Katie; oh dear. Off-key and flat. Totally underwhelming, and I think she lacked the power that the song needs in the chorus.

Katie- 4/10- that wasnt that good :( the vocals were shaky and it was a bit boring, could well be goodbye to her after that

Edited November 6, 201014 yr by chart wizard

Katie was not bad... though her Don't Speak version was a bit lifeless IMO.

She murdered a classic #1 track, no further comments 3/10

Cher Lloyd: Such a shame she went straight back to rapping. She sung it well though - 7.0/10

Mary Byrne: Poor Mary, wasnt the right song for her. Not a good performance. - 5.0/10

Katie Waissel: Actually prefered that far more there than the last couple of weeks. I love the song but I am sick with the whole Gwen Stefani comparison, shes nothing like her.Overall OK. - 6.5/10

THIS HAS NOT BEEN A GOOD START

Katie = 7.5

 

Loved her look and wig. Dont speak is one of my fave songs of all times but her performance wasnt that good.

Shes not popular then I see her in the bottom 3 unfortunately.

 

Katie = 7.5

Mary = 7.0

Cher = 6.5

I actually really liked Katie's performance! Yes, her vocals weren't great all the time, but it was a brilliant performance imo. 8/10

Katie - Nice performance, but not exactly ground breaking. 7.5/10 I'm hoping she'll get a little further in the contest....but it looks like the odds are against her. :(

 

Katie - 7.5/10

Cher - 7/10

Mary - 6.5/10

Edited November 6, 201014 yr by Sabrewulf

And suddenly I'm glad Cher went back to her flat singing and boring rap... because now I can hate her again ^_^

So this will be the week that the underdogs are better than the faves it seems not seen these performances yet though, but I believe Cher did me proud :P

Oh I don't know about Aiden this week. I can't tell if I like this or not. I think I'm liking it, (apart from the weird jaunty jaw movements), he has a strange charm that attracts me.

Lol. Sinead O'Connor is American now! :P Yeah, I know Prince wrote it, but it's not American! :P

Aiden = 5.0

 

Horrendous performance. He has ruined that cute song. Oh dear, bottom 3 please!

 

Katie = 7.5

Mary = 7.0

Cher = 6.5

Aiden = 5.0

I'm the same as Chemical Halo - I can't decide if that was good or not.

 

It definitely got better near the end, but I wish he'd stop over-complicating the melodies, and he looked like he was having a stroke at times. In all I guess it's the best of the 4 performances so far.

Aiden- 6/10- meh, that was OK, but it was the same thing again- he is seriously looking like a one trick pony

Aiden: He sounded rather flat to me, compared to his previous attempts 4/10

Aiden Grimshaw: Actually really liked that. Nowhere near 'Mad World' but best he has done since by far. Still think he is very inconsistant though. - 7.5/10

Aiden - That was....wow I'm not fully sure why (maybe it was the fire :P) but it gave me goosebumps. :wub: His intensity worked really well in that song...and it gave him a good chance to show off his singing abilities. 9/10

 

Aiden - 9/10

Katie - 7.5/10

Cher - 7/10

Mary - 6.5/10

Katie - Below average, quite disappointing, Aiden - best since Mad World, but still don't get him.