Happy heavenly birthday to Paul Cattermole, who would’ve turned 49 years old today. May he rest in peace.

Happy belated birthday to Paul

Had another discography run through

And also listened to the juniors/8 this time, i know they are kids but did not remember there being such a maturity difference between the first and second album lyricism

Unsure if anyone here knows this. Tina was originally meant to be a member of Mis-Teeq, but was replaced by Su-Elise Nash and Zena McNally after successfully auditioning for S Club.

16 hours ago, DanielCarey said:

Unsure if anyone here knows this. Tina was originally meant to be a member of Mis-Teeq, but was replaced by Su-Elise Nash and Zena McNally after successfully auditioning for S Club.

Ooh probably the better choice for her as S club had the bigger success overall (not that misteeq didnt do too shabby either)

And now I gone down a rabbit whole

S club 3 was Paul, Bradley and Joe

Then Tina joined

Then Joe left and sadly Paul died and Stacey Frank's from S club 8 joined to become S club allstars

Random side projects between reunions

On 18/05/2026 at 18:41, 777666jason said:

Ooh probably the better choice for her as S club had the bigger success overall (not that misteeq didnt do too shabby either)

And now I gone down a rabbit whole

S club 3 was Paul, Bradley and Joe

Then Tina joined

Then Joe left and sadly Paul died and Stacey Frank's from S club 8 joined to become S club allstars

Random side projects between reunions

I think Tina would've been just a backing singer, like Su-Elise, had she joined. Joining S Club was better, especially since they had more chart success.

On 22/05/2025 at 19:47, ThePensmith said:

There aren't enough eyerolls at the erasure of Natural's 25th anniversary I can make. But to be expected, sadly 🙄

Tbf, Natural was their first sort of "flop" by their own standards. First not to go top 2 and first not to certify, I can see why they ignored it. (Ps I know I am reply over a year later loool)

1 hour ago, Spiceboy said:

Tbf, Natural was their first sort of "flop" by their own standards. First not to go top 2 and first not to certify, I can see why they ignored it. (Ps I know I am reply over a year later loool)

And arguably one of their best 😢

25 minutes ago, 777666jason said:

And arguably one of their best 😢

Hmmm, it's one of their weaker singles for me. I like it a lot but its more of an album track in my eyes.

10 hours ago, Spiceboy said:

Hmmm, it's one of their weaker singles for me. I like it a lot but its more of an album track in my eyes.

I’m with you spiceboy, I like it but I sometimes feel it’s a Rachel Stevens solo track masquerading as an S Club single.

I know you never said the last part and it’s probably a little unfair to if I’m being honest.

57 minutes ago, Paddington James said:

I’m with you spiceboy, I like it but I sometimes feel it’s a Rachel Stevens solo track masquerading as an S Club single.

I know you never said the last part and it’s probably a little unfair to if I’m being honest.

Goodness this is the most aggressive I've seen you Pads. 😋😉❤️

I think you could say that about Jo for Two in a million too tbh.

1 hour ago, Spiceboy said:

Goodness this is the most aggressive I've seen you Pads. 😋😉❤️

I think you could say that about Jo for Two in a million too tbh.

Haha I did feel that as I posted it. It was a bit harsh.

I also thought the same with Jo and Two In A Million.

36 minutes ago, Paddington James said:

Haha I did feel that as I posted it. It was a bit harsh.

I also thought the same with Jo and Two In A Million.

Lol it wasn't at all I was laughing because you said it was probably unfair. You are the least unfair person on these forums! 🥰

Right can you leave Two in a million out of this

You could argue half the discography they were backing singers for Jo unfortunately btw

1 hour ago, Spiceboy said:

Lol it wasn't at all I was laughing because you said it was probably unfair. You are the least unfair person on these forums! 🥰

Aww thanks spiceboy. It probably also wasn’t helped by the fact I think there were more deserving songs on 7 that should’ve been singles.