to be fair, Lift me up is her worst song.... while What I am is not even Emma's song, it a cover of Edie Brickel... so

They're both pretty damn average. Much preferred the other 'Up' song by Geri & that Emma track is very pedestrian. What I Am by a whisker.

The full chart from Radio 1 on this very day in 1999 is on Mixcloud. The reactions from Emma and Geri respectively when Mark Goodier confirms their chart positions are GOLD: https://www.mixcloud.com/StephenTheRadioKid...odier-07111999/

Emma.

Lift Me Up

 

What I Am has a better video but the song wasnt good enough for her debut.

 

Prefer Emma overall tho.

'What I Am' has this for me, I feel like 'Lift Me Up's potential as a song could have been realised with a more... competent vocalist to pull it off. :lol:

 

The most iconic single released that week (a new entry at #5) would be my choice:

 

 

NOW we're talking! :wub: :wub:

Geri by far! Emma has way better songs than this.

The Corrs? What Can I Do

 

Yeah that’s the one!

Lift Me Up by miles

Voted for Lift and Up as I couldn't remember the Emma one but it's actually better!!

Lift me up is catchier.

What I Am is MILES better than Lift Me Up.

Edited November 13, 20195 yr by girlsaloudjunkie