So Astro fans are called ASTRONAUTS.

 

And that's THE stupidest shit I've seen all year. :mellow: :mellow:

 

Astro & Drew

have gone this week - I totally agree with the forst one out but deffo not the second.

 

My final 2 would now be:

Melanie

Josh

Edited December 2, 201113 yr by euro music

This week you can vote for one song for each of the top 5, and whichever has the most votes is sung:

 

http://www.thexfactorusa.com/challenge

 

(obviously don't read on if you haven't seen the result and you watch at UK pace, it is given away by the two acts not there)

 

Choices:

 

 

Rachel Crow

Ain't No Mountain High Enough (Diana Ross)

Valerie (Mark Ronson & Amy Winehouse/The Zutons)

Forget You (Cee-Lo Green)

 

Melanie Amaro

I Didn't Know My Own Strength (Whitney Houston)

The Voice Within (Christina Aguilera)

Hero (Mariah Carey)

 

Chris Rene

Fly (Sugar Ray)

Angel (Shaggy)

My Love Is Your Love (Whitney Houston)

 

Marcus Canty

We Belong Together (Mariah Carey)

Saving All My Love For You (Whitney Houston)

I'll Make Love To You (Boys II Men)

 

Josh Krajcik

Chasing Pavements (Adele)

Come Together (The Beatles)

Everytime You Go Away (Hall & Oates)

 

 

Bolded are my choices.

Edited December 2, 201113 yr by Liаm

GUTTED FOR DREW. Praying for a Melanie win now :(

Melanie so obvious though, with the not putting through, then simon going back to the house, it was just all so set up and made for drama purposes, and shes a good singer, but hardly a big star.

I liked Drew, so good at judges houses with It Must Have Been Love but she is very odd.

I think i want Rachael to win :D So likeable, and so talented. :)

Edited December 2, 201113 yr by Karma

I only like Rachel and Melanie now,I reckon Josh will win though - if this was Idol he'd be walking it anyway. I'm not sure if the same kind of people vote here as on Idol though, because on Idol the belting females always have a bumpy ride (Pia's early shock elimination, Fantasia landing bottom 2 three times etc.) and Melanie is sailing through.

 

I just pray one of the two girls win, Josh is overrated and just Idol fodder :(

For heaven's sake!! This week has been the worst ever in terms of my favourites in Reality shows! Firstly Janet on Sunday being eliminated on UK X Factor, followed by Jess on I'm A Celeb, followed by Hayley on Apprentice and finished off by Drew on US X Factor! :angry:

 

Of course, Janet and Drew are more important than the other two - and Janet my favourite out of herself and Drew - it's so annoying! I really hope Drew gets a recording contract (possibly with Syco even though it hasn't got a good reputation!) and we know that Janet has already had an offer, so some positive there.

 

JANET AND DREW YOU ARE THE BEST!

 

/Rant over

GUTTED FOR DREW. Praying for a Melanie win now :(

I'm also gutted about Drew & now hope for a Melanie win with Josh runner-up

Have you noticed just like UK X Factor they never let you know who had the lowest votes from the 2 in the sing-off

 

Astro should never have been in it as it's a singing competition

Dictionary definition of singing: To utter a series of words or sounds in musical tones.

Where were the musical tones in Astro - I never heard any.

 

Chris Rene can't sing either although he does attempt it - As for Marcus Cantee - I just fall asleep when he starts warbling.

Edited December 3, 201113 yr by euro music

The thing that cuts most about Drew leaving is that you just know it wasn't a justified decision, only a 'f*** you' from the ladies to Simon. LA had no choice either, Marcus being his act. But seriously, how is Marcus better than Drew by any stretch :mellow:

Marcus was miles better than her in the sing-off. -_-

She was so nervous, she wasn't prepared to sing for survive.

Who would I like to send home next week - L.A. REID :lol:

Marcus was miles better than her in the sing-off. -_-

She was so nervous, she wasn't prepared to sing for survive.

I thought her sing-off was absolutely stunning :o Marcus did well with his song too tbf, but he is just in NO WAY anywhere near as good as Drew :(

I thought her sing-off was absolutely stunning :o Marcus did well with his song too tbf, but he is just in NO WAY anywhere near as good as Drew :(

 

This ^ Plus Marcus seems really out of tune in parts!

Like I said last page, I think Paula and Nicole voting off Drew was just a middle finger to Simon :( I hate LA Reid (what a twat) but he had no choice but to send Drew home given that Marcus is his act. Marcus is good at times, but he's not winner material - I don't see how they feasibly viewed him as so much better...

Paddypower Outright winner odds:

 

 

Melanie Amaro evens

 

Josh Krajcik 2/1

 

Rachel Crow 5/1

 

Chris Rene 16/1

 

Marcus Canty 20/1

Seriously pissed off with this now...

 

 

Marcus was bottom AGAIN but he survived yet again and dispatched RACHEL... It was absilutely horrible to watch, the poor girl broke down and collasped on the floor in tears :(

 

 

N Scherz had the final decision, she was booed off stage for it :D

Edited December 9, 201113 yr by Liаm

Lol I just watched the video, poor Nicole. She made a bad call though. I don't think people would have cared so much if Rachel didn't have such a dramatic breakdown when they announced her name!! She definitely shouldn't have gone but at the end of the day, she had the least amount of votes so...

:mellow:

 

Seriously worse than the UK version. Good I stopped watching at Live Shows Week 1 :D

The presenter is doing a REALLY bad job there. Just look at his face after he announces the results. I know he was listening to someone through the earpiece but still.

 

 

The eliminated contestant looked rather confident :lol:

 

Oh Nicole, what a COW(ARD).

It just goes to show how bad the judges really are: Simon & Paul are OK but the Scherz & L.A. Reid really haven't a clue.

 

Marcus should have gone weeks ago.

 

Also why couldn't Chris do something like his second song instead of the rappin and arm wavin' like he's done since week 1.

 

Well I for one think Marcus is amazing. And it was so over the top, Nicole has nothing to be blamed for, the public voted for Marcus over Rachel. Rachel will clearly get snapped up anyway.