#1: Tim McGraw (3), Teardrops on My Guitar (7)

#2: Teardrops on My Guitar (3), Our Song (4)

#3: Picture to Burn (3), Our Song (4)

#4: Our Song (2), Should've Said No (4)

#5: Should've Said No (2), Love Story (3)

#6: White Horse (1), Love Story (7)

#7: Love Story (3), You Belong With Me (8)

#8: Fifteen (1), You Belong With Me (8)

#9: Fearless (2), You Belong With Me (3)

#10: Mine (3), You Belong With Me (5)

#11: Back to December (5), You Belong With Me (7)

 

How this works (rules used from Shawn forum):

 

Each round, we'll pit two songs against one another. You vote for your favorite song of the two and the winner will advance to the next round where it will duel against another song - it'll stay in until it's knocked out by another song.

'You Belong With Me' again!

You Belong With Me again for me as well!

Will leave this open until Monday.

Closing later today! Get your vote in if you haven't already!

Voted against 'You Belong With Me' the past two rounds but I do definitely prefer it to 'Mean'

Closing!