Jump to content

Katy Perry or Diana Vickers 142 members have voted

  1. 1. Whose X-Factor performance was better

    • Katy Perry
      39
    • Diana Vickers
      92

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

  • Author
You've never heard Diana speak? :o Where have you been that past 2 years!?!

I don't watch the X-Factor :lol:

 

 

 

  • Replies 92
  • Views 7.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Considering Katy Perry performed what is possibly the worst live performance this show has ever seen (barely a single word in tune), this is a daft question, really.....

Best Song: Katy

Best Perfomancs/show: Katy

Best Vocally: Diana

 

Katy wins.

katy perry hasnt got the best voice but firework is a better song. my wicked heart is a $h!t song .
katy perry hasnt got the best voice but firework is a better song. my wicked heart is a $h!t song .

 

in fairness diana doesnt have the writers katy has i mean 5 people wrote firework, 2 people wrote mwh

I do think its hilarious that people arent that bothered that "singers" cant "sing" well. Im sure its norm a big factor. I like mu singers to be able to sing, oh well, maybe thats just me lol

Yeh its ridiculous especially when they say it doesnt matter because she has great stage presence or looks great. Its about singing!

Diana was FAR better...Katy is awful live, there's no denying that.
Katy REALLY wasn't half as bad as people are making her out to be. I thought both were decent performances tbh.
Diana was better but I prefer the Katy song. ^_^
Katy REALLY wasn't half as bad as people are making her out to be. I thought both were decent performances tbh.

 

And thats your opinion. Most people seem to disagree.

It's quite embarrassing for those BIG artists to appear on X Factor against X Factor acts. Joe was better than Usher and Diana was better vocally than Katy Perry. Katy's performance was ok though.
Joe was better then usher? :lol: Well never thought i'd hear that! We are voting for the best PERFORMANCE and katy was better (and usher was better then joe)
It's quite embarrassing for those BIG artists to appear on X Factor against X Factor acts. Joe was better than Usher and Diana was better vocally than Katy Perry. Katy's performance was ok though.

 

Is it not even more EMBARRASSING when you're a judge on a show where people have to sing live yet you mime?? I think that is FAR worse!

Is it not even more EMBARRASSING when you're a judge on a show where people have to sing live yet you mime?? I think that is FAR worse!

Of course, Cheryl is a joke. Total tragedy.

Joe was better then usher? :lol: Well never thought i'd hear that! We are voting for the best PERFORMANCE and katy was better (and usher was better then joe)

Lol - Uhmm I advise you to watch Usher's performance again - all he sang was yeah, c'mon, yeah, c'mon. Utter $hit.

Edited by MTV79

I'm a big fan of Ms. Vickers, but, honestly, I'm not that keen on 'My Wicked Heart'. There are far better songs on her album that she could've/should've released as her 3rd single. :unsure:

 

That being said, I must say, that her performance on the X-Factor on Sunday Night, albeit a bit shaky, given her nerves at returning, and that she had been quite ill most of that week, was very professional, and showed how she has matured as an artist and performer. :yahoo:

 

Sadly, I can't say the same for Ms. Perry. :(

I think you're going way overboard with this... her performance wasn't great but it wasn't the worst and you know, at least she does sing live on there unlike Britney or Cheryl Cole who don't know how to.

 

Besides, I have seen Katy give decent performances before.

Yeah, kudos to Katy for actually singing live. At least she did do it (and in full AND without a huge backing track).

 

Katy does most of her performances (well at least the ones I've seen) fully live and usually with a band and I like that. Britney and Cheryl take note indeed.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.