My instinct would've been to save Shake It Out as it's one of her big hitters, but I haven't looked in detail at what songs fit into each of the other rounds. It's probably my favourite by her though so I approve of it, that said, I LOVE What Kind of Man and that doesn't get anywhere near the recognition it deserves these days, I'd love to see it represented!

What a start :cheeseblock:

 

Shake It Out please!!

Unless you're saving it for a later round 'Cosmic Love' pls xxx

Shake It Out for sureeee

I choose Shake It Out from those choices!

 

(This is also my first and only participation so far in AF Idol :kink:)

Thanks for the feedback so far! I do feel Shake It Out might have the most general appeal but, and it might be me being a blind stan, I feel there’s enough big hitters left to fill the remaining the singles round.

 

I choose Shake It Out from those choices!

 

(This is also my first and only participation so far in AF Idol :kink:)

Well make sure your second is voting for Florence in Round 2 x

I'd prefer Cosmic Love but Shake it Off is of course amazing too

ROUND 2: First OR last single from an era

 

SHAKE IT OUT

 

regrets collect like old friends, here to relive your darkest moments

 

We move on to the Ceremonials era and with the song that properly launched it! Shake it Out initially had a slower start than expected in the charts but was propelled to match the peak of Rabbit Heart after a performance on The X Factor UK. It is a HUGE song and again, very representative of the Ceremonials era with the striking use of organs. It starts off very gentle and builds up into a moment of a chorus that's full of energy where Florence lets it all out. So let go of everything and shake it all out to ensure the choice isn't a regret!

 

 

:wub: Brilliant choice, hoping it can repeat the success of Rabbit Heart (Raise It Up) in this competition!

Well make sure your second is voting for Florence in Round 2 x

I did! :P

I take it we're saving 'Cosmic Love' for later then :cheer:

 

('Shake It Out' is also one of her best tho x)

HELP! The next round is album track which I'm most stuck on so it's very open for suggestions! This is also the only chance for any slower album tracks as they won't have a chance of being entered into any other rounds.

 

My initial thoughts are but please please offer more suggestions!:

 

Hurricane Drunk

Only If for a Night

Heartlines

How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful

Hiding

Make Up Your Mind

Which Witch (Demo)

 

I'm thinking one of the HBHBHB ones for the uptempo one? There's one I've not mentioned which I'm saving for Should've Been a Single.

 

I take it we're saving 'Cosmic Love' for later then :cheer:

:o

How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful would be my pick- its a beautiful song

HBHBHB for sure!!!!

ONLY IF FOR A NIGHT!!!

 

HBHBHB CAN BE USED FOR FLOP SINGLE!!!!!!!! WHICH WITCH? IS ALSO ONE OF HA BEST EVER AND SHE DIDN'T PUT IT ON THE ALBUM BECAUSE THE ALBUM STANK OF FLOP AND SHE XOULDN'T PUT A SONG THAT MYSTICAL ON A FLOP!!!!

ONLY IF FOR A NIGHT!!!

 

HBHBHB CAN BE USED FOR FLOP SINGLE!!!!!!!! WHICH WITCH? IS ALSO ONE OF HA BEST EVER AND SHE DIDN'T PUT IT ON THE ALBUM BECAUSE THE ALBUM STANK OF FLOP AND SHE XOULDN'T PUT A SONG THAT MYSTICAL ON A FLOP!!!!

How Big wasn’t a single?

I am not as familiar with the album tracks after the first two albums so not much help :cry: I will be listening to the later albums over the next week or so though~

 

Of what I do know, Only If for a Night and Heartlines are both brilliant.

 

ONLY IF FOR A NIGHT!!!

 

HBHBHB CAN BE USED FOR FLOP SINGLE!!!!!!!! WHICH WITCH? IS ALSO ONE OF HA BEST EVER AND SHE DIDN'T PUT IT ON THE ALBUM BECAUSE THE ALBUM STANK OF FLOP AND SHE XOULDN'T PUT A SONG THAT MYSTICAL ON A FLOP!!!!

Don’t you be coming in here to slander the How Big How Blue How Beautiful era!!!

 

I am not as familiar with the album tracks after the first two albums so not much help :cry: I will be listening to the later albums over the next week or so though~

 

Of what I do know, Only If for a Night and Heartlines are both brilliant.

You won’t need to bother with High as Hope for the purposes of this because I don’t think anything on there has a chance of success in this game :kink:

 

You must become more familiar with HBHBHB though, I’ve always loved it but I’ve been listening to it so much such this whole thing commenced. I absolutely adore it :wub:

I'd think Hurricane Drunk might have the best chance at doing well.

 

My personal faves are HBHBHB and Heartlines though!

Seven devils!! that's the best album track and I think it was used in some tv show so maybe people know it

 

I'm not calling you a liar, Heartlines, Only if for the night are all great

 

Not crazy about HBHBHW myself