'Robbie Williams is a perfect judge' - says Louis Walsh of his X Factor replacement

 

https://www.independent.ie/entertainment/te...t-37296082.html

STAR IS BORN X Factor contestant Natasha Boon hailed as ‘next Amy Winehouse’ by Robbie Williams

The audience went wild and Robbie Williams showered her with praise, calling her 'a diamond in the rough'

 

https://www.thesun.co.uk/tvandshowbiz/72103...obbie-williams/

I am enjoying Robbie but i cant take to Ayda at all, i dont know what it is about her but i just cant warm to her.

RW being curious. No way did he mean to be disrespectful.

 

I thought tonight was OK. I really liked this Felix and the two very young girls. Robbie - gorgeous. B-)

 

 

https://t.co/i3O156LWHQ

 

 

http://i64.tinypic.com/dqj0qh.png

 

 

RW being curious. No way did he mean to be disrespectful.

 

I thought tonight was OK. I really liked this Felix and the two very young girls. Robbie - gorgeous. B-)

https://t.co/i3O156LWHQ

http://i64.tinypic.com/dqj0qh.png

 

 

Louis is on his side so he will be fine :lol: , Things can only get better :banana:

That is all we need , Pete Conway standing in as judge , I like the guy but Robbie will not endear the tv audiences by turning the X Factor into the Robbie Williams show :(

 

it's bloody awful :blink:

That is all we need , Pete Conway standing in as judge , I like the guy but Robbie will not endear the tv audiences by turning the X Factor into the Robbie Williams show :(

 

it's bloody awful :blink:

 

There were two acts on there I actually cared about tonight.

 

Tommy the guitar guy was at the Six Chair Challenge I saw. I love his quirky lyrics. He's my favourite f all four auditions so far. He actually fell off the stage in his excitement on the night we were there :o

 

I'm rooting for Scarlett too because she's from Epsom. :)

 

 

Programme was OK again for me tonight. Not great but OK.

 

 

 

I am wondering how this will turn out at the end for Robbie. With his personality everything becomes the RW show at one point. But when he was on his peak people in the majority loved it, now it seems to turn the majority off. It is all very PC these days, anything he isn't. At least the x-factor gets a lot of headlines everywhere.

I am wondering how this will turn out at the end for Robbie. With his personality everything becomes the RW show at one point. But when he was on his peak people in the majority loved it, now it seems to turn the majority off. It is all very PC these days, anything he isn't. At least the x-factor gets a lot of headlines everywhere.

 

 

Very true what you say Elisabeth , Robbie will go back to his day job , I doubt this will have any impact on his own career , some folk love him , others do not & that has always been the case . I guess they are having family time now with the new baby & then it starts again with the XF & his tour. How many of the live shows is he doing , I see nothing definite about it except that Sharon O is stepping in for him , is he going to miss them all , the live shows are always better than the auditions as the silly acts are well gone by then , I would not mind seeing him on those

Nice pic from Metro.uk

 

 

http://i67.tinypic.com/124kfmc.jpg

I think Sharon is an additional judge. he will miss two live shows out of six.

I have not watched the x-factor yet, but I assume that they have cut it so that it is controversial and who is giving this away better than 'without filter' Rob.

Let's see where this will end.

I have to say that I am wondering - curious me - if indeed Teddy will be a flower girl at this wedding and if he will then stop the protection of her at least. Somehow I cannot believe this after the post of Ayda about Coco.

X Factor's transgender contestant Felix defends Robbie Williams ...

 

https://www.thesun.co.uk › x-fac...

 

Aww this makes me feel quite sad for Robbie. He did ask permission to ask the question. Gary warned him about that editing...

 

 

Sorry I think I've got the link wrong. We're in Devon and I'm on my phone :rolleyes:

Edited September 10, 20186 yr by Laura130262

Apparently Judges Houses are being filmed this week in LA.

X Factor's transgender contestant Felix defends Robbie Williams ...

 

https://www.thesun.co.uk › x-fac...

 

Aww this makes me feel quite sad for Robbie. He did ask permission to ask the question. Gary warned him about that editing...

Sorry I think I've got the link wrong. We're in Devon and I'm on my phone :rolleyes:

 

You need to take everything you read with a pinch of salt ;)

You need to take everything you read with a pinch of salt ;)

 

There's a transgender guy on Upfront that RW talks to a lot. He was explaining the "deadname" scenario. It was quite informative actually. It's good to learn this stuff. :)

Quite enjoyed it tonight. Really liked the choir and Georgia the blonde girl.

 

 

I had a conversation with my youngest daughter about XF today as she said she was looking forward to watching it tonight. I asked her what she thought about the new panel.

 

 

She thought Robbie and Louis "lovely" but wasn't warming to Ayda.

 

I asked her why and she said 1. She was a big fan of Nicole Scherzinger and missed her on there. 2. She felt Ayda would have nothing to say if her husband were not sitting next to her. She felt she referenced him too much.

 

I don't think that Ayda is coming across as well as I thought she would on screen. I'm a bit surprised I have to say.

 

I'll be interested to watch the live shows and if they capture her personality. Especially the ones Robbie won't be at.

Quite enjoyed it tonight. Really liked the choir and Georgia the blonde girl.

I had a conversation with my youngest daughter about XF today as she said she was looking forward to watching it tonight. I asked her what she thought about the new panel.

She thought Robbie and Louis "lovely" but wasn't warming to Ayda.

 

I asked her why and she said 1. She was a big fan of Nicole Scherzinger and missed her on there. 2. She felt Ayda would have nothing to say if her husband were not sitting next to her. She felt she referenced him too much.

 

I don't think that Ayda is coming across as well as I thought she would on screen. I'm a bit surprised I have to say.

 

I'll be interested to watch the live shows and if they capture her personality. Especially the ones Robbie won't be at.

 

 

 

In fairness I doubt Ayda would have got the job without Robbie , they desperately wanted Robbie , I worry for her on the live shows as the mentors really have to do their job then to get the best out of their protege's & Ayda does not have that experience , she is doing ok up to now & she is very nice to the contestants but nice will not be enough going forward, the only thing is that the cameras will be focused a lot on Sharon as she makes good tv. I like Louis , he is really good as a judge. The guy taking off his shirt made me laugh, talking about showing off & it all going wrong & Robbie telling him to tone it down :lol:

David Walliams spent time with Robbie in LA this week, is he assisting Robbie or Ayda :unsure:

Talent on XF way better tonight ,

 

 

 

http://i68.tinypic.com/28tcknn.jpg

 

 

I :heart: Ayda's ring ....