June 29, 201411 yr Melanie G's version of 'Word Up' is far superior. :smoke: ~ Sugababes I find 'Soul Sound' very underrated. :( It's a pretty uplifting song! 'Get Sexy' is a huge guilty pleasure of mine. Although at the time I wouldn't have said it would have needed to be filed under "guilty pleasure", as it seemed a lot of fans loved it back then. I honestly don't remember it being so hated in 2009. I guess Keisha being removed from the group a month after its release & all the subsequent drama has tarnished the memory of it. All Saints Quite surprised that 'Chick Fit' didn't come last actually - not that I'm saying it necessarily deserved to come last, but I think it's the biggest flop out of the whole list (bar the free download 'Freedom' :kink: ) so I thought it might not be very well known here. I'm still sad at how badly 'Studio 1' did! 'All Hooked Up' is probably my least favourite All Saints single, and it was a pity that this was the last single they released in their hey day... they went out on a bit of a low. Little Mix Dead @ Tulisa in that 'Cannonball' video still. :lol: I have such a soft spot for this track tbh - glad it didn't come last for them here.
June 29, 201411 yr Absolute RESULT for 'Girls' finishing last. One of the biggest abominations to ever be created in a recording studio and it has not one redeemable quality about it.
June 29, 201411 yr Author Absolute RESULT for 'Girls' finishing last. One of the biggest abominations to ever be created in a recording studio and it has not one redeemable quality about it. I'm quite partial to the Klas Åhlund rework every now and then, that really should've been the single version.
June 29, 201411 yr No, Get Sexy was a laughing stock back when it was released to be fair. Cannonball is awful and deserves it, especially having such a thematically dissonant song for an X Factor winner :lol: Such an anathema of an anthem! I liked All Hooked Up but yeah they did seem to fizzle out. So ridiculous that the heydey of the two biggest Uk girl bands was so short.
June 29, 201411 yr I hope they performed Holler at the INJUSTICE of some of these basic RATES? Justice 4 Holler. :( I don't expect to see it in the top half of these results, sadly!
June 29, 201411 yr Hmm. Not really the bottom ten I would have hoped for. 'All Hooked Up', 'Soul Sound', 'Chick Fit' and maybe even 'No Can Do' deserve better, or at least to finish above trash like 'Beautiful Cause You Love Me'. The next lot needs to feature a Girls Aloud cull really. I'm actually a little surprised the lowest All Saints songs aren't the forgettable covers. 'Girls' coming last is definitely the right result though. A song with no redeeming qualities.
June 29, 201411 yr Very glad 'Get Sexy' and 'Freedom' are in the bottom 10, shame about the other Sugababes songs being in there. Their discography definitely got the least consistent ratings, with lots of highs and lows though, so I suppose it should have been expected. The Sats need to start losing a few now though.
June 29, 201411 yr Justice 4 Holler. :( I don't expect to see it in the top half of these results, sadly! Me either :( Pop trash by basic new bands will be higher of course :rolleyes:
June 29, 201411 yr Author 90. GENTLEMAN / The Saturdays 5.23 F5luP09KWqA 9.5 Totto 9 Let Go For 2nite, Dobbo, Hayzayy, Doug --- 0 152chris, Calum Hood, Michael! -1 Jahq, Simon, TheSatsLadyGaga, Cameron, Dandy 89. HEADLINES (FRIENDSHIP NEVER ENDS) / Spice Girls 5.25 VMo6v_uFZKU 10 JSG, Michael! 9 GRIFF, Regina, missingyou, Let Go For 2nite, Mike Sugafan --- 0 RabbitFurCoat, Wallzus, Hayzayy, Dandy -1 152chris, mr_aly, Leonardo, JoeP, Chez Wombat, Aled, Davidson 88. WAR OF NERVES / All Saints 5.33 A-vaHR2roxQ 11 Totto 9 GRIFF, gooddelta, Mike Sugafan, AaronTM --- 0 Rob S, Calum Hood -1 DionTheSats123 87. ANGELS WITH DIRTY FACES / Sugababes 5.42 dCDXh2Fc284 10 Totto, Jade, Michael! 9 JSG --- 0 Martyn -1 Wallzus, Cameron, DionTheSats123 86. I THINK WE'RE ALONE NOW / Girls Aloud 5.43 WjpbcsttFyM 11 jsilv 10 JSG, Let Go For 2nite --- 0 Electro Paradise, Michael! -1 Rob S The Saturdays just avoid a bottom 10 placing as 'Gentleman' finishes at 90. Personally I think this song is very underrated and is a great piece of girl band pop. 'And then they wonder why most girls just spit it' *.* This means Spice Girls are the last group to lose a single as 2007 comeback track 'Headlines' is at 89. Not really the comeback they hoped for, as the Children In Need track charted at #11. Oops! 'War Of Nerves' by All Saints is at 88. I couldn't remember this at all when I listened back to their singles a few weeks ago. Powerpuff Girls ANTHEM 'Angels With Dirty Faces' finishes at 87. This release was really overshadowed by the other double A-side single 'Stronger', it isn't really that bad. Finally Girls Aloud lose their 2006 Christmas release, a cover of 'I Think We're Alone Now'. I actually quite like the single version of this, greatly improved from the original version that appeared on The Sound of Girls Aloud.
June 29, 201411 yr May I also say what an absolute travesty the gorgeously calming 'Soul Sound' has been beaten by the soul destroying 'Get Sexy'. Early Sugas ftw :(
June 29, 201411 yr I only gave AWDF a ten because of the Powerful Girls :lol: The actual song is pretty :blink: I like Headlines :(
June 29, 201411 yr 'I Think We Are Alone Now' is definitely Girls Aloud's worst so I am glad to see it bow out first. Hope a few of their other cover's are next, their covers were always their weakest.
June 29, 201411 yr Very pleased that Girls Aloud's worst two singles (imo) 'I Think We're Alone Now' and 'Walk This Way' are their bottom 2! I like both, but the vast majority of their discography is far superior to these two covers. Probably right that 'Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)' is last for the Spice Girls, as much as I like it. I don't believe 'Gentleman' to be the worst single by The Saturdays, although it's certainly in their bottom third.
June 29, 201411 yr Really excited for this reveal. Supporting 'Viva Forever' all the way but a lot of gems to come. No huge losses so far and a lot i expected to come bottom quarter. 'Headlines' really isn't that bad at all though, was shocked it got so many negative points.
Create an account or sign in to comment