February 10, 20205 yr Gutted I didn't vote, if I had it would have been Madonna all the way - there really isn't any competition. Just as long as its not Kylie or Gaga I'm ok. Hoped to see RiRi higher.
February 10, 20205 yr My ideal result from those remaining would be 1 Kylie 2 Lady Gaga 3 Madoona 4 Britney It could go either way though as all 4 have alot of fans here.
February 10, 20205 yr Yeah I'm giving up on predicting the order of the Top 4 as it could literally go any way now! I still have a feeling Madonna will be No. 1 though.
February 10, 20205 yr Author NO 4- BRITNEY SPEARS- 494 POINTS (Voters: GirlsAloudJunkie- 26 points, Riser- 17 points, Mack- 25 points, Darkhorse- 26 points, Stonedragon- 8 points, Blacksquare- 9 points, Spiceboy- 19 points, ThePensmith- 29 points, Josephstyles- 30 points, Gezza- 26 points, Sam Judd- 24 points, Bjork- 6 points, jra1989- 23 points, Pippa- 11 points, Miichaelking21- 13 points, Vibe- 14 points, M4NGO- 24 points, Josh!- 17 points, Jordan Lee- 11 points, Lukuzz- 26 points, Jonjo- 29 points, ….ready for it- 25 points, NickF1- 30 points, James Barkley- 26 points) BIGGEST UK HIT: BABY ONE MORE TIME (#1, 1999) BORN TO MAKE YOU HAPPY (#1, 2000), OOPS I DID IT AGAIN (#1, 2000), TOXIC (#1, 2004) EVERYTIME (#1, 2004) SCREAM AND SHOUT (#1, 2012) TOTAL UK TOP 40 HITS: 30 T08xvBkYRkI
February 10, 20205 yr Britney about where she should be imo. Great discography despite the fact she's not the best live act around
February 10, 20205 yr Britney about where she should be imo. Great discography despite the fact she's not the best live act around She has some great songs and I've bought some of her albums but the fact that she rarely sings live annoys me about her.
February 10, 20205 yr The fact she still manages to sell out shows without singing live, proves otherwise. :') She's a shadow of her former self nowadays ofc, but peak Britney (2000-2005) is untouched as a live performer (this countdown is about everything, so I can live on past glory thank you :D ). If you don't agree with her not singing live, great that's cool. Don't pay to see her that's completely up to you. But she clearly has enough interest as a live performer to give us a record breaking Vegas residency, in which she in turn made it "cool" for younger artists to opt for their own residencies and diminished the "Vegas is where artists go to rest" or whatever it was. Her power is literally still managing to sell out tours whenever she tours, even with the whole "but she doesn't sing live!!!!!11!!" headlines and comments. If she didn't put on a spectacle/show then I'd agree with the singing live criticisms. But she makes up for it in the shows imo (and a lot of other people obviously hence constantly selling out her tours etc) She's a huge part of my upbringing. In the same way that Gaga was for many of those in 2009. In the same way that Madonna, Kylie & even Spice Girls were for the 80's & 90's kids. 'Blackout' has been named one of the most influential albums ever. An album in which she was executive producer of. She's constantly reinvented herself and is heading into her 3rd Decade as one of the most prolific names in music history. Her impact is undeniable. Her legacy in tact. She's one of the biggest female artists and performers of all time and I'm SO happy that her legacy is largely remembered here. Enough for her to finish top 4 in this list :heart: I LOVE HER! (Dunno if you could tell :blush: Sorry. None of this was meant to be rude, so I apologise if it comes off that way aha - I get v protective over her. :P )
February 10, 20205 yr Early Britney is fantastic. Like her singles trajectory from 99-03/04 is flawless tbh. But she’s not the most talented. And as a live act she’s appalling these days. She’s also only really made two great albums for me. In The Zone and Blackout all her other albums as a whole package are very patchy. But those early singles she released really were all genius and bring back so many memories. But I’ve always preferred Xtina over her tbh. I actually thought Britney was gonna win this though! Edited February 10, 20205 yr by Jordan Lee
February 10, 20205 yr But Bjork doesn't like her so she has no talent x I voted for her :) she was talented, but on a different league than Madonna it's not that Kylie or Britney are not talented, but you really cannot compare once I read a post somewhere I think popjustice that was genious comparing Madonna with others like Kylie or Britney paraphrasing what they were saying is that Madonna is like a sushi chef that for 30 years ruled sushi in the world and reinvented sushi all the time like every 3 years coming with a new trend and making classic after classic by comparison people like Kylie or Britney, they cannot make sushi but they're good at buying sushi, they need where to go to buy and can buy good one and sell it but that doesn't make them sushi chefs they're good at their job but it's another job :)
February 10, 20205 yr Again i disagree, Madonna has an amazing career i dont take from it at all but some of her material isnt as strong as some people say. I dont think she is or was, always the market leader. I think Kylie, Britney, Gaga and Madonna have each had their highs and lows. I am biased to Kylie as she is my fave, i think what Kylie has above the others is she has remained down to earth and level headed and has no airs or graces.
February 11, 20205 yr I think exactly the right three have finished in the Top 3 so I actually don't mind what order they're in (as long as Madonna is #1 and Kylie is #2 :P)
February 11, 20205 yr Everyone’s deserving of a win. Gaga is my fave but she debuted like two decades after Kylie and Madonna so she obviously hasn’t released as much material. She’s definitely the most talented vocally of who’s left and I’d probably say she the most talented overall too. Madonna however is the most creative and versatile she’s the reinvention queen and controversy queen too. Kylie really should finish third tbh. She’s basically like the Aussie Britney to me. Like I see them both very similarly. They both aren’t strong vocalists but put on extravagant shows, both struggle making good albums but make great singles, both have iconic music videos and images and dance routines etc but just don’t have the overall package what Gaga and Madonna have.
February 11, 20205 yr Everyone’s deserving of a win. Gaga is my fave but she debuted like two decades after Kylie and Madonna so she obviously hasn’t released as much material. She’s definitely the most talented vocally of who’s left and I’d probably say she the most talented overall too. Madonna however is the most creative and versatile she’s the reinvention queen and controversy queen too. Kylie really should finish third tbh. She’s basically like the Aussie Britney to me. Like I see them both very similarly. They both aren’t strong vocalists but put on extravagant shows, both struggle making good albums but make great singles, both have iconic music videos and images and dance routines etc but just don’t have the overall package what Gaga and Madonna have. Comparing Kylie to Britney is totally inadmissible and lame to say the least... They have nothing in common, Kylie sings live in all of her concerts, you have youtube to prove it if you never saw her live, Kylie is a versatile artist that sang so many different types of songs, has a career spanning more than 30 years and is still having success... I don't think I need to defend Kylie, just trying to prove your point is wrong. Britney never sang a live tune in her concerts and has strong songs but zero talent... Madonna is lipsyncing in her last 5 tours for half of the tour if not more, she collaborated with everyone starting 2008 to stay relevant but in vain, at least Kylie never looked for cheap success or collaborations to be successful, she always relied on her flair for good songs and concepts and up and coming producers... Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't. I think Kylie is the overall number one female artist who fully made use of her talent, her sexy image, her feel good music (and only that) to be successful, she never resorted to cheap controversy or bashing religion etc (like early Gaga did and like Madonna most of her career). Edited February 11, 20205 yr by adancing
February 11, 20205 yr Comparing Kylie to Britney is totally inadmissible and lame to say the least... They have nothing in common, Kylie sings live in all of her concerts, you have youtube to prove it if you never saw her live, Kylie is a versatile artist that sang so many different types of songs, has a career spanning more than 30 years and is still having success... I don't think I need to defend Kylie, just trying to prove your point is wrong. Britney never sang a live tune in her concerts and has strong songs but zero talent... Madonna is lipsyncing in her last 5 tours for half of the tour if not more, she collaborated with everyone starting 2008 to stay relevant but in vain, at least Kylie never looked for cheap success or collaborations to be successful, she always relied on her flair for good songs and concepts and up and coming producers... Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't. I think Kylie is the overall number one female artist who fully made use of her talent, her sexy image, her feel good music (and only that) to be successful, she never resorted to cheap controversy or bashing religion etc (like early Gaga did and like Madonna most of her career). well said. :cheer: obviously the person who falsely said that Kylie has the same vocal abilities as Britney probably has never seen or heard Kylie singing live, she has amazing vocal abilites and never sings out of tune unlike Britney who could never perform unless she’s lip synching or using vocoders...
February 11, 20205 yr Comparing Kylie to Britney is totally inadmissible and lame to say the least... They have nothing in common, Kylie sings live in all of her concerts, you have youtube to prove it if you never saw her live, Kylie is a versatile artist that sang so many different types of songs, has a career spanning more than 30 years and is still having success... I don't think I need to defend Kylie, just trying to prove your point is wrong. Britney never sang a live tune in her concerts and has strong songs but zero talent... Madonna is lipsyncing in her last 5 tours for half of the tour if not more, she collaborated with everyone starting 2008 to stay relevant but in vain, at least Kylie never looked for cheap success or collaborations to be successful, she always relied on her flair for good songs and concepts and up and coming producers... Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't. I think Kylie is the overall number one female artist who fully made use of her talent, her sexy image, her feel good music (and only that) to be successful, she never resorted to cheap controversy or bashing religion etc (like early Gaga did and like Madonna most of her career). I fully support this view. Kylie delivers a real live show and sings live on all the songs which is something Britney has never done, or even came close to. Kylie identifies she is not the strongest female singer in the market but she more than makes up for that in other areas and has huge levels of creativity.
February 11, 20205 yr Why do people need to get so defensive over their faves? Just let people have their opinions. For me, Kylie trumps Britney in every way but I can't deny that Britney has some gems in her discography too.
Create an account or sign in to comment