Jump to content

Featured Replies

A nice climb for Texas !! Clean Bandit are also great!
  • Replies 1.5k
  • Views 73.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Don’t know much about New Order

 

Think Clean Bandit are a bit high personally, love a bit of Texas

  • Author
Tomorrow will see another 30 pointer exit and we'll see our first band drop out of the top 30 from the last rate.

New Order are fab: were in my draft votes but ended up being muscled out.

 

Clean Bandit were great right at the beginning and then became boring.

Bye bye Texas I love them. Unusually Red Book is my fave album of theirs!

Yes, Red Book is a great album! Personally though I just love listening to their first greatest hits - 'Black Eyed Boy' is surely one of the best pop songs ever written, it's so uplifting and feelgood :wub:

 

Big drops for New Order and Clean Bandit :o

I quite enjoy a bit of New Order and Clean Bandit were great for their first few singles but have gradually dissolved into blandness. 'Symphony' was the last song of theirs I properly loved.

 

Texas <3 one of my first musical loves, Sharleen is a class act and a captivating performer - she really has a lot of star quality.

 

They are still good too - recent singles Mr Haze and After All are up there with some of their old classics.

Edited by gooddelta

Only lost Gorillaz and Foo Fighters since I last checked so not bad going, both largely based on their 2000s work but they do still come up with a good recent gem every now and then.
Yes, Red Book is a great album! Personally though I just love listening to their first greatest hits - 'Black Eyed Boy' is surely one of the best pop songs ever written, it's so uplifting and feelgood :wub:

 

 

Their Greatest Hits is utterly fab I agree and I love that song too. :wub:

They are still good too - recent singles Mr Haze and After All are up there with some of their old classics.

Oh yeah, Mr Haze is a total bop - so much fun!

NO 77- EVERYTHING EVERYTHING ( :up: 163)- 77 POINTS

oh lets fucking get it-!! :deadbanana: :deadbanana: :deadbanana:

 

now i'm a wee bit more grateful for that strange moment when Cough Cough reached the top 40 bc not being able to vote for the GOAT band would've been an instant dealbreaker sorry xx

New Order are a really weird one for me.

 

I love Joy Division but just cannot get to feel anything much for New Order. Even the first album, which is broadly JD in style, doesn't excite me, and whilst I recognise and appreciate their importance and many great songs, pretty much everything they've done leaves me completely cold or I find slightly annoying and overrrated.

 

I've tried and tried, in fact I'm listening to my playlist of them right now, and I have many friends who've loved them for years but I just can't get in to them.

They should have tried Hooky on lead vocals instead, couldn’t have been much worse! Instrumentally though, they’re great IMO - best to leave the Joy Division comparisons to one side as much as possible.
They should have tried Hooky on lead vocals instead, couldn’t have been much worse!

 

 

They did. he sings lead vocals on Dreams Never End and Doubts Even Here from the debut album

  • Author

NO 70- PINK FLOYD ( :up: 176)- 94 POINTS

 

3137-1-300x300.jpg

 

Voter: Scene- 13pts, xajnipi- 4pts, Smint- 30pts, King Rollo- 14pts, Chez Wombat- 6pts, Chartjack2- 27pts

7 UK TOP 40 HITS

BIGGEST HIT: ANOTHER BRICK IN THE WALL (#1, 1979)

 

 

  • Author

NO 69- KEANE ( :up: 102)- 97 POINTS

 

keane--417605159-300x300.jpg

 

Voter: Padamic Tension- 21pts, AH Gold- 21pts, Smint- 5pts, Riser- 14pts, Chez Wombat- 15pts, PeteFromLeeds- 12pts, Stonedragon- 9pts

10 UK TOP 40 HITS

BIGGEST HIT: SOMEWHERE ONLY WE KNOW (#3, 2004) IS IT ANY WONDER? (#3, 2006)

 

 

  • Author

NO 68- THE SMITHS ( :down: 28) - 100 POINTS

 

the-smiths-300x300.jpg

 

Voter: Scene- 21pts, Gezza- 27pts, Jason- 24pts, Chartjack2- 28pts

16 UK TOP 40 HITS

BIGGEST HIT: THIS CHARMING MAN (#8, 1992)

 

 

The Smiths should be higher! Difficult to pick a single fave from them but love This Charming Man, Heaven Knows I’m Miserable Now, Still Ill, What Difference Does It Make and How Soon Is Now. :cheeseblock:

 

Pink Floyd climbing a lot since last time! :clap:

I could easily have voted for all 3 of those - all brilliant acts. I guess Pink Floyd have so few singles that depending on whether you’re thinking singles when voting they might be left out. Keane are the kings of the soaring chorus.

Strange for Pink Floyd and Keane to have climbed so much from last time and for The Smiths to have dropped so much!

Pink Floyd and The Smiths are obviously both seminal bands and deserve their places in the top 100 even if I'm not massively into either of them (although 'Girlfriend In A Coma' is absolute genius :wub:)

I liked Keane's debut but lost interest pretty quickly after that.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.