Somebody needs to put this theory of versatility to the test. Live on stage. *licks teeth*

 

 

 

You're too ugly for him.

Oh my music taste is so odd. I Like the RHCP and Hanson and I'm trying so hard not to be mainstream I'm making myself more mainstream.

 

 

My good god Janet MUST go this weekend. She's so dull and pretentious it makes Born This Way and Lady GaGa look normal.

Off to a bad start.

I think POOR sums this up well.

This girl has no vocal control.

 

 

8.4 Misha B (Cyndi Lauper)

8.0 Little Mix (Justin/Supremes)

7.4 Amelia (T'Pau)

7.2 Marcus (Wham)

3.0 Janet (Hanson)

 

9.1 Misha (Fugees)

8.2 Marcus (Stevie Wonder)

8.0 Little Mix (Christina)

5.6 Janet (RHCP)

3.5 Amelia (Kelly Clarkson)

 

I think Tulisa and Gary need to f*** off

Amelia 2 = 7.5

After the amazing first performance, Since you've been gone was a very forgettable performance.

 

Amelia - 9.0 / 7.5 = 16.5

Marcus - 7.7 / 8.5 = 16.2

Misha B - 8.5 / 7.5 = 16.0

Little Mix - 8.0 / 8.0 = 16.0

Janet - 6.0 / 6.5 = 12.5

Edited November 26, 201113 yr by Jason

We now know she can't do upmtepo (oww)

Oh Amelia, I really want to LOVE you but that was pretty shaky :(

 

Round two;

 

09.5 Little Mix

09.0 Misha

07.5 Amelia

07.5 Marcus

03.0 Janet

I actually think Janet will top the votes again :wub: She has a fanbase :wub:

 

Hopefully Marcus and Little Mix to go. Both are absolute shit!

01 Little Mix - Beautiful

02 Amelia Lily - China In Your Hand

03 Amelia Lily - Since U Been Gone

04 Misha B - Killing Me Softly

05 Janet Devlin - Under The Bridge

06 Marcus Collins - Lately

07 Marcus Collins - I'm Your Man

08 Misha B - Girls Just Wanna Have Fun

09 Little Mix - Baby / Baby Love

10 Janet Devlin - Mmmbop

 

Another superb, powerful performance.

I'm sorry but they did actually watch the same as us??

Exactly! It's probably the strongest top five we've had in quite a while. I genuinely wouldn't mind any of them winning, which is more than I can say for most years.

 

I think last year's top five was a lot stronger than this year's (as proven by all five of them going on to have at least some commercial success).

 

Same old for Amelia, again she has to go this week AFAIC. Janet's first performance was obviously the worst of the show by a mile but I'd rank both of Amelia's as the second and third worst.

Edited November 26, 201113 yr by Bré

I think the bottom 2 will be Misha and Little Mix because Misha is hated and Little Mix were bollocks.

Amelia Lily (Since You've Been Gone) - I was not nearly as keen on that, the vocals in the chorus were too much and she went off key a few times. At other times she sounded good, but it was a little bit too much of an ask for her. - 7.0/10.0

 

RATES:

Little Mix (Beautiful) - 10.0

Misha B (Girls Just Want To Have Fun) - 9.5

Misha B (Killing Me Softly) - 9.0

Amelia (China In Your Hand) - 9.0

Marcus (Lately) - 8.5

Marcus (I'm Your Man) - 8.0

Little Mix (Baby/Baby Love) - 7.5

Amelia (Since You've Been Gone) - 7.0

Janet (Under The Bridge) - 3.0

Janet (Mmmbop) - 0.5

It was the perfect song for her voice, it's just a shame that she just has the one shouty level to it. Even on the quiet bits you can tell she is DESPERATE to just start belting everything (I have no idea where the judges were getting all this emotion from in the last song?)

Amelia - I thought that was REALLY shaky. Especially at the start when she was walking on to the stage it was all so obvious. Having said that I did like it overall and when it was good it was very good. 7/10

 

 

Misha - 8.5/10

Little Mix - 8/10

Janet - 7.5/10

Amelia - 7/10

Marcus - 6.5/20

 

Misha - 16.5/20

Amelia - 15.5/20

Little Mix - 15/20

Marcus - 14/20

Janet - 13/20

 

So that's Marcus and Janet for the bottom two with hopefully Janet going.

I'm sorry but they did actually watch the same as us??

[conspiracytheorist] They said nice things to lull the voters into a false sense of security! It's a ploy to get her out! [/conspiracytheorist]

I think tonight's show shows why X Factor needs to be cancelled.

OMG you gave most of them 8 out of 10 or more.

 

Your standards are dire

 

I actually think the standard tonight has been really good, apart from Janet bringing it down. I am not normally as generous, but I think most people did well tonight.