Jump to content

Melanie C Solo Albums

pippa
in Spice Girls

Best Mel C Album. 45 members have voted

  1. 1. Vote For The Best Album

    • Northern Star
      28
    • Reason
      5
    • Beautiful Intentions
      2
    • This Time
      3
    • The Sea
      4
    • Stages
      0
    • Version Of Me
      1

  2. 2. Worst Mel C Album

    • Northern Star
      0
    • Reason
      5
    • Beautiful Intentions
      1
    • This Time
      6
    • The Sea
      0
    • Stages
      31
    • Version Of Me
      0

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

1. Northern Star

2. The Sea

3. Beautiful Intentions

4. Reason / This Time / Version of Me

7. Stages

 

I find it really tough to rate Reason, This Time and Version of Me as there are songs I adore on all three and then two on each album I'm not keen on (soul boy, do it, I want candy, this time, dear life, our history) so I find it hard to rate them lol.

  • Replies 67
  • Views 6.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

This Time is definitely the worst, but Reason is just a bit too meandering in quite substancial places. -_-

 

It's got great songs like Home and Reason, and I am also a fan of some of the uptempos and Water.

 

Songs like Do I, Soul Boy and Love Myself in You though, are just a bit too bland.

This Time is definitely the worst, but Reason is just a bit too meandering in quite substancial places. -_-

 

It's got great songs like Home and Reason, and I am also a fan of some of the uptempos and Water.

 

Songs like Do I, Soul Boy and Love Myself in You though, are just a bit too bland.

 

 

I have made my own version of Reason and took those three songs out and the album is SO much better (although I have a soft spot for lose myself in you, it's too slow on an already slow album). My tracklisting is:

 

1. Here it comes again

2. Yeh, yeh, yeh

3. On the horizon

4. I love you without trying

5. Reason

6. Water

7. Let's love

8. Living without you

9. Positively somewhere

10. Home

11. Knocked out

 

I'd include Wonderland at the end but I find the summery upbeat knocked out ends it really upbeat. If this had been the tracklisting it would be my second favourite after Northern Star (possibly my favourite).

Beautiful Intentions is a quality album lyrically but I feel its let down a bit by the production.

 

If it had had a production similar to Kelly Clarksons Breakaway I think it could've almost topped Northern Star.

 

I still really enjoy it though. Little Piece of Me and You Will See would've made excellent singles.

Little Piece Of Me was screaming to be a single !!
Little Piece Of Me was screaming to be a single !!
Beautiful Intentions is a quality album lyrically but I feel its let down a bit by the production.

 

If it had had a production similar to Kelly Clarksons Breakaway I think it could've almost topped Northern Star.

 

I still really enjoy it though. Little Piece of Me and You Will See would've made excellent singles.

 

I really agree with this, the production just needs a bit more of a polish to it, I love it though :wub:

 

Go to topic listing

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.