Posted May 27, 201114 yr Decided to do a Vs for Rihanna's last two albums. I have not included Mad House as it was Intro anyway. Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's my name Stupid In Love Vs Cheer (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part 2 Rated r wins it for me. Loud is a great album. But Rated R for was very different from Rihanna and through the creative and quality side of it, its her best album to date.
May 27, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's my name Stupid In Love Vs Cheer (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part 2 7-4 to Rated R and it really is a much much better album overall, although I think the highs are higher on Loud.
May 27, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's my name Stupid In Love Vs Cheers (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl (in the world) Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part II Rated R - 5, Loud - 6 VERY close call, I adore both albums, both albums very different. both have some crap on also - Skin and G4L for examples.
May 27, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's my name Stupid In Love Vs Cheer (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part 2 R 5 L 6
May 27, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's my name Stupid In Love Vs Cheers (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed <<< FUCK RIGHT OFF! :drama: (My 2 favourite Rihanna songs! :manson:) Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part 2 'Fire Bomb' vs. 'California King Bed' was the hardest. Them two are constantly changing with 'Take A Bow' to be my favourite Rihanna song! Rated R: 5 Loud: 6 She's one of very, very few acts to actually be improving with each and every release. Which is why she's one of the best popstars around.
May 27, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's My Name? (Hard is awesome but What's My Name? is probably the best thing she's done) Stupid In Love Vs Cheer (Drink to That) (Both too awful to choose) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only Girl (In the World) Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case LoveVs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the Way You Lie (Part 2) Rated R - 09 Loud - 01 Loud is a truly wretched album. Rated R was not.
May 27, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's My Name Stupid In Love Vs Cheers (Drink to That) - Completely agree about these both being awful. I guess 'Stupid in Love' is slightly more bearable though. Rockstar 101 Vs Fading - These two are rather poor too. Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the Way You Lie Part 2 'Rated R' - 7 'Loud' - 4 Top 3 overall would be: 01 'Hard' 02 'Skin' 03 'What's My Name'
May 27, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's My Name Stupid In Love Vs Cheers (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed - this is the hardest! Both are brilliant. Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part 2 Rated R - 5 Loud - 6 Both genuinely amongst my top 100 albums ever, along with Good Girl Gone Bad, and to think I wasn't even anything approaching a fan for the first two and a half years of her career...
May 27, 201114 yr Top 3 overall would be: 01 'Hard' 02 'Skin' 03 'What's My Name' :heart: Not even gonna embaress Rated R by doing this..
May 27, 201114 yr Just realised...where's 'Rude Boy'?! Haha! I didn't even notice. Hard and What's My Name? are her two best. :wub:
May 27, 201114 yr Ok.. Wait Your Turn Vs S&M - Easy. Love Wait Your Turn. :wub: Hard Vs What's my name - Hard has grown on me Stupid In Love Vs Cheers (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading - Two easy wins for Loud. Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world - Both good, but RR edges it. Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed - Why? Why? Why? I love both of these songs so much. After Unfaithful, these two would probably round out my RiRi top 3. CKB just about does it in the end, but I hated having to choose that. Photographs Vs Man Down - Fairly easy. G4L Vs Raining Men - A hard to choose average pairing. Te Amo Vs Complicated - Worst pairing really, but I'll go with Te Amo. Cold Case Love Vs Skin - Never listened much to either of these, but Cold Case Love is slightly better. The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part 2 - Love Last Song, but LTWYL2 is so much better. If I include Rude Boy as an extra, along with Who's That Chick, which I know is a feature and isn't on Loud, but just to give Rude Boy something to compare against, because I can't think of anything else right now. Rude Boy Vs Who's That Chick? - I like Rude Boy a bit more, I think. Scoring. Rated R - 7 (Or 6 without the last pairing) Loud - 5 Edited May 27, 201114 yr by Eyes
May 27, 201114 yr This is the way it SHOULD be with Rude Boy and Who's That Chick added :P Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's My Name (VERY Hard...excuse the pun :lol: ) Stupid In Love Vs Cheers (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed - this is the hardest! Both are brilliant. Rude Boy Vs Man Down Photographs Vs Raining Men G4L Vs Complicated Te Amo Vs Skin Cold Case Love Vs Love the way you lie Part 2 The Last Song Vs Who's That Chick? 6 each! :wub:
May 27, 201114 yr ^ I thought about that, but decided against it, as it lets the themes fit - Cold Case Love vs Skin is a very good match (both slow tracks), and same with The Last Song vs Love The Way You Lie Pt 2 (both album enders). Besides, it doesn't affect my scores much, as the only things that would change is Rude Boy would lose, Raining Men would win, and Who's That Chick would win over The Last Song.
May 28, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's my name Stupid In Love Vs Cheers (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part 2 Rated R: 2 Loud: 9 Not surprised as I prefer Loud overall.
May 28, 201114 yr After re-listening to 'Rated R' a lot lately, because of this, I have now decided 'Fire Bomb' is the greatest song she has ever, ever done for me :wub:
May 29, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's my name Stupid In Love Vs Cheers (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed VERY hard Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part 2
June 1, 201114 yr Wait Your Turn Vs S&M Hard Vs What's my name Stupid In Love Vs Cheer (Drink to that) Rockstar 101 Vs Fading Russian Roulette Vs Only girl in the world Fire Bomb Vs California King Bed Photographs Vs Man Down G4L Vs Raining Men Te Amo Vs Complicated Cold Case Love Vs Skin The Last Song Vs Love the way you lie Part 2
June 1, 201114 yr She just keeps getting better with each album, :wub: for me there is only one terrible track on LOUD which is 'Raining Men'.
