised viewpoint, but I've listed her as being 10th last week anyway. I was totally unbiased this week in regards to her, and found her performance better than Rebecca and Aiden, not taking her personality into account at all. And yes, I've put Rebecca 8th, as I preferred 7 of the other 8 contestants. I appreciate Rebecca has an outstanding voice but I wasn't hearing it on this performance, she sounded like she was mumbling for some of it :unsure: And this performance was even more boring than she normally is. Rebecca can be good if she wants to be, but this performance just didn't do it for me I'm afraid. Edited November 14, 201014 yr by Bray
November 14, 201014 yr 1 1 Matt Cardle (just realised how much he sounds like James Dean Bradfield :o ) 2 2 Paije Richardson (why all the hate again? :( Great performance, not the perfect performance, but he can actually sing as well as being fun) 3 3 Rebecca Ferguson (Beautiful vocals again, but kind of bland) 4 6 Mary Byrne (back to her usual form :wub: Yes, she's a one trick pony, but a talented one) 5 7 1 Direction (Maybe it's because ones I like have gone out, but they seem a little better this week, they were kind of in harmony :o) 6 9 Aiden Grimshaw (Should have done Sacrifice, but I'm starting to see what others see in him. Apart from the sexy.) 7 8 Katie Waissel (Totally by default this. Totally boring performance. I'm sure some members of Belle Amie were amongst her backup dancers.) 8 9 Wagner (He was actually fun this week, which is more than could be said for the lady below...) 9 5 Cher Lloyd (:manson: really. Pure karaoke. And cheating bitch to use an Eminem song. Stay showed so much promise, what happened?) OUT 4 TreyC Cohen
November 14, 201014 yr Rebecca Ferguson [3-1-3-2-2-1] Aiden Grimshaw [1-3-2-5-1-2] Cher Lloyd [10-11-8-1-5-3] Mary Byrne [2-2-1-3-4-4] Paije Richardson [9-4-5-4-3-5] Wagner Fiuza-Carrilho [4-9-6-10-8-6] Katie Waissel [13-10-9-8-10-7] One Direction [14-7-11-7-7-8] Matt Cardle [12-12-8-11-9-9] OUT: Treyc Cohen [8-5-4-6-6-OUT] Belle Amie [6-6-10-9-OUT] John Adeleye [15-13-14-[OUT] Diva Fever [11-8-OUT] Storm Lee [16-14-OUT] FYD [7-OUT] Nicolò Festa [5-OUT] The top 3 were definitely the standouts last night, but I hope Paije can last at least a few more weeks. Looking unlikely though! Even though Katie's performance was definitely the worst, I'd still rather see her next week over Matt and One Direction. Edited November 14, 201014 yr by 152chris
November 14, 201014 yr After last nights - 1. Rebecca (1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1) Another amazing performance 2. Cher (2-5-3-3-3-3-3-2-2-2) Her 2nd best performance yet after 'Stay' imo 3. One Direction (6-6-6-6-6-7-7-5-4-3) Their best ever performance last night! 4. Matt (8-11-10-9-8-8-8-7-5-4) Growing on me very week, sang well 5. Paije (8-8-7-5-5-6-8-7) Not the best song choice, but sang it good 6. Mary (3-4-5-4-4-4-4-4-6-5) Losing her spark and sounding a bit out of tune :down:7. Aiden (5-3-3-5-5-6-6-8-7-6) Horrible rendition of Rocket Man imo 8. Wagner (12-11-11-9-9-10-10-9-8) Still slightly funny, but its wearing thin now 9. Katie (11-13-13-12-10-11-9-10-9) Absolutley abysmal, how does she keep getting worse? The Top 4 are miles ahead of the others, Katie needs to f*** off!
November 14, 201014 yr 1 One Direction (1-1-1-1-1-2-1) 2 Matt Cardle (4-6-4-3-2-1-2) 3 Katie Waissel (5-2-2-2-4-4-3) 4 Wagner (xx-10-7-6-6-5-4) 5 Rebecca Ferguson (10-11-10-9-8-3-5) 6 Mary Byrne (8-5-3-4-3-7-6) 7 Cher Lloyd (6-4-6-7-5-6-7) 8 Paije (xx-12-12-11-9-8-8) ----------------------------------- OUT Aiden Grimshaw
November 14, 201014 yr Can't believe Katie is still here, but whatever :puke2: :right:1. Rebecca (1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1) 2. Cher (2-5-3-3-3-3-3-2-2-2-2) 3. One Direction (6-6-6-6-6-7-7-5-4-3-3) 4. Matt (8-11-10-9-8-8-8-7-5-4-4) 5. Paije (8-8-7-5-5-6-8-7-5) 6. Mary (3-4-5-4-4-4-4-4-6-5-6) 7. Wagner (12-11-11-9-9-10-10-9-8-8) 8. Katie (11-13-13-12-10-11-9-10-9-9) Out: Aiden (5-3-3-5-5-6-6-8-7-6-7)
November 14, 201014 yr Overall rates: Week 1 - 6 01. Rebecca Furguson [54 pts] 02. Matt Cardle [50 pts] 03. Mary Byrne [41 pts] 04. Cher Lloyd [39 pts] 05. Paije Richardson [34 pts] 06. Katie Waissel [30 pts] 07. One Direction [29 pts] 08. Wagner [18 pts] OUT: Aiden
November 14, 201014 yr Rate: Cher One Direction Matt Paije Katie Rebecca Aiden Mary Wagner Verdict this week: BLAH. The usual stood out. She has a technically strong voice but her tone does nothing whatsoever for me. Combine that with the fact that she's dull as dishwater, has zero stage presence and comes out with the same old crap every week about 'really starting to come out of her shell now' etc and that's why I want her gone.Agree :lol:. The praise from judges is generous too. ''You're Like A Diva'' says Louis while She stands hunched with her head down. I like her modesty but her Performances bore me.
November 15, 201014 yr Author Rebecca Ferguson (5-5-3-1-3-2-1) Matt Cardle (6-8-4-3-2-1-2) One Direction (2-2-1-4-1-3-3) Cher Lloyd (1-1-5-6-4-5-4) Mary Byrne (10-9-7-5-6-7-5) Paije Richardson (10-11-9-7-6-6) Katie Waissel (12-15-12-10-9-8-7) Wagner (16-14-12-11-10-8) F.Y.D (8-7) Nicolo Festa (9-11) Storm Lee (11-14-13) Diva Fever (12-8) John Adeleye (7-13-10-8) Belle Amie (3-3-6-7-8) TreyC Cohen (6-9-11-10-9) Aiden Grimshaw (4-4-2-2-5-4)
November 15, 201014 yr On X-Factor singing alone: 1 Rebecca Ferguson (Saturday rank: 1) 2 Matt Cardle (SR: 8, worst performance yet - prob about equal with Mary and Paige) 3 Katie Waissel (SR: 5, but #1 by miles for her sing-off song - best performance of the weekend!) 4 Cher Lloyd (SR: 3) 5 Paije Richardson (SR: 6, OK but boring) 6 Mary Byrne (low because of the lack of variation) (SR: 7, good but boring) 7 One Direction (best performance this week, by far) (SR: 2) 8 Wagner (his best too, but obviously way down on all the others) (SR: 4, just because it's the first time he's been in tune) (Aiden would have been 4th, and ranked middle for Saturday, awfully out of tune in the sing-off) Overall (singing, performance, entertainment, likeability, 'star qualities', etc) 1 Katie Waissel (brilliant but she shouldn't win X-Factor) 2 Matt Cardle (hopefully will come 2nd. Sings brilliantly sometimes but somewhat overrated and is at least as ambitious as Katie, yet with her it's a bad thing apparently) 3 Wagner (on comedy value alone he makes top 3. Let him have his year in the limelight!) 4 Paije Richardson (won't win or do very well musically but has a nice voice and is likeable) 5 Rebecca Ferguson (great voice, has confidence, but doesn't scream 'star' at all - is it just me thinking that? She could do well if she wins though - with the right material. Like Matt, overrated somewhat) 6 Mary Byrne (likeable but apart from her interesting back story and ability to belt out ballads, she doesn't have much more to give. Would be interesting if she won - wouldn't be as big as SuBo though) 7 Cher Lloyd (what would be her target market apart from teenage girls who like her 'attitude? Does she want to be Cheryl Cole or Lady Sovereign? Not fussed at all although her voice has improved) 8 One Direction (probably nice enough, but just a bit bland/samey overall - one hit album then flop into obscurity, I think. Simon would give them $h!t songs IMO) This year seems to have more good performers/singers than last year (and most of the other years) and Wagner is better comedy than Jedward. Joe wouldn't win this year, definitely not. Alexandra would have a chance, Leon wouldn't win, Shayne would be in the final, Steve wouldn't be final 16, and we have the new Leona for the final in the shape of Rebecca. Edited November 15, 201014 yr by John_Squire
November 20, 201014 yr 01. Cher Lloyd / 03-04-09-05-01-06-02-01- 02. Rebecca Ferguson / 07-07-02-02-07-05-01-02- 03. One Direction / 05-09-05-08-02-03-04-03- 04. Paije Richardson / 06-08-10-09-08-08-04- 05. Matt Cardle / 04-03-03-01-03-02-03-05- 06. Katie Waissel / 12-13-13-06-08-07-05-06- 07. Mary Byrne / 08-05-06-09-05-09-07-08- 08. Wagner / 16-14-12-11-10-09-08- --- Nicolo Festa / 11-10-x F.Y.D. / 09-12-x Storm Lee / 10-14-11- Diva Fever / 15-12 John Adeleye / 06-11-10-11- Belle Amie / 01-08-01-07-10-x Treyc Cohen / 02-04-04-04-01-x Aiden Grimshaw / 02-01-07-03-06-04-06-x Edited November 22, 201014 yr by THEO.
November 20, 201014 yr 1. Cher 2. Paije 3. Katie 4. Matt 5. Rebecca 6. Mary 7. One Direction 8. Wagner
November 20, 201014 yr After tonight: 1. Rebecca - despite her being a bit off tonight, she's still overall the best 2. Cher - She's consistently great, I loved Imagine!!!! 3. Matt - He's been a 9 or 10 out of 10 each week, but CT wasn't too good, he could be in danger :( 4. Katie - I hate all the hate she gets, I love her! 5. One Direction - I did hate them, but they've been quite good the last few weeks :o 6. Paije - He's quite inconsistent. LIB was amazing, but his Elton song last week was awful 7. Mary - She's boring now :( Belt, belt, belt. Yawn. 8. Wagner - One word. AWFUL!
November 20, 201014 yr Tonight's show was especially awful compared to other weeks that have been cringe-worthy. Everyone but one person was terrible and I surprised myself when I realized this, but the best of the night was a shining.... 1. KATIE!! This was the kind of act she needed to be, someone reminiscent of Natalie Imbruglia, et al small voiced, jazzy singers. [GAP] 2. Cher Lloyd 3. Matt Cardle (though he does NOT have the swagg-a needed to pull that off [see Murs, Olly]) 4. Mary Byrne 5. Paije Richardson 6. Rebecca Ferguson (she MASSACRED a very lovely song) 7. 1Direction 8. Wagner
November 20, 201014 yr 01 03 Wagner- just because tonight he made me laugh, plus I think hes going tomorrow :( and I dislike Paije and Mary but they were good tonight :( 02 02 Cher Lloyd 03 01 Matt Cardle 04 05 Katie Waissel 05 06 One Direction 06 04 Rebecca Ferguson 07 08 Paije Richardson 08 09 Mary Byrne Edited November 20, 201014 yr by chart wizard
November 20, 201014 yr Tonight: 1.Mary - Don't know the song well but it really suited her voice 2.Katie - One of her best, don't get why people don't like her at all 3.One Direction - a few mess ups but still enjoyed it 4.Cher 5.Paije 6.Matt 7.Rebecca 8.Wagner Overall: 1.Cher 2.One Direction 3.Matt 4.Rebecca 5.Mary 6.Katie 7.Paije 8.Wagner
November 21, 201014 yr After a rewatch of week 7: 1 Katie 2 Mary 3 One Direction 4 Paije 5 Cher 6 Wagner 7 Rebecca 8 Matt Overall Singing 1 1 Rebecca (I'll give her this one crappy week, but she can't afford another) 3 2 Katie (one more fantastic performance would put her top of the singing IMO) 5 3 Paije (such a mature voice at times) 2 4 Matt (terrible performance, much prefer his 'girly' songs than that awful attempt at being tough) 4 5 Cher (she was OK with Imagine but it didn't showcase anything special) 6 6 Mary (she's very good at what she does. Nuff said.) 7 7 One Direction (they are getting better...) 8 8 Wagner (obviously) Overall 1 1 Katie 3 2 Wagner 4 3 Paije 5 4 Rebecca 6 5 Mary 2 6 Matt 7 7 Cher 8 8 One Direction
November 21, 201014 yr ONES I LOVE 1 2 Paije Richardson (best/only good vocal performance of the night, and a song I would definitely buy (if I could afford it)... Paije deserves more respect... he's like a mini David McAlmot :lol:) 2 1 Matt Cardle (WOOF @ the white vest... the song not so much. It was like he was possessed by the ghost of Rod Stewart's career) 3 4 Mary Byrne (Back to what she does best - Poundland Shirley Bassey) 4 3 Rebecca Ferguson (I thought it was kind of good, but kind of bad) ONES I DON'T GIVE A FLYING FUCK ABOUT 5 5 1 Direction (they continue to be almost bearable, apart from the fact that I really want to smash their little faces in) 6 7 Katie Waissel (loved the Rita Pavone hair (google it). The performance was fairly horrible but not as bad as previous weeks) 7 9 Cher Lloyd (THANK GAWD she didn't rap again. Not good, but not quite as offensive as previous weeks) 8 8 Wagner (GET WAGNER OUT! GET WAGNER OUT!)
November 21, 201014 yr 1 - Katie Waissel (5-2-1-4-5-3-1) 2 - Paije Richardson (3-7-4-7-4-7-2) 3 - Rebecca Ferguson (1-1-2-1-1-1-3) 4 - Mary Byrne (4-5-5-8-8-4-4) 5 - Wagner (8-6-7-6-3-5-5) 6 - One Direction (16 [last] -14 [last] -12 [last] - 11 [last] - 10 [last] -9 [last]-6) 7 - Cher Lloyd (9-4-9-3-7-6-7) 8 - Matt Cardle (6-8-10-9-6-8-8 [last]) OUT Aiden Grimshaw (11-13-6-5-2-2-OUT)
Create an account or sign in to comment