I'd forgotten just how much Pavel hated the Sats :lol:

 

I'd agree with the ordering of the Babes line-ups but id probably put the Sats above 4.0.

Nobody, I'm a sats fan

 

(I quite like both tho, Freedom is great, but so is flatline.)

((Was About You Now 4.0? Or was that 3.0? Damnit this is all so confusing))

Edited July 7, 201411 yr by *Tim

About You Now was 3.0. 4.0 wishes it did something that good or successful.

4.0 only got to release 2 singles so it shouldn't be that confusing :lol:

I don't think putting Freedom on Amazon for free and STILL NOT HAVING PEOPLE DOWNLOAD IT makes it a proper release~

Counting Freedom would have made it 3 pav :P

 

About A Girl and Wear My Kiss would be the 2 referred to

Nobody, I'm a sats fan

 

(I quite like both tho, Freedom is great, but so is flatline.)

((Was About You Now 4.0? Or was that 3.0? Damnit this is all so confusing))

 

In summary:

 

1.0 (Keisha, Mutya, Siobhan)

Overload, New Year, Run For Cover, Soul Sound [One Touch]

Flatline

 

2.0 (Keisha, Mutya, Heidi)

Freak Like Me, Round Round, Stronger, Angels With Dirty Faces, Shape [Angels With Dirty Faces]

Hole In The Head, Too Lost In You, In The Middle, Caught In A Moment [Three]

Push The Button, Ugly [Taller In More Ways]

 

3.0 (Keisha, Amelle, Heidi)

Red Dress, Follow Me Home [Taller In More Ways (Re-release)]

Easy [Overloaded - The Singles Collection]

Walk This Way

About You Now, Change, Denial [Change]

Girls, No Can Do [Catfights & Spotlights]

Get Sexy [sweet 7 (Sampler)]

 

4.0 (Jade, Amelle, Heidi)

About A Girl, Wear My Kiss [sweet 7]

Freedom

 

^_^

In summary:

 

1.0 (Keisha, Mutya, Siobhan)

Overload, New Year, Run For Cover, Soul Sound [One Touch]

Flatline

 

2.0 (Keisha, Mutya, Heidi)

Freak Like Me, Round Round, Stronger, Angels With Dirty Faces, Shape [Angels With Dirty Faces]

Hole In The Head, Too Lost In You, In The Middle, Caught In A Moment [Three]

Push The Button, Ugly [Taller In More Ways]

 

3.0 (Keisha, Amelle, Heidi)

Red Dress, Follow Me Home [Taller In More Ways (Re-release)]

Easy [Overloaded - The Singles Collection]

Walk This Way

About You Now, Change, Denial [Change]

Girls, No Can Do [Catfights & Spotlights]

Get Sexy [sweet 7 (Sampler)]

 

4.0 (Jade, Amelle, Heidi)

About A Girl, Wear My Kiss [sweet 7]

Freedom

 

^_^

This clears it all!

 

In that case definately 1.0 because Overload>>>>

2.0 > 1.0 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3.0 >>>>...>>>>> being bludgeoned to death by a rotting carcass of a skunk > 4.0 > The Saturdays > nothing

 

:lol:

 

'All Fired Up' justifies their existence though.

This clears it all!

 

In that case definately 1.0 because Overload>>>>

Wise choice my friend!

 

In summary:

 

1.0 (Keisha, Mutya, Siobhan)

Overload, New Year, Run For Cover, Soul Sound [One Touch]

Flatline

 

2.0 (Keisha, Mutya, Heidi)

Freak Like Me, Round Round, Stronger, Angels With Dirty Faces, Shape [Angels With Dirty Faces]

Hole In The Head, Too Lost In You, In The Middle, Caught In A Moment [Three]

Push The Button, Ugly [Taller In More Ways]

 

3.0 (Keisha, Amelle, Heidi)

Red Dress, Follow Me Home [Taller In More Ways (Re-release)]

Easy [Overloaded - The Singles Collection]

Walk This Way

About You Now, Change, Denial [Change]

Girls, No Can Do [Catfights & Spotlights]

Get Sexy [sweet 7 (Sampler)]

 

4.0 (Jade, Amelle, Heidi)

About A Girl, Wear My Kiss [sweet 7]

Freedom

 

^_^

 

Only 4.0 line-up had 100 % result, all 3 singles were # 1s in my chart. :yahoo:

In the terms a quality of singles best period : 3.0 from "Follow Me Home" to "Denial" (only "About You Now" is not perfect)

2.0 era is a hit or shit.

Sugababes is only Heidi for me, so I don't care about 1.0.

Edited July 8, 201411 yr by Alex.

Thing is though I can't judge 4.0 on Sweet 7 due to the fact Keisha had vocals on all but 1 song. It's 3.0 material covered by 4.0. However Freedom was a delight, marginally better than Flatline. So in summary I went for both.

I prefer 4.0 but I am hoping for music from both :P

I've voted both. I think each member of the Sugababes has brought something new to the band, all six members can sing. Sweet 7 can't really be attributed to 4.0 in my opinion, yes it was released with Jade but it was written, recorded and produced with Keisha. The two original songs we've heard from 4.0, Freedom & Crash and Burn, are great songs and Freedom is much better than Flatline IMO.

 

2.0 will always be the ultimate, real Sugababes line-up though regardless of Heidi not being an original.

i am so tired of waiting for MKS + very uch bored

i Miss Heidi and Sugaz 4.0

I wish Jade replaced Amelle instead of Keisha! It would've been an amazing line-up to have had Keisha, Heidi and Jade.

Jade just doesn't fit the Sugababes mould for me, maybe it's because we knew her before she came in, I'm not sure.

I'll go for MKS but:

I want the best of both worlds. I want Heidi, Mutya, Siobhán Keisha.

Honestly 2.0 FTW

Those were the days :(

Don't like 2.0, solo career for Heidi. :cheer: