I'm embarrased that I used to think Harry was the best looking

 

Zayn is clearly the best looking.. Followed by Liam/Harry. Niall and Louis are meh

 

Oh and the video is decent for a debut single. Their label/management were never going to spend money on a top quality video.. They'll want to make as much money as possible out of it

I'm loving this song! :)

As much as I hate Boybands, I BLOODY LOVE THIS SONG!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I'm so ashamed

Terrible performance, they were so nervous though so I knida felt for them :wub:

 

And their looks? I think Louis is kinda hot, but mainly cuz I think he's gay.. Actually they're all hot , and I'm younger than them all so there's nothing weird...

Oh dear god, I always thought they were good vocalists on X Factor especially Liam, but the intro was obviously so they didnt have to do the whole thing and Zayn wouldn't have to do his solo, the moment they ran out, the harmonies were so off it was unbelievable and someone was in completely the wrong key. By Harry's solo verse, he had no breathe left to go so low, and it just came out as a quite moan and then came Zayn's last big note, which was just completely wrong - he just be made to stand there and look gorgeous to my eyes, but never, NEVER try and do any high notes on his own.

 

For anyone who missed it:

 

Edited September 10, 201113 yr by Davidson

Taylor Swift called, she wants her VMA performance back..

^As a massive fan of both artists I thought the exact same thing

 

You can't blame Harry for being out of breath though. I mean, he did just run out of the tube and into the studios :kink:

Edited September 10, 201113 yr by Jáhq

Why the surprise that they aren't great vocally? :wacko:

 

Won't matter Cowell's plans for them never included them being able to sing. :P

Taylor Swift called, she wants her VMA performance back..

 

I said that the second a saw them running on the train.

 

As someone said further back it was clearly done so they only had to sing the smallest amount live, and what they did was just terrible.

 

I always said during X Factor last year they clearly couldn't sing very well as they got a ridiclously loud backing vocal and backing singers every week other than the final where their vocals suddenly were alot weaker than every week previously. The tiny live bit of WMYB showed just how weak they are vocaly. The second single, which no doubt the album will be coming straight after, is going to be an X Factor performance, so it will be intresting to see how they approach that. I am assuming it will be mimed

OK, it wasn't the best performance ever, but it was fine for me. Harry looked really nervous, but TBH, I'd be the same, even after being in the final of The X Factor. It's a great song and I'll be sure to buy it.

LMAO @ the Taylor Swift rip off. Sad thing is a lot of kids at home will be thinking it was such a unique performance.

The actual performance side showed no progression since their time on X Factor. There was always someone slightly out of key but you could barely hear it through the backing track which was so loud. They used to sound OK solo... apparently not any more!

 

Not that it matters, this song is going to be huuuge.

Just watched the performance

 

Could Modest Management have not been a little more original ? Used the girls running/screaming scene for both them and JLS within the same week

 

 

Just watched the performance

 

Could Modest Management have not been a little more original ? Used the girls running/screaming scene for both them and JLS within the same week

 

 

However JLS are obviously running away from the many girls for a very diffrent reason. It's not like the fans of either band are gonna care they copied each other, or that One Direction copied Taylor Swift

Is this what Cowell is going to do for every "live" performance they have to give, have a huge video introduction and a million girls to hide the fact that they cannot sing and always had to rely on loud backing tracks and backing singers during X-factor.That was shocking I actually take back everything horrid I have said about JLS they are miles better.

No. The girls were a part of the 'Red or Black' game, so they were pretty vital to the performance.

Have you SEEN Louis? Camp as a row of pink tents.

 

He is the "John Barrowman" one with the Justin Bieber haircut who always talks very loudly with a weird voice? Urgh, I saw them on TV and this member (don't know who is who) just irritated me a lot. :lol:

Louis isn't gay. :P

 

Gonna buy this on CD tomorrow, hopefully!

If Louis isn't gay the universe is OUT OF SYNC because he is SCREAMING.

If Louis isn't gay the universe is OUT OF SYNC because he is SCREAMING.

 

The universe must be out of sync then. :P

Is one of them just a boy whose been on Simon's books for a long time before X Factor as I cannot for the life of me find his audition?