http://www.josepvinaixa.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Mutya-Keisha-Siobhan.png

 

http://cdn.idolator.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/Sugababes-Loaded-crop-2011.jpg

Edited July 5, 201411 yr by Alex.

As if it's a choice! #teammks.

 

You've chosen very apt pictures. There's the classy MKS then there's 4.0....

I want the best of both worlds. I want Heidi, Mutya, Siobhán.

But Heidi in Keisha's place would change the 3-part harmony too much. Heidi lacks that power and has too different a vocal style and ability imo to take that place.

There isn't enough material to judge, imo. Freedom > Flatline but yeah I'd rather listen to the Saturdays...

There isn't enough material to judge, imo.

"Sweet 7" for 4.0 and "One Touch" for 1.0 (MKS)

There isn't enough material to judge, imo. Freedom > Flatline but yeah I'd rather listen to the Saturdays...

Really? Christ you must hate Flatline :lol:

"Sweet 7" for 4.0 and "One Touch" for 1.0 (MKS)

For once you make a valid point! While Crash & Burn is the only true 4.0 track on the album it gives a good indication of harmonies etc.

It's quite easily MKS.

I enjoy the "I like nobody, I'm the Saturdays' fan" option. :kink:

 

I like music from both 1.0 and 4.0, but ultimately I'd go for 1.0. They were the soul of the Sugababes, and a bit of that soul continued into 2.0 and 3.0... but it left the building with 4.0.

4.0 for me. Best Sugababes line-up.

 

The small problem I have with this poll is that it overlooks 2.0 and 3.0 entirely. I'd doubt that we had a poster here who only liked either 1.0 or 4.0 and hated everything either after or up to that point.

The small problem I have with this poll is that it overlooks 2.0 and 3.0 entirely. I'd doubt that we had a poster here who only liked either 1.0 or 4.0 and hated everything either after or up to that point.

 

1. I'm here for this option.

2. There is no chance to see 2.0 or 3.0 line-up together again.

 

MKS obv

"Sweet 7" for 4.0 and "One Touch" for 1.0 (MKS)

 

Well then definitely 100% MKS.

 

But I much prefer 'Freedom' to 'Flatline'.

1. I'm here for this option.

2. There is no chance to see 2.0 or 3.0 line-up together again.

Point 2 is disregarding what my post was about. Nobody here only likes 1.0 or 4.0. Everyone here liked some amount of 2.0 and 3.0 material also.

 

If you're telling me you only like 4.0 and never liked anything else they ever did, I'd find that very difficult to believe. Mainly because anyone that thinks Freedom can hold a candle to things like Freak, Round Round, Push The Button et al needs sectioning for the safety of society.

Point 2 is disregarding what my post was about. Nobody here only likes 1.0 or 4.0. Everyone here liked some amount of 2.0 and 3.0 material also.

 

If you're telling me you only like 4.0 and never liked anything else they ever did, I'd find that very difficult to believe. Mainly because anyone that thinks Freedom can hold a candle to things like Freak, Round Round, Push The Button et al needs sectioning for the safety of society.

 

Don't get me wrong. I like some songs from 2.0 and 3.0, but dislike Mutya and Keisha, so 4.0 was my favourite line-up.

I prefer "Freedom" above all mentioned songs. "Freak Like Me", "Round Round" and "Hole And The Head" are really weak.

 

That all might be true but you're NOT THE ONLY PERSON HERE.

2.0 > 1.0 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3.0 >>>>...>>>>> being bludgeoned to death by a rotting carcass of a skunk > 4.0 > The Saturdays > nothing

2.0 > 1.0 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3.0 >>>>...>>>>> being bludgeoned to death by a rotting carcass of a skunk > 4.0 > The Saturdays > nothing

 

Cunterella :smoke: