Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 398
  • Views 19.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

One of my favourite songs of all time, girl group or not. So many memories and emotions every time i listen :cry: Perfection, perfection, perfection.

 

Team 'About You Now' although 'Pure Shores' is very worthy too and definitely the more renowned song of the two.

  • Author

DRUM ROLL PLEASE

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

02. ABOUT YOU NOW / Sugababes 9.16

11 Insomnio, Eyes, HausofKubrick, gooddelta, Wallzus, *Tim, JosephStyles, Ultraviolence, Calum Hood, Dobbo, Michael!, DionTheSats123, Juliano, Doug

10 152chris, Jahq, RabbitFurCoat, Regina, troylovesmusic, Simon, AdamAloud, JoeP, NiallMinogue, missingyou, Aled, JSG, Rob S, Jonjo, Cameron, Let Go For 2nite, April, Jack, CallumC97, Jay, AaronTM, LaLa2586, Dandy

---

2 Hayzayy

-1 Totto

 

It was close but in the end Sugababes take second place with the ever amazing 'About You Now'. After the slightly underwhelming Greatest Hits era everything looked set to be OK when 3.0 unleashed this mega hit on us. I don't know who this Totto thinks he is giving -1's to all these classics??

 

That means, against ALL THE ODDS...

 

 

01. PURE SHORES / All Saints 9.29

11 Martyn, 152chris, Insomnio, kellyannmarie, JoeP, Chez Wombat, missingyou, Aled, SceneofSIXCrimes, JSG, Liam, Jade, Davidson, n4yr, pippa, Jack, jsilv, Jay, Juliano, Doug

10 GRIFF, Nick F1, AdamAloud, NiallMinogue, Rob S, Dane, April, Mike Sugafan, Michael!, DionTheSats123, Dandy

---

6 RabbitFurCoat, Totto, Calum Hood

1 Hayzayy

 

YES! Who would've thought it! Well a staggering 20 11's and 12 10's 'Pure Shores' takes the crown and is Buzzjack's favourite girl band single of 2014. After the Saints were losing so many, let's be honest, terrible singles, things looked bleak for the Saints. But here we are with them having the winning single! It is SUCH a classic track I can't even argue with it winning. And I've been thinking about it since doing this results, but none of the other bands could do this song as well as All Saints could. They absolutely MAKE IT.

 

Before I finish, here are the averages for each girl band:

 

6th. All Saints / 6.82

5th. Little Mix / 6.84

4th. Sugababes / 6.86

3rd. The Saturdays / 7.41

2nd. Spice Girls / 7.44

1st. Girls Aloud / 7.5

 

I'll post a list of the entire top 100 shortly. Thank you to everyone who voted and commented for this rate. It's truly been a joy to revisit all these girlband classics and to see the results unfold and change with every vote was very exciting! I hope you've enjoyed it as much as me!

 

YASSSSSS :wub: that'd definitely be in my top 5 of the whole rate, such a classic, perfect song.

 

 

Thanks for this Adam, it's been good to have my memory jogged of some of these songs!

Surprised to see it win, and I'm disappointed for About You Now, but still, good winner! About You Now is definitely my favourite girlband song ever.

 

THANKS FOR HOSTING THIS ALL ADAM, it's been absolutely flawless and amazingly hosted. You really need to win BJSC soon.

  • Author

Top 100

 

1. All Saints - Pure Shores / 9.29

2. Sugababes - About You Now / 9.16

3. Spice Girls - Viva Forever / 8.98

4. Girls Aloud - Sound Of The Underground / 8.89

5. The Saturdays - Ego / 8.85

6. Sugababes - Hole In The Head / 8.81

7. Little Mix - DNA / 8.76

8. Spice Girls - Spice Up Your Life / 8.73

9. The Saturdays - Higher (ft. Flo Rida) / 8.69 (more 11's)

10. Sugababes - Too Lost In You / 8.69

11. The Saturdays - Up / 8.66 (more 11's)

12. All Saints - Never Ever / 8.66

13. Sugababes - Freak Like Me / 8.61

14. Little Mix - Move / 8.6

15. Girls Aloud - Untouchable / 8.53

16. Girls Aloud - Biology / 8.48 (more 11's)

17. Sugababes - Push The Button / 8.48

18. Girls Aloud - Call The Shots / 8.45

19. Spice Girls - 2 Become 1 / 8.42

20. Girls Aloud - The Show / 8.33

21. The Saturdays - All Fired Up / 8.33

22. Sugababes - Round Round / 8.31

23. Spice Girls - Say You'll Be There / 8.3

24. Spice Girls - Wannabe / 8.27

25. The Saturdays - What About Us (ft. Sean Paul) / 8.24

26. Girls Aloud - No Good Advice / 8.22

27. Spice Girls - Stop / 8.15

28. Sugababes - Stronger / 8.07

29. Girls Aloud - Sexy! No No No… / 8.05

30. Girls Aloud - The Loving Kind / 7.97

31. Sugababes - Ugly / 7.9

32. All Saints - Black Coffee / 7.89 (more 11's)

33. Girls Aloud - Something Kinda Ooooh / 7.89

34. Girls Aloud - Something New / 7.85

35. Girls Aloud - Love Machine / 7.78 (more 11's)

36. Spice Girls - Goodbye / 7.78

37. Sugababes - Overload / 7.76

38. The Saturdays - Disco Love / 7.75 (more 11's)

39. Spice Girls - Who Do You Think You Are / 7.75

40. Sugababes - Red Dress / 7.69

41. The Saturdays - Notorious / 7.68

42. Sugababes - Change / 7.65

43. All Saints - Rock Steady / 7.63

44. Sugababes - Denial / 7.62

45. The Saturdays - Issues / 7.61

46. The Saturdays - Work / 7.56

47. Little Mix - Salute / 7.44 (more 11's)

48. Sugababes - In The Middle / 7.44

49. Sugababes - Easy / 7.38

50. Girls Aloud - The Promise / 7.34

51. The Saturdays - Not Giving Up / 7.31

52. Sugababes - Caught In A Moment / 7.28

53. Little Mix - Wings / 7.22

54. The Saturdays - Missing You / 7.17

55. Sugababes - About A Girl / 7.16

56. Girls Aloud - Can't Speak French / 7.13

57. Spice Girls - Too Much / 7.09

58. Girls Aloud - Wake Me Up / 6.96

59. The Saturdays - My Heart Takes Over / 6.95 (more 11's)

60. Little Mix - Little Me / 6.95

61. Sugababes - Run For Cover / 6.92

62. The Saturdays - If This Is Love / 6.87

63. Girls Aloud - Jump / 6.8

64. Girls Aloud - Life Got Cold / 6.73

65. Little Mix - Change Your Life / 6.7

66. All Saints - I Know Where It's At / 6.61

67. Spice Girls - Mama / 6.6

68. The Saturdays - Forever Is Over / 6.5

69. Girls Aloud - I'll Stand By You / 6.41

70. The Saturdays - 30 Days / 6.38

71. The Saturdays - Just Can't Get Enough / 6.21

72. Little Mix - How Ya Doin'? (ft. Missy Elliott) / 6.06

73. Girls Aloud - Whole Lotta History / 6.06

74. Girls Aloud - Long Hot Summer / 6.01

75. All Saints - Bootie Call / 5.94

76. Sugababes - Wear My Kiss / 5.93

77. Girls Aloud - Beautiful 'Cause You Love Me / 5.92

78. Sugababes - Follow Me Home / 5.9

79. Sugababes - Shape / 5.87

80. Spice Girls - Holler / 5.72

81. Spice Girls - Let Love Lead The Way / 5.65

82. All Saints - Lady Marmalade / 5.6

83. Sugababes - New Year / 5.51

84. Girls Aloud - See The Day / 5.47

85. All Saints - Under The Bridge / 5.44

86. Girls Aloud - I Think We're Alone Now / 5.43

87. Sugababes - Angels With Dirty Faces / 5.42

88. All Saints - War Of Nerves / 5.33

89. Spice Girls - Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) / 5.25

90. The Saturdays - Gentleman / 5.23

91. Sugababes - Get Sexy / 5.21

92. Little Mix - Cannonball / 5.17

93. All Saints - All Hooked Up / 5.11

94. All Saints - Chick Fit / 5.03

95. Sugababes - Soul Sound / 4.91

96. Sugababes - No Can Do / 4.87

97. Sugababes - Freedom / 4.7

98. Girls Aloud vs. Sugababes - Walk This Way / 4.63

99. Little Mix - Word Up! / 4.61

100. Sugababes - Girls / 4.19

 

  • Author
Surprised to see it win, and I'm disappointed for About You Now, but still, good winner! About You Now is definitely my favourite girlband song ever.

 

THANKS FOR HOSTING THIS ALL ADAM, it's been absolutely flawless and amazingly hosted. You really need to win BJSC soon.

 

You always seem to back the runner-up Rob! Whether it's rates, BJSC or Melodifestivalen! :lol:

 

Here's hoping this month's fabulous pop track takes Sandebörg all the way! :wub:

You always seem to back the runner-up Rob! Whether it's rates, BJSC or Melodifestivalen! :lol:

 

Here's hoping this month's fabulous pop track takes Sandebörg all the way! :wub:

I really am! :( I actually think I put the kiss of death on these things.

Could have been better winners but it's still a good song. Big thanks for doing this (and so quick :o)!
'Pure Shores' is by far All Saints best song. :wub: So pleased it beat 'About You Now'. :D

What a terrific winner! 'Pure Shores' is absolutely perfect. :wub:

 

Thanks so much for doing this rate Adam, it's been very enjoyable! :D

YES for Pure Shores winning :wub: That song brings back so many memories, I always forget just how good it is. It has aged surprisingly well too.

 

Thanks for doing this Adam, honestly one of the best countdowns on here in a while I think.

After all of this, i think i have finally seen the light for 'Holler' too :drama: Michael's impact? :S

 

Now i really need to dig out Sugababes/All Saints discographies and get listening too...

2 Overrated tracks as the top 2 imo beating 3 amazing songs at #3,#4 and #5 but each to their own.
After all of this, i think i have finally seen the light for 'Holler' too :drama: Michael's impact? :S

 

Now i really need to dig out Sugababes/All Saints discographies and get listening too...

You would love All Saints I think, the majority of their material has aged pretty well too.

'Pure Shores' is an absolute wonderful winner. Definitely one of the best girlband songs of all time.

 

Notable mention for 'Sound Of The Underground' and 'Too Lost In You' doing so well and also Girls Aloud getting the highest discography average despite only having 1 song in top 14.

Not Totto giving -1's to all the best songs :drama:

 

Thanks for doing this countdown Adam! It was flawless apart from the winner

Edited by *Tim

Oh my, I would've never have predicted that winner but what an amazing song and worthy winner, probably my favourite song in the whole rate :wub: Actually really happy with each act's highest song, they're all really great. Little Mix excepted it must be said, DNA has aged really badly and isn't anything on Move, REALLY shocked those two weren't in each other's places.

 

Excellently hosted Adam, this has been quite the success!

Edited by Chez Wombat

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.