Jamelia has Beware Of The Dog and Superstar but Alesha has the life alteringly amazing Drummer Boy *.* so, Alesha.

As if Beverley Knight is lumped in with Shaznay Lewis and JAVINE. Out of the five named in the poll she's basically in another league, so she'd win it for me.

 

In terms of Alesha vs Jamelia. I think I slightly lean towards Alesha, though I feel her music has aged worse than Jamelia's and I prefer Jamelia as a person because she's sassy. Soooo yeah.

Yeah, I really find Alesha to be a bit basic personality wise.

I think Alesha has an amazing personality. :o and that laugh as well!

 

I'd love to meet her.

I picked Jamelia as I still listen to her songs all the time. She also picked great singles.. (Something About You, Beware of the Dog, Superstar, See It In A Boys Eyes, DJ :wub:)

Plus, I think being on Loose Women has given her a bit more shelf life.. at least the 'daytime audience' know who she is now :lol: and she's a bit of a b!tch on there which I love.

It's definitely made me like her more. She's one of the more likeable panelists for me.

 

Alesha had a few good tracks but I feel like she kinda lost herself and now she's quite happy being one of Cowell's 'girls'.

Edited July 16, 201411 yr by Scherz

Love both of them but I ended up going to Jamelia because her discography is a little bit more consistent.

Easily Jamelia :heart:

 

I remember the times we had a Jamelia forum ^_^ what happened to the member Off Da Endz :unsure:

I think Alesha has an amazing personality. :o and that laugh as well!

 

I'd love to meet her.

 

I've never met Alesha, but I've met Jamelia. She's lovely, and was very down to earth but also very funny.

I like both but prefer Jamelia. I still play her Best Of every once in a while.

Jamelia for me loved her since 'I Do' and followed her since, Alesha I love on talent panels and as part of Mis-teeq but not solo

Jamelia by far. I agree with the above comments of Alesha on talent shows and bands. I love 'Thank You' and 'See It In A Boys Eyes' by Jamelia :wub:

Edited July 17, 201411 yr by Cameron

I went for Jamelia, she's had much better singles such as (Superstar, Something About You, Thank You & Beware Of The Dog). To be honest I do like Alisha Dixon, but as for her songs only 2 I like Lipstick and The Boy Does Nothing

You people disappoint me so. :(

 

Jamelia does have the "Javine is a slag" thing on Never Mind The Buzzcocks in her favour though.