November 14, 201014 yr Sorry if anyone gets upset by this :( but I give Take That a year before Robbie jumps ship again. As long as that? I thought it was a good performance and the song sounded better live than it does on record ... but Robbie may as well have had this as a solo song on his album and sung it tonight with session singers. Kath Oh and on the contestants. Katie was miles better than Aiden in the sing-off. I just don't know why Dermot bothered asking Simon who he was going to send home - the world and his wife knows that unless she's up against One Direction ... he's always going to vote to keep Katie.
November 14, 201014 yr Yes but Aiden was bottom of the vote. I agree with the general oppinion that Waissel is an utter tit, but Aiden wasnt eliminated through the judges alone. There is nothing to complain about as far as I can see. yes but surely that's the reason we have the judges decision? last year olly murs got fewer votes than jedward but the correct decision was made to keep olly in and he came second, something that jedward would not have achieved. the public aren't always right!
November 14, 201014 yr BASICALLY, anybody who bitched about Katie staying last week has no right to bitch about her staying this week.
November 14, 201014 yr yes but surely that's the reason we have the judges decision? last year olly murs got fewer votes than jedward but the correct decision was made to keep olly in and he came second, something that jedward would not have achieved. the public aren't always right! Do you honestly think Louis would have taken it to deadlock if they didn't already know that Aiden was bottom of the public vote though? I don't. BUT ... she WAS better in the sing-off (despite being one of the worst acts on the show last night.) Kath
November 14, 201014 yr It just seems like politics again - Aiden was a bigger threat to 1direction so I wasn't surprised that Simon voted against Aiden
November 14, 201014 yr I dont think Aiden peaked in week 1. Mad World was indeed his best performance but he'd been a lot more consistant in my opinion that quite a lot of the others. I am loving Nicolo's unashamed hate for Katie on Twitter though. Utterly brilliant. yes but surely that's the reason we have the judges decision? last year olly murs got fewer votes than jedward but the correct decision was made to keep olly in and he came second, something that jedward would not have achieved. the public aren't always right! You make a good point actually. I suppose really this brings back the real reason she's still here which is the amount of publicity and controvesy she brings to the show. I do wonder what would have happened though if Katie was bottom of the night. I think it's fair to say Simon knows the result beforehand so would he have made Louis vote Aiden out?
November 14, 201014 yr I do wonder what would have happened though if Katie was bottom of the night. I think it's fair to say Simon knows the result beforehand so would he have made Louis vote Aiden out? Definitely. Kath
November 14, 201014 yr What a difference the sex of a contestant a year makes... :whistle: That's more to do with that Jedward were completely vile and were even less talented than Wagner, let alone Katie.
November 14, 201014 yr Do you honestly think Louis would have taken it to deadlock if they didn't already know that Aiden was bottom of the public vote though? I don't. BUT ... she WAS better in the sing-off (despite being one of the worst acts on the show last night.) Kath No, because then he might of well have saved katie then if he wanted to keep her in
November 14, 201014 yr No, because then he might of well have saved katie then if he wanted to keep her in But going to deadlock would create extra drama.....plus the end result would be the same. It's win win for them.
November 14, 201014 yr Aiden was dreadful :cheer: Thank God he has gone I think you normally post a load of old twaddle Shelli (no offence) ... but on this occasion I agree with you. I could NOT have stood watching him another week ... he just made me so bloody nervous. Kath
November 14, 201014 yr Katie is far from a bitch, she is a very nice girl. The bitch of the contest is Ms. Lloyd.
November 14, 201014 yr I don't think people are annoyed that Aiden went over Katie due to public vote, I think its more the fact that Katie SHOULD have gone last week instead of TreyC and so this situation could have been avoided. Would there be uproar if TreyC had been kept over Aiden? I don't think so. Poor Katie, she must have the record amount of times for surviving the bottom 2/3. Saved or not, she can't have much more confidence left. However I liked how shocked she and Paije were upon hearing they were saved as it shows their not overly cocky. And Paije needs more credit, he's a very good singer.
November 14, 201014 yr I think Katie was better than Treyc and Aiden. Treyc was incredibly boring. And Aiden was jut awful
November 14, 201014 yr Awwww I'm rather sad Aiden has gone. I quite liked him. I know not why as he was out of tune 90% of the time and made me develop a twitch when he sang. But I felt strangely drawn to him. :(
November 14, 201014 yr I think Katie was better than Treyc and Aiden. Treyc was incredibly boring. And Aiden was jut awful TreyC never had a bad week. She was unlucky to be constantly labeled as 'boring' when she showed a lot of versatility and had an extremely powerful voice. I mean how can boring have anything to do with it when Leona Lewis won this show? Katie sang very well tonight, I'll give her that but she was extremely poor last night and even worse it last week's sing off. As someone has already stated, Aiden could be good but was very inconsistant which is something you can't say about TreyC.
Create an account or sign in to comment