Jump to content

Best Mel C Album. 45 members have voted

  1. 1. Vote For The Best Album

    • Northern Star
      28
    • Reason
      5
    • Beautiful Intentions
      2
    • This Time
      3
    • The Sea
      4
    • Stages
      0
    • Version Of Me
      1
  2. 2. Worst Mel C Album

    • Northern Star
      0
    • Reason
      5
    • Beautiful Intentions
      1
    • This Time
      6
    • The Sea
      0
    • Stages
      31
    • Version Of Me
      0

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Posted

In Melanies 17 year solo career she has presented us with 7 solo studio albums.

What are your opinions on these albums?

Please vote for both the best and worst solo album from Melanie.

 

  • Replies 67
  • Views 6.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I went for Beautiful Intentions as my best although Northern Star is pretty neck and neck with it.

 

Worst would easily be Stages

Northern Star is easily my favourite :wub:

Stagesis my least favourite, I like a few tracks but in general it’s a total miss.

'Northern Star' is my favourite - although 'The Sea' runs it a very close second. Brilliant and underrated album that was. 'This Time' was the worst for me purely because it was the least engaging.
  • Author

Best: Reason (Beautiful Intentions very close followed by Northern Star)

Worst: This is easily Stages.

I love reason and I'm shocked but has 3 votes for worst, its by far her album I listen to the most. Stages gets worst as it does nothing for me.

Stages is not a studio album. Shouldn’t really be included .

 

NS best

Reason worst (nice album but there are not hits here)

  • Author

I dont understand the hate for Reason when it has such wonderful songs such as:

 

Here It Comes Again

Lose Myself In You

On The Horizon

Lets Love and

Melt.

Stages is not a studio album. Shouldn’t really be included .

It is, after all it's recorded in a studio! Christmas albums count as studio albums too.

 

 

Best: Northern Star

Worst: Stages

I dont understand the hate for Reason when it has such wonderful songs such as:

 

Here It Comes Again

Lose Myself In You

On The Horizon

Lets Love and

Melt.

 

All of those songs are part of the reason why that album is demonised. Those songs are particularly bad, only better than Soul Boy imo. The only good songs are Reason and Home. The rest is pish :cry:

  • Author

It most certainly is down to different tastes but Reason is just enjoyable throughout.

Northern Star is a great album too but has a variant of sounds going through it which takes from the album.

Beautiful Intentions is my second choice as it has a together sound to it but i like the songs less than those on Reason.

I've never really joined other fans in believing Reason is mostly bad. For the most part I quite like it actually, the only song I don't like is Soul Boy. Lose Myself in You is the best album track imo.
Isn’t it 20 years?? Anyway... I voted for Reason because it’s the one I listen more frequently. The songs didn’t age as bad as some from Northern Star (my opinion). And the worst has to be Stages... sorry, but only bought it because it was Melanie.
I've never really joined other fans in believing Reason is mostly bad. For the most part I quite like it actually, the only song I don't like is Soul Boy. Lose Myself in You is the best album track imo.

 

 

Aaah Jay :wub:

 

I'm with you I never understood the intense dislike for Reason I think there are some great tracks on it, could do with a bit of a re-working of track order and boot of Soul boy and Do I for Love you without trying and Love to you instead. Something like this:

 

1. Here it comes again

2. Yeh, yeh, yeh

3. On the horizon

4. Reason

5. Lose myself in you

6. Let's love

7. I love you without trying

8. Positively somewhere

9. Love to you

10. Melt

11. Water

12. Home

 

My favourite album track is probably Reason although I love Home and Positively Somewhere too :wub:

I think I was tired earlier, I meant to say... Positively Somewhere is my favourite album track! :lol: I do like Lose Myself in You though!
It is, after all it's recorded in a studio! Christmas albums count as studio albums too.

Best: Northern Star

Worst: Stages

 

Is it recorded in a studio ?

It is a covers album not created in a studio. It is a concept album.

 

Madonna for example does not include her gh , her remix album or her soundtracks as ‘her albums’ .

 

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.