I want X Factor to fail so the more inappropriate the "judges" the better.

 

Sophie Ellis-Bextor would have been a good choice, she was stroppy as hell when she was younger, there's probably some of that left in her. So, please don't. Kelly Rowland, therefore, is a brilliantly boring choice.

Matt Edmonson and Kimberley Walsh presenting the Xtra Factor.

LOL WHAT.

 

Kimberley, God bless her, has the charisma of a box of recycled cardboard. Matt Edmonson is just an outright CUNT.

I love Matt Edmundson :D

 

I had a feeling he'd get a job as he used to get a good reaction from his F Factor show on the X Factor website

Kimberley Walsh is not confirmed yet!

 

Matt's confirmed. Meanwhile it's between Kimberley Walsh, Frankie Standford, Laura Hamilton & Stacey Solomon.

Kimberley Walsh is not confirmed yet!

 

Matt's confirmed. Meanwhile it's between Kimberley Walsh, Frankie Sandford, Laura Hamilton & Stacey Solomon.

 

Is Tulisa 100% confirmed to be a judge on X-Factor? That'd be horrible as I thought N-Dubz criticised shows such a X-Factor before..

Matt Edmundson will be a great host :D I always liked F Factor

Edited May 25, 201114 yr by chart wizard

IF Cheryl has been dropped in the US and comes crawling back to the UK version, she'd quite clearly own the panel (especially considering who some of the replacements are rumoured to be.) With Simon gone, she'd be like the NEW QUEEN.

Chery would take Simon's place as the "main" judge for sure.

I don't think she would comeback to the X Factor. She's far too clever to damage her image like that.

 

Being sacked and then coming crawling back [i'm sure ITV would be foaming at the mouth over the though of her coming back] would give the notoriously fickle UK Press plenty of ammunition to just character assassinate her, which is something I'd wish on very very very few people.

 

She clearly has a brilliant team behind her and a very astute business mind, she did make herself into the nations sweet heart and have a big solo career despite having very little vocal ability [i'm sorry Bertie et al, but she really is a weak vocalist. There's very little power or technique in her voice] and to do that you have to be pretty brilliant. There is no way she would comeback. I imagine she'll comeback to the UK, do some interviews where she tells of her heartbreak at being fired [While still attempting to break the US market but not spending every waking moment out there] then coming back with a massive third solo album on a wave of public sympathy and just riding it to #1 sans X Factor. Then after missing this year just swaggering back onto the panel next year, after the inevitable rating dive, as it's saviour.

 

I should really go into PR.

I think going back to Girls Aloud would be the logical move for her at this point. She's got about as much out of her solo career as she can I think - her last album sold a lot less than her debut (and the law of diminishing returns dictates that, if the trend continued for another album, she'd be in very dangerous territory indeed). At this point, she really needs to do something that would gain critical acclaim, and I think her only chance of that is with Girls Aloud, because her voice really isn't strong enough to stand up on its own solo - she's much better providing a sweetener for the stronger voices in Girls Aloud.

 

I always thought it was a shame Girls Aloud went on hiatus when they did anyway - it was just at the time where they were finally carving out a trademark sound (melodic, ambient, tasteful pop - Call the Shots, The Loving Kind etc. - rather than the cookie-cutter stuff Cheryl put out solo), and when they'd finally overhauled Sugababes as the UK's premier girlband

Yes, Tulisa is fit!! Happy ha ha

I think going back to Girls Aloud would be the logical move for her at this point. She's got about as much out of her solo career as she can I think - her last album sold a lot less than her debut (and the law of diminishing returns dictates that, if the trend continued for another album, she'd be in very dangerous territory indeed). At this point, she really needs to do something that would gain critical acclaim, and I think her only chance of that is with Girls Aloud, because her voice really isn't strong enough to stand up on its own solo - she's much better providing a sweetener for the stronger voices in Girls Aloud.

 

I always thought it was a shame Girls Aloud went on hiatus when they did anyway - it was just at the time where they were finally carving out a trademark sound (melodic, ambient, tasteful pop - Call the Shots, The Loving Kind etc. - rather than the cookie-cutter stuff Cheryl put out solo), and when they'd finally overhauled Sugababes as the UK's premier girlband

 

Completely agree, was the worst timing ever, especially after they won a Brit. They should have at least released 1 more album before the 'hiatus' I really hope this does push her back into Girls Aloud. Although we still have to wait for Nadine to flop in the US with her next single and for Nicola to release her album in October.

 

Where will Cheryl go then... lol

It would be the worst move in her career for her to go back to the UK X factor, she would just look stupid. She needs to go back to Girls Aloud - but Nicola needs to release her solo stuff first (the single sounds like it will be a hit too!) so what will she do? ha

Tulisa confirmed.

 

na na NINE

Oh dear.

GOOD GRIEF

 

I never thought I'd say this, but bring back Cherly

I really hope this is the beginning of the end. And that it somehow destroys N-Dubz's career in the process.