Jump to content

Which queen really won these double shantays and deserved to stay just that little bit more than the other queen? 23 members have voted

  1. 1. Mickey (Spanish Version) (SEASON 3)

    • Yara Sofia
      14
    • Carmen Carrera
      6
  2. 2. It?s Raining Men (RuPaul version) (SEASON 4)

    • Sharon Needles
      13
    • Phi Phi O Hara
      7
  3. 3. Dancing On My Own (ALL STARS 1)

    • Raven
      8
    • Jujubee
      12
  4. 4. Whip My Hair (SEASON 5)

    • Roxxxy Andrews
      10
    • Alyssa Edwards
      10
  5. 5. Point Of No Return (SEASON 6)

    • Darienne Lake
      12
    • BenDeLaCreme
      8
  6. 6. Shut Up & Drive (ALL STARS 2)

    • Alyssa Edwards
      6
    • Tatianna
      14
  7. 7. Woman Up (SEASON 9)

    • Cynthia Lee Fontaine
      4
    • Farrah Moan
      16
  8. 8. I Kissed a Girl (ALL STARS 3)

    • BenDeLaCreme
      9
    • Shangela
      11
  9. 9. New Attitude (SEASON 10)

    • Eureka O Hara
      4
    • Kameron Michaels
      16
  10. 10. If (SEASON 10)

    • Aquaria
      13
    • Eureka O Hara
      7
  11. 11. Jump To It (ALL STARS 4)

    • Manila Luzon
      13
    • Monet X Change
      7
  12. 12. Fighter (ALL STARS 4)

    • Monet X Change
      8
    • Trinity The Tuck
      12
  13. 13. Sorry Not Sorry (SEASON 11)

    • Brooke Lynn Hytes
      7
    • Yvie Oddly
      13

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Posted
As it says on the tin, who do you think should have won these double shantays had only one queen been allowed to stay each time! Don’t think I’ve missed any off but if I have do let me know!
  • Replies 4
  • Views 780
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The Brook Lynn vs. Yvie one was impossible! They both complimented each other in the lipsync and it wouldn't have been as epic if they both didn't turn it out as hard as they did!
Yara Sofia Vs Carmen Carrera - Yara, definitely with her "Its not kissing for your life" line, just hilarious, while she did have the slight advantage of the sing being in her language, Carmen did ooze sexiness. But it was Yara who edges out in front in my opinion.

Sharon Needles Vs Phi Phi O'Hara - This was one hell of a smackdown, sworn rivals coming head to head with Sharon serving up camp & Phi Phi really giving it her all & literally flipping her wig. Sharon would have definitely been the one saved if Willam hadn't been kicked out. Also if Phi Phi did get the boot then I reckon she would have been brought back on the makeover challenge instead of Kenya, coz out of all the eliminated Queens she had the best track record & we'd probably have the same final 3. I also think that Willam would have got the boot in the makeover challenge against Latrice who would have slaughtered her in the lip-sync.

Raven Vs Jujubee - Probably the most emotional lip-sync in Drag Race herstory, not much of a show they both cried in each others arms to such a classic & amazing song 'Dancing On My Own'.

Roxxxy Andrews Vs Alyssa Edwards - Now this was EPIC!, both Queens brought choreography, energy and copious amounts of hairography for a pretty awful song, but that wig underneath a wig was everything. While both were great Alyssa didn't miss a word & didn't need the gimmick wig reveal.

Darienne Lake Vs BenDeLaCreme - One of my personal fave lip-syncs ever & how much I hate to admit it Darienne was probably better with her boob shakes & during the dance break she was taking money (that was the winning moment). But glad Ben didn't go as it would have been a travesty.

Alyssa Edwards Vs Tatianna - When we saw Alyssa Edwards and Tatianna walk down that runway in matching corsets, with that look of fire in their eyes, we knew some smackdown was gonna be involved & it was perfection.

Cynthia Lee Fontaine Vs Farrah Moan - Definitely the weakest on this list (Cynthia's performance wasn't good, WTF was going on with her mouth). Wouldn't call this a proper double Shantay as Farrah would have definitely been saved (even though she wasn't all that great either), but she did look like a young pop diva on this track.


I'll give opinions on the rest in another post.
Yeah there's absolutely no way you could separate Yvie and Brooke, the very definition of a double shantay because they both completely slayed it but in a way that complimented each other, it was as if they prepared it for a show together because they got totally got each other with it!

I definitely think some voters are just picking their favourite as opposed to who won the lipsync! Of all the ones on the list you can attribute an actual winner to the lipsync, Monet beat Trinity HAAAANDS down.

 

Those I think were worthy of a double Shantay the most:

Sharon & Phi Phi and Eureka & Kameron... I really don't think Eureka is given enough credit for this one, she puts her whole self into it.. the moment she SMACKS the ground is pure I Want To Stay Energy

 

Those I think worthy of a double Shantay but I could pick a winner:

Alyssa v Tati (Tati was the winner for me though), Brooke & Yvie (Yvie won because I didn't expect it of her)

 

Those I think worthy of a double Shantay because they were both same level not because both were exceptional:

Monet & Manila, Raven & Juju, Shangela & Ben - difficult one because Shangela had all the ideas but Ben just copying her was comedy gold,

 

Those I think one person should have won:

Monet beating Trinity

Roxxxy beating Alyssa

Darienne beating Ben

Farrah beating Cynthia

 

And I feel like Eureka and Aquaria might have been a double Sashay if it wasn't the final. Carmen and Yara I don't remember well enough.

Edited by Adam

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.