Obviously, they have had their difficulties over the year with their feud before finally putting all their differences aside and reuniting for Shame and the Take That 5-piece reunion.



That being said, who is your favourite of the two? In their feud, who did you back? Who do you prefer musically?

Feel free to explain your answer and vote in the poll.

I'll start by saying I think they are both massively talented and I have been a fan of Take That and Robbie all my life.

For me though, Robbie is my favourite as his music just means so much more to me. When I was growing up Robbie was very prominent in the media whereas Gary was in his quieter phase. I had a lot more exposure to Robbie and I find his music very relatable and it has helped me through difficult times.

I've really enjoyed Gary's last two albums but Robbie just has such a huge back catalogue and edges ahead for me. Robbie was also my crush for many years.

Gary.

Gary, I do like robbie more now than I used to as for years I had little time for him personality wise.

Gary from what we get to see comes across much more grounded than Robbie.

Gary's a tax-dodging Tory scrote, so I'll choose Robbie on that basis.

 

I prefer him musically solo as well.

For me robbie showed a real venomous side at the peak of his fallout with Gary and it was a trait I didnt particularly like as it went on for so long. This added to my delight in seeing Take That making such a monstrous comeback.

What is the point of this thread?

 

Can't we just remove it? It's so boring......

 

I'd sooner have pins stuck in my eyes.... :rolleyes:

Just when you think we'd all moved on.... :unsure:

Robbie!