District 3 - Some reasonable harmonies at the end, but they really are completely bland and the song choice and arrangement was just strange. I also hate the lead singers voice. - 3/10

OH SWEET MERCIFUL CHRIST

Oh dear. At this rate, I'm not going to want to see ANYONE through to next week.

James Arthur - 8.7

I loved this song choice and I liked the rap part! :o

 

James Arthur - 8.7

District 8.5

James Arthur - I'm really surprised, I haven't liked him before - but I really liked him tonight. I preferred it at the beginning when it was like, no backing track, it made the track sound really beautiful, and he sung it well. I liked what was done with him there, he didn't shout it. 8/10

Not a fan of James but I really liked his rap. Not so much the chorus.

 

District 3: 3/10

James Arthur: 6/10

I didn't like that really. The rap wasn't good and the arrangement was poor.

 

08.5 District3

05.0 James Arthur

Too bad Gary can't whip out the old 'I'm in the Head Judge's seat' remark this year.

So the giant hunk of shit massacred an amazing song. I now hate him that little bit more.

what an awful start, totally turning them into something there not!! or they were just generally crap to begin with lol

Much better than the first performance, but I still have some doubts over James Arthur, its ok but nothing special 5/10

James Arthur - What on earth was that noise at the beginning? Apart from that I thought it was actually very good, the song choice shouldn't have worked but it did and the rap part was actually very impressive. I still think he needs work on his breathing though because it really does make him sound incredibly desperate. - 7.0/10

 

James Arthur - 7.0

District3 - 3.0

Not bad from Melanie but lets hope she doesn't do the 'hold a big note' thing too often.

Melanie Masson - A lot of people scream songs with no control on this show, but she has power that I really really love. Class act. 8.5/10

Melanie - 7.0

Predictable song chance. There's way too much shouting for me.

 

James Arthur - 8.7

District 8.5

Melanie 7.0

What on earth was that, I wish she wouldn't shout that much, my ears hurt now. Does nothing for me but I give 6/10

Oh wow she KILLED THAT. Amazing.

Thus far:

 

04 District 3

02 James Arthur

10 Melanie Masson

Melanie Masson - I have liked her all series but she has never amazed me, however that was just outstanding. That is how you perform at the first live show, totally unexpected. - 9.5/10

 

Melanie Masson - 9.5

James Arthur - 7.0

District3 - 3.0

Wow what a voice :lol: My ears are still ringing.

 

Melanie Masson: 8/10

James Arthur: 6/10

District 3: 3/10