June 11, 20205 yr Need all of this to happen :cry: 7" vinyl collection for the singles would be amazing! Let me throw more of my money at you, Spice Girls -_- Oh that's strange, I'm not sure why they wouldn't be showing up for you! :o These are the images at the top of each section: http://i.imgur.com/1R37tzom.jpghttp://i.imgur.com/QSKTN9zm.jpg http://i.imgur.com/N7G1r1vm.jpg http://i.imgur.com/3g2Wen2m.jpg Can you see the single/album artworks? :cry: I can only see the artworks, not the banners... how strange...
June 11, 20205 yr I've decided from now on I'm going to use the Scottish, independent and physicals chart only for my official Melanie C discography, just look at this chart run :lol: 1. Northern Star (1999) [#3] 2. Reason (2003) [#5] 3. Beautiful Intentions (2005) [#9] 4. This Time (2007) [#57] <_< 5. The Sea (2011) [#6] 6. Stages (2012) [#7] 7. Version Of Me (2016) [#2] :yahoo: 1. When you're gone (with Bryan Adams) [#2] 2. Going down [#3] 3. Northern star [#4] 4. Never be the same again (feat Lisa Left Eye Lopez) [#1] 5. I turn to you [#1] 6. If that were me [#18] 7. Here it comes again [#6] 8. On the horizon [#12] 9. Melt / Yeh, yeh, yeh [#27] 10. Next best superstar [#8] 11. I want candy [#9] 12. Carolyna [#19] 13. This time [#32] 14. Think about it [#15] 15. Weak [#29] 16. I know him so well (with Emma Bunton) [#14] 17. I don't know how to love him [#20] 18. Loving you (with Matt Cardle) [#2] 19. Anymore [#1] :w00t: 20. Who I am [#37] 21. Blame it on me [#61] One can dream eh. Ps Jay didn't you have some physical chart positions for some of the other singles on the UK chart? I'm sure I remember seeing I want candy would have been #7 without downloads and Geri's Desire would have been top 20, I want to say Carolyna would have been top 20 too?? Also how come we don't have independent chart positions for BI and TT?? Edited June 11, 20205 yr by Spiceboy
June 11, 20205 yr :cry: I can only see the artworks, not the banners... how strange... I changed the display modes and now they now appear! Might have had some issues with cookies or whatever... ANYWAY crisis averted :cheer:
June 11, 20205 yr Just seen the sale updates lol, Thanks Jay. Viva Forever and Goodbye deserve to be millionaires. And does this mean the real successful solo spice is Geri? :kink:
June 11, 20205 yr Just seen the sale updates lol, Thanks Jay. Viva Forever and Goodbye deserve to be millionaires. And does this mean the real successful solo spice is Geri? :kink:
June 11, 20205 yr Guess who doesn't need the collab at all? :kink: I'll re-word that... "Guess who couldn't get a collab at all?" Ooh your gif answered it :P
June 11, 20205 yr Author I’m guessing that is based on their singles runs, i.e. Schizophonic singles being more consistent than Northern Star’s. Scream If You Wanna Faster outsold Reason, had a huge hit single, and two further singles that outsold anything Melanie released after Northern Star album. Also the fact that Geri has more #1 singles. Melanie C has Northern Star (album sales) & two Gold #1s on her side, plus perseverance to release far more than Geri. (Comments from a UK charts perspective). It’s clear they’re the top two solo Spice Girls commercially, and both have different achievements!
June 11, 20205 yr I'll re-word that... "Guess who couldn't get a collab at all?" Ooh your gif answered it :P I mean we aren't discussing who's the most talented, are we?
June 11, 20205 yr Geri is so talented that she ends up writing and recording several albums only to shelve them because she's afraid she'll overshadow the Melanies and Emmarrr :wub:
June 11, 20205 yr I’m guessing that is based on their singles runs, i.e. Schizophonic singles being more consistent than Northern Star’s. Scream If You Wanna Faster outsold Reason, had a huge hit single, and two further singles that outsold anything Melanie released after Northern Star album. Also the fact that Geri has more #1 singles. Melanie C has Northern Star (album sales) & two Gold #1s on her side, plus perseverance to release far more than Geri. (Comments from a UK charts perspective). It’s clear they’re the top two solo Spice Girls commercially, and both have different achievements! Plus, the other girls needed collabs to open the era and break free, Geri didn't and did all that pure solo, she even made the cover the huge hit lol, not to mention she's the weakest singer/performer among them too lol.
June 11, 20205 yr Emma the only one of them to release 4 albums with an actual label, I think we know she is solo Spice queen.
June 11, 20205 yr Emma the only one of them to release 4 albums with an actual label, I think we know she is solo Spice queen. Plus, at least she has actual tallent lol :cheer:
June 11, 20205 yr I’m guessing that is based on their singles runs, i.e. Schizophonic singles being more consistent than Northern Star’s. Scream If You Wanna Faster outsold Reason, had a huge hit single, and two further singles that outsold anything Melanie released after Northern Star album. Also the fact that Geri has more #1 singles. Melanie C has Northern Star (album sales) & two Gold #1s on her side, plus perseverance to release far more than Geri. (Comments from a UK charts perspective). It’s clear they’re the top two solo Spice Girls commercially, and both have different achievements! - Melanie has been far more successful internationally than Geri - In the UK, Melanie has sold much more albums - Melanie has sold hundreds of thousands of tickets I think we have a winner! :cheer:
June 11, 20205 yr Guys guys guys stop seriously, it's not a competition between the girls! Because Melanie's already won it :lol:
June 11, 20205 yr Melanie C's first album has sold more in the UK than ALL of Geri Halliwell's albums to date. The same for international success. Plus, Mel C has had other international hit singles and albums throughout her career. Geri didnt. End of discussion. Edited June 11, 20205 yr by Mr.X
June 11, 20205 yr Melanie C's first album has sold more in the UK than ALL of Geri Halliwell's albums to date. The same for international success. Plus, Mel C has had other international hit singles and albums throughout her career. Geri didnt. End of discussion. With the help of Bryan Adams and Left Eye. Three of them, Melanie, Emma and Geri all did have the hits here in Asia. Never Be The Same Again, What Took You So Long and It's Raining Men but then again TLC was very popular in Asia as well. It's Raining Men was a soundtrack of Bridget Jones which was a hit globally, people at that time probably didn't buy the song or the album but they surely knew It's Raining Men's Geri version. Geri was painted as somewhat Brit Madonna and there were a lot of controversies among the music gurus over here back then too lol. The whole point was just that she did it on her own in her own ways and very successful, didn't mean to take anything away from Melanie. Geri is brilliant for me but she's selfish and lacks grit.
June 11, 20205 yr Author Editing Victoria Beckham's posts now. Music Week stated at the time that A Mind of Its Own sold below 24,000 in its first week. http://scans.chartarchive.org/UK/2002/UK%2...02002.02.23.pdf I'm not sure where the 27,000 figure came from that has been generally accepted as being the first week figure for many years - I can't find a source for it! So I'll take <24,000 as being true.
