There have been some good comebacks but Britney's has been the best in my opinion. Her single has been quite the success especially considering she hasn't been involved in promoting. The album is also an excellent piece of work... probably her best yet. :wub:

I voted Leona - this song is amazing AND...

 

I havent seen records fly off the shelve soo much ever before

 

loads of places had sold out!

Rihanna - Umbrella

i wouldnt call rihanna a comeback

 

 

loved j-lo because she has been gone for ages and i love her song

How is Leona even a COMEBACK. Didn't she just get here? Her debut album hasn't even been released yet :huh:

It's Hikaru, B!tch :heart:

 

It just doesn't work Matty, it just doesn't work :(

britney, amaazing song! awfully managed comeback though

Ella ella ella eh eh eh for me

How is Leona even a COMEBACK. Didn't she just get here? Her debut album hasn't even been released yet :huh:

agreed.

 

they have to have released an album to make a comeback

Not only do they have to have released an album to have a comeback, they have to have been away for years! Leona, Mutya and Rihanna certainly aren't comebacks - Alicia and Kylie are.

mutyas could be seen as a come back cos she left the babes went away for over a year then came back

For me it's between Avril, Leona & Kylie

It just doesn't work Matty, it just doesn't work :(

 

I didn't even realise it was from 'Gimme More' until I seen your post, I need to take more notice :lol:

 

but it's true <3

Hard between Rihanna & Leona, but voted for Rihanna.

Not only do they have to have released an album to have a comeback, they have to have been away for years! Leona, Mutya and Rihanna certainly aren't comebacks - Alicia and Kylie are.

 

 

Everyone on that list is a comeback, except for Leona and Rihanna. And I hope you are just using Kylie and Alicia as examples... and not as the only artists who you believe are worthy of being deemed a comeback.

 

And Mutya is a comeback IMO, she was in Sugababes but she already has a fan base that was waiting on new music from her.

Mine's not in the list: Celine Dion - Taking Chances

Same Here, Celine Dion - Taking Chances