It always used to be Heidi for me but after the events in and after 2009 I was vastly disappointed in her as well as in Keisha. Mutya - I love her realness but she needs some sanity at times instead of overload of implants, tattoos etc. And Siobhan... She's made two brilliant albums, she definitely is THE "smart girl" of the group, and while she's not the leader in MKS - she doesn't need it. And she slowly but surely became my favourite Sugababe.

 

As for the other two - I like Amelle more - she has that originality, and I like her voice. 'Beware' is brilliant too. She can go OTT quite often but I definitely find something interesting in her as a personality. Jade... She's a nice girl, and I liked her before the Sugababes - she used her chance, it didn't work, I can't blame her for trying to get some bread for her and her invalid parents. But she's just not a Sugababe, even in her soul. Amelle *has* that Sugababes vibe, Jade - not at all. That's one of the reasons why 3.0 still worked somehow - but replacing a pure Sugababe by an erm... "Trinity Stoner"... is just WRONG for Sugababes fame.

 

So it's got to be

1. Siobhan

2. Mutya

3. Heidi

4. Keisha

5. Amelle

 

Jade

Maybe they voted for the most beautiful member in their opinion. :)

 

Deciding your favourite singer by how beautiful is she? That must be the shallowest thing I've ever heard.

Deciding your favourite singer by how beautiful is she? That must be the shallowest thing I've ever heard.

 

I'm confused as to why it's shallow for liking your fave sugababe. For me is based on voice, personality & looks ie beautiful so i don't get what's so wrong in that. I just hope we're not going down a moral/religious road here. Sorry if im a tad muddled.

Edited March 2, 201312 yr by Rob Summers

Maybe you should read properly before jumping on conclusions...

 

I said that deciding your favourite singer exclusively by the look of her face and not paying attention to any other feature like voice, creativity, work, personality etc. it's shallow. And I reaffirm my statement.

Maybe you should read properly before jumping on conclusions...

 

I said that deciding your favourite singer exclusively by the look of her face and not paying attention to any other feature like voice, creativity, work, personality etc. it's shallow. And I reaffirm my statement.

 

ok my mistake. don't get shirty all the same :(

Actually I'm not pretty sure that Alex meant by 'beautiful' exactly beautiful in terms of looks. It could be the language barrier and he possibly meant just being generously good in all the terms.

Actually I'm not pretty sure that Alex meant by 'beautiful' exactly beautiful in terms of looks. It could be the language barrier and he possibly meant just being generously good in all the terms.

All very confusing lol.

1. Jade

2. Amelle

3. Mutya

4. Heidi

5. Keisha

6. Siobhan