October 27, 200717 yr I've been right so far! :P Danni has made it 2-1, i think simon will make it 3 votes for daniel.
October 27, 200717 yr Im sure next week Alisha will get given something to make sure shes not in the bottom 2 - however lets face it shes not gonna win x factor Emily in the bottom next week definatly
October 27, 200717 yr Author And Simon should have chose Alisha to go out, so it would have been a public vote But in the end the right person went out, I was so surprised Leon went thru
October 27, 200717 yr Andy & Leon were the worst 2 again, Should have been them in the bottom 2. Daniel was rubbish tonight though. I'm glad Alisha hasnt gone- She well needs a better song!!
October 27, 200717 yr Daniel was c**p, so he deserved to go. then again, all but about 4 of them were dreadful!
October 27, 200717 yr Author Daniel was c**p, so he deserved to go. then again, all but about 4 of them were dreadful! I agree, along with Alisha, Leon, Andy and Emily Sharon needs to lift her game she is the one mentoring the 2 young girls, I just think her remaining acts will leave in the next 3 weeks, and Sharon will leave the X Factor for good. she looks as if she had enough.
October 27, 200717 yr I think Sharon and Louis should both leave, they are making the show look even more tired than it already is.
October 27, 200717 yr ew Andy, why isn't he bottom 2? If the cause he is fit reason is used i am annoyed Well do you think he was put through because of his singing ability? Of course not!
October 27, 200717 yr Well do you think he was put through because of his singing ability? Of course not! I really have to disagree with this, Andy is one of the people who has really gone out to change week on week. He went from 'stand with microphone and make the audience believe it' last week to 'work the whole stage, incorporating dance' this week. I think his vocals are some of the best on the show, he has an immense warmth to his voice which, to be fair, was showcased better last week but I think to put the voters down to his looks is disrespectful. I am not naive enough to suggest that no-one is voting for him for that reason, of course the young girls are, but Daniel's 'PS. We Love You' on Xtra Factor was made up of people saying how good looking he was - and it didn't help him, now did it? I actually joined up to argue with that :unsure: Geek! Anyway, now I'm here, my opinion from best to worst: 01. Niki 02. Same Difference (though it pains me to say it) 03. Andy 04. Leon (I can't see the fault, he sang my favourite song of all time and did a good job, far better than Westlife) 05. Futureproof 06. Hope 07. Beverley 08. Rhydian (excellent but as a theatrical performance not as a pop star) 09. Alisha 10. Emily 11. Daniel
October 27, 200717 yr 01. Niki 02. Same Difference (though it pains me to say it) 03. Andy 04. Leon (I can't see the fault, he sang my favourite song of all time and did a good job, far better than Westlife) 05. Futureproof 06. Hope 07. Beverley 08. Rhydian (excellent but as a theatrical performance not as a pop star) 09. Alisha 10. Emily 11. Daniel I think Beverly is ALOT better then acts like Leon (PUKE) and Futureproof (PUKE). And why does Rhydian have to be a popstar? Nothing wrong with Broadway performances.
October 27, 200717 yr Best to worst: 1 Hope - was just amaze :wub: 2 Same Difference - were actually really good! 3 Andy - it wasn't as bad as everyone made out. Far better than BeeGees version. 4 Futureproof - they sound so good together, even if they don't look all that right. 5 Beverly - great performance 6 Rhydian - utter knob but he's good at what he does. 7 Leon - Meh. 8 Niki - Started off so well but then murdered it when she got to the high notes. Can't understand why she was arse-licked so much? 9 Alisha - c**p song, though everyone knows she can do better. Right choice to keep her in. 10 Emily - lack of charisma and performance. Not ready at all for this sort of competition. 11 Daniel - song was $h!t but his voice is way over-rated anyways
October 27, 200717 yr I think Beverly is ALOT better then acts like Leon (PUKE) and Futureproof (PUKE). And why does Rhydian have to be a popstar? Nothing wrong with Broadway performances. I think Beverley is great, don't get me wrong. I would give her seven out of ten but that was not as good as she did in the other stages for me. I think I would have appreciated it more if it had been the first non-Whitney performance I had heard of it. However, ultimately I agreed with Simon, having heard Leona and a million other reality show stars sing it, it was far from the best perfomance of that song I have heard. And I don't think Rhydian should change and be a popstar, and of course there is nothing wrong with Broadway BUT I just think if he won this show it would be the same old Il Divo/Ray Quinn story. He would get an album out there, no singles, then a year later he would be back with another album of the same stuff and Cowell will expect it to sell just as well. Andy Abraham and Journey South have proved this is not the case so unless Simon is going to make a star out of him with Broadway shows coinciding with single releases then for me it seems pointless voting him in as the winner. I think he will be better off not winning and going the Brenda route straight into the West End. All that plus I still can't stand him despite his obvious talent.
Create an account or sign in to comment