http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/CarrieUnderwoodBanner.jpg

Carrie Underwood || Ultimate Rate || Results

So, we had NINE rates in total, the results for Carrie's Ultimate Rate will begin in the afternoon.

FULL LIST OF RESULTS:

1. 10.3 Blown Away || Blown Away
2. 10.0 Ever Ever After || N/A
3. 9.72 Temporary Home || Play On
4. 9.61 Cowboy Casanova || Play On (more 11s)
5. 9.61 Before He Cheats || Some Hearts (fewer 11s)
6. 9.56 I Know You Won't || Carnival Ride
7. 9.44 All-American Girl || Carnival Ride
8. 9.39 So Small || Carnival Ride
9. 9.33 Just a Dream || Carnival Ride (no 11s, same 10s, more 9.5s)
10. 9.33 See You Again || Blown Away (no 11s, same 10s, fewer 9.5s)

11. 9.33 Some Hearts || Some Hearts (no 11s, same 10s, fewer 9.5s)
12. 9.28 Two Black Cadillacs || Blown Away (same 11s, more 10s)
13. 9.28 Who Are You || Blown Away (same 11s, fewer 10s)
14. 9.22 Jesus, Take The Wheel || Some Hearts
15. 9.17 Good Girl || Blown Away (no 11s, more 10s)
16. 9.17 Quitter || Play On (no 11s, fewer 10s)
17. 9.00 Last Name || Carnival Ride
18. 8.94 Inside Your Heaven || Some Hearts (higher score to more decimal places)
19. 8.94 There's a Place For Us || N/A (lower score to more decimal places)
20. 8.83 Undo It || Play On (more 10s, more 9.5s)

21. 8.83 Play On || Play On (more 10s, fewer 9.5s)
22. 8.83 Wasted || Some Hearts (fewer 10s)
23. 8.72 Flat On The Floor || Carnival Ride
24. 8.67 I Told You So || Carnival Ride (one 11)
25. 8.67 Change || Play On (no 11s, more 10s)
26. 8.67 Get Out Of This Town || Carnival Ride (no 11s, less 10s)
27. 8.61 Unapologize || Play On
28. 8.57 I'll Stand By You || N/A
29. 8.56 Mama's Song || Play On (one 11)
30. 8.56 Good In Goodbye || Blown Away (no 11s)

31. 8.50 Starts With Goodbye || Some Hearts (one 11, more 10s)
32. 8.50 I Ain't In Checotah Anymore || Some Hearts (one 11, less 10s)
33. 8.44 What Can I Say (feat. Sons of Sylvia) || Play On (one 11, two 9.5)
34. 8.44 Thank God For Hometowns || Blown Away (one 11, no 9.5s)
35. 8.38 Wheel of the World || Carnival Ride
36. 8.36 Home Sweet Home || N/A
37. 8.33 The Night Before (Life Goes On) (two 10s)
38. 8.33 Cupid's Got a Shotgun || Blown Away (one 10, one 9)
39. 8.33 Forever Changed || Blown Away (one 10, no 9s)
40. 8.27 Don't Forget to Remember Me || Some Hearts (one 10)

41. 8.27 One Way Ticket || Blown Away (no 10s)
42. 8.22 Twisted || Carnival Ride
43. 8.21 Sometimes You Leave || Carnival Ride (bonus track)
44. 8.16 The More Boys I Meet || Carnival Ride
45. 8.05 Songs Like This || Play On
46. 8.00 You Won't Find This || Carnival Ride
47. 7.94 Whenever You Remember || Some Hearts
48. 7.88 That's Where It Is || Some Hearts
49. 7.83 I Just Can't Live A Lie || Some Hearts
50. 7.72 Leave Love Alone || Blown Away (one 10)

51. 7.72 Lessons Learned || Some Hearts (highest score = 9.5)
52. 7.72 Wine After Whiskey || Blown Away (highest score = 9, more 9s)
53. 7.72 Look At Me || Play On (highest score = 9, fewer 9s)
54. 7.72 Do You Think About Me || Blown Away (highest score = 8.5)
55. 7.61 Crazy Dreams || Carnival Ride (highest score = 9.5)
56. 7.61 This Time || Play On (highest score = 8.5)
57. 7.56 Nobody Ever Told You || Blown Away
58. 7.50 How Great Thou Art (live) || N/A
59. 7.39 Someday When I Stop Loving You || Play On
60. 7.36 Remind Me (Brad Paisley ft. Carrie Underwood) || N/A
61. 7.28 We're Young and Beautiful || Some Hearts

PREDICTIONS PLEASE

Edited July 29, 201312 yr by JosephVickers1D

Well if See You Again is not top 5, I will kill you all. :smoke:

Ever Ever After to WIN.

Before He Cheats, Wasted, Flat On The Floor (lol as if) or Cowboy Cassanova to win <3

Song of Choice: Nobody Ever Told You
You shine like a diamond, glitter like gold...

51. 7.72 Lessons Learned || Some Hearts (highest score = 9.5)
52. 7.72 Wine After Whiskey || Blown Away (highest score = 9, more 9s)
53. 7.72 Look At Me || Play On (highest score = 9, fewer 9s)
54. 7.72 Do You Think About Me || Blown Away (highest score = 8.5)
55. 7.61 Crazy Dreams || Carnival Ride (highest score = 9.5)
56. 7.61 This Time || Play On (highest score = 8.5)
57. 7.56 Nobody Ever Told You || Blown Away
58. 7.50 How Great Thou Art (live) || N/A
59. 7.39 Someday When I Stop Loving You || Play On
60. 7.36 Remind Me (Brad Paisley ft. Carrie Underwood) || N/A
61. 7.28 We're Young and Beautiful || Some Hearts

Getting a large chunk out of the way first so the next post begins the top 50. No major losses here. We're Young and Beautiful comes deservedly last as it's pretty dire compared to a lot of her debut album. The only major loss for me is the fantastic Nobody Ever Told You, which should be top 40 at least. Tiebreakers galore at the top, broken by their maximum score and the amount of said score if necessary.

WOT. Lessons Learned, Look at Me and Do You Think About Me far too low. :cry:

Lessons Learned and Crazy Dreams wtf :/

Song of Choice: The More Boys I Meet
So I close my eyes and kiss that frog...

41. 8.27 One Way Ticket || Blown Away (no 10s)
42. 8.22 Twisted || Carnival Ride
43. 8.21 Sometimes You Leave || Carnival Ride (bonus track)
44. 8.16 The More Boys I Meet || Carnival Ride
45. 8.05 Songs Like This || Play On
46. 8.00 You Won't Find This || Carnival Ride
47. 7.94 Whenever You Remember || Some Hearts
48. 7.88 That's Where It Is || Some Hearts
49. 7.83 I Just Can't Live A Lie || Some Hearts
50. 7.72 Leave Love Alone || Blown Away (one 10)

So we begin this section with the winner of the tiebreak at the end of the previous set of votes. Leave Love Alone only JUST makes it into the top 50. Not too many major losses here either, gutted about The More Boys I Meet and One Way Ticket not being a bit higher though, especially the latter which lost out to another song due to it not receiving any 10s. I've actually forgotten how Whenever You Remember and That's Where It Is go, oops. #flopstan

Twisted and Songs Like This FAR too low :(

Poor One Way Ticket... :cry:

Song of Choice: Starts With Goodbye
I guess it's gonna have to hurt, I guess I'm gonna have to cry, and let go of some things I've loved to get to the other side...

31. 8.50 Starts With Goodbye || Some Hearts (one 11, more 10s)
32. 8.50 I Ain't In Checotah Anymore || Some Hearts (one 11, less 10s)
33. 8.44 What Can I Say (feat. Sons of Sylvia) || Play On (one 11, two 9.5)
34. 8.44 Thank God For Hometowns || Blown Away (one 11, no 9.5s)
35. 8.38 Wheel of the World || Carnival Ride
36. 8.36 Home Sweet Home || N/A
37. 8.33 The Night Before (Life Goes On) (two 10s)
38. 8.33 Cupid's Got a Shotgun || Blown Away (one 10, one 9)
39. 8.33 Forever Changed || Blown Away (one 10, no 9s)
40. 8.27 Don't Forget to Remember Me || Some Hearts (one 10)

So after a break where I forgot had a life (lolz) we now enter tie central (Silas, your votes could've prevented this x), with Don't Forget To Remember Me just edging its way into the top 40, robbing One Way Ticket of that coveted spot. Next up is a personal song to Carrie, which comes in the form of Forever Changed. Carrie has previously said she will not be performing it live due to how personal it is. Later on, there's the fairly marmite track Thank God For Hometowns. I personally really like it but others aren't so fussed, meaning it finishes roughly in the middle here. Finally, Starts With Goodbye crashes out FAR too low. :cry:

Thank God for Hometowns, Don't Forget to Remember Me and Cupid's Got A Shotgun FAR too low. :(

Um bye at Home Sweet Home so low :mellow:

 

And Don't Forget To Remember me scraping top 40 :(

Song of Choice: Mama's Song
He is good, so good, and he treats your little girl like a real man should...

21. 8.83 Play On || Play On (more 10s, fewer 9.5s)
22. 8.83 Wasted || Some Hearts (fewer 10s)
23. 8.72 Flat On The Floor || Carnival Ride
24. 8.67 I Told You So || Carnival Ride (one 11)
25. 8.67 Change || Play On (no 11s, more 10s)
26. 8.67 Get Out Of This Town || Carnival Ride (no 11s, less 10s)
27. 8.61 Unapologize || Play On
28. 8.57 I'll Stand By You || N/A
29. 8.56 Mama's Song || Play On (one 11)
30. 8.56 Good In Goodbye || Blown Away (no 11s)

Now we're losing the REALLY good songs. Liam DEAD at Flat On The Floor and Wasted missing the top 20, and me dead at Change and Mama's Song doing the same. COME ON GUYS, where's the Mama's Song love? It's beautiful! The only songs I'm not too fussed with here are I Told You So and I'll Stand By You (Girls Aloud did it better, sorry Carrie).

This order is looking about right so far!! 'Forever Changed' is probably one I'd have liked a bit higher though!

This countdown is going terribly :( Flat On The Floor and Wasted are two of my Carrie faves, there are tracks above that are very weak by comparison. WHERE IS YOUR TASTE BUZZJACK?

This order is looking about right so far!! 'Forever Changed' is probably one I'd have liked a bit higher though!

http://s17.postimg.org/aikh7wurj/tumblr_m92lac_VBTK1rxvai0o4_250.gif

No.

Song of Choice: Two Black Cadillacs
The preacher said he was a good man, and his brother said he was a good friend, but the women in the two black veils didn't bother to cry...

11. 9.33 Some Hearts || Some Hearts (no 11s, same 10s, fewer 9.5s)
12. 9.28 Two Black Cadillacs || Blown Away (same 11s, more 10s)
13. 9.28 Who Are You || Blown Away (same 11s, fewer 10s)
14. 9.22 Jesus, Take The Wheel || Some Hearts
15. 9.17 Good Girl || Blown Away (no 11s, more 10s)
16. 9.17 Quitter || Play On (no 11s, fewer 10s)
17. 9.00 Last Name || Carnival Ride
18. 8.94 Inside Your Heaven || Some Hearts (higher score to more decimal places)
19. 8.94 There's a Place For Us || N/A (lower score to more decimal places)
20. 8.83 Undo It || Play On (more 10s, more 9.5s)

Some real shockers here. Firstly, the fact that Two Black Cadillacs and Jesus, Take the Wheel are not in the top 10 make me feel quite sad. Secondly, I can't believe Who Are You managed to get up this high! Lovely song but above Jesus, Take the Wheel, Good Girl and Last Name? I don't think so. I guess this shows exactly how strong the top 10 is though.

J,TTW is good but SO overrated.

YOUR TOP 10

http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/All-AmericanGirl-1.pnghttp://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/BeforeHeCheats.pnghttp://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/BlownAway.pnghttp://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/CowboyCasanova.pnghttp://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/EverEverAfter.png

All-American Girl
Before He Cheats
Blown Away
Cowboy Casanova
Ever Ever After
I Know You Won't
Just a Dream
See You Again
So Small
Temporary Home

http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/IKnowYouWont.pnghttp://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/JustaDream.pnghttp://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/SeeYouAgain.pnghttp://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/SoSmall.pnghttp://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/TemporaryHome.png

WHAT WILL WIN? PREDICTIONS PLEASE!