That Spice Girls song really is only selling on name alone, so disgraceful.

 

Have you not stopped and thought that some people might actually like the song?

Have you not stopped and thought that some people might actually like the song?

 

Of course, but I've hardly seen universally glowing reviews or reception for it either.

Of course, but I've hardly seen universally glowing reviews or reception for it either.

 

Maybe not. But they ain't bringing an album out there just releasing a single for charity, and doing a tour.

 

I like the song, and it features quite highly on the Buzzjack Multichart so I can't be the only one to like it.

 

So to say it's only selling because it's the spice girls, could be true in some ways, but would people actually buy a song they didn't like?

Well, the music buying public are like sheep at the best of times.

Alicia #4 :o

Kylie #12

Spice Girls #18

 

YEY go Spices :cheer:

That Spice Girls song really is only selling on name alone, so disgraceful.

 

the song is beautiful...

the song is beautiful...

 

It makes me want to throw up over the radio.

 

But each to their own.

It makes me want to throw up over the radio.

 

But each to their own.

 

Well I don't like it either but that's all I'm saying. Lots of people bought Joe Dolce's Shaddapya Face and kept probably one of the best songs of the 1980's from getting to number one. So you're right ... each to their own.

 

I wouldn't throw up over a perfectly good radio for it though ... I'd at least manage to make my way to the bathroom!

 

Norma

Edited November 7, 200717 yr by Norma_Snockers

Kylie #11

Spice #16

 

Maybe in the next update the Spices will have surpassed Kylie!

 

Can't wait for the battle on Sunday!

Edited November 7, 200717 yr by rub

I agree with Aly, it only sells on name. If it was not the SG and not a CIN single, this song would have never been on itunes top20 in 2 days (would have never been top20 at all IMO), it wouldn't get any radio support, and people would even not give a 2nd listen to it.

I agree with Aly, it only sells on name. If it was not the SG and not a CIN single, this song would have never been on itunes top20 in 2 days (would have never been top20 at all IMO), it wouldn't get any radio support, and people would even not give a 2nd listen to it.

 

Not surprised by your comment seeing your sig.

 

Do I have to remind you the GA #1's? 2 out of 3 are from charity singles. (Let's not discuss their quality...) The other one is a single released from the final of the most watched programme in the UK at the time.

 

So, please, stop talking of selling thanks to charity and hype...

 

iTunes Top 50 Songs

 

1. Bleeding Love - Leona Lewis

2. Rule the World (Radio Edit) - Take That

3. Apologize - Timbaland

4. No One - Alicia Keys

5. Valerie - Mark Ronson

6. Hot Stuff (Let's Dance) - Craig David

7. About You Now (Radio Edit) - Sugababes

8. Gimme More - Britney Spears

9. Uninvited (Radio Edit) - Freemasons

10. Goodbye Mr. A (Radio Edit) - The Hoosiers

11. 2 Hearts - Kylie Minogue

12. Home - Westlife

13. Happy Ending - MIKA

14. Hate That I Love You - Rihanna

15. Hey There Delilah - Plain White T's

16. Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) [Radio Version] - Spice Girls

17. She's So Lovely - Scouting for Girls

18. Handle Me (Radio Edit) - Robyn

19. Heater (Radio Edit) - Samim

20. Let Me Think About It (Radio Edit) - Ida Corr vs Fedde Le Grand

21. In the Air Tonight - Phil Collins

22. Taking Chances - C?ine Dion

23. Let's Dance to Joy Division - The Wombats

24. Rock Star - Nickelback

25. Ayo Technology (feat. Justin Timberlake) - 50 Cent

26. The Heart Never Lies (Radio Edit) - McFly

27. Rule the World - Take That

28. Hot - Avril Lavigne

29. About You Now - Sugababes

30. Good Life (feat. T-Pain) - Kanye West

31. Kiss Kiss (feat. T-Pain) - Chris Brown

32. The Way I Are - Timbaland, D.O.E. & Keri Hilson

33. Goodbye Mr A - The Hoosiers

34. Baby Love (feat. will.i.am) - Nicole Scherzinger

35. Stronger - Kanye West

36. The Pretender - Foo Fighters

37. Big Girls Don't Cry (Personal) - Fergie

38. Valerie (Version Revisited) [feat. Amy Winehouse] - Mark Ronson

39. End of the Road - Boyz II Men

40. Bleeding Love - Leona Lewis

41. Umbrella - Rihanna

42. 1973 - James Blunt

43. Worried About Ray - The Hoosiers

44. Tears Dry On Their Own - Amy Winehouse

45. Apologize (feat. Timbaland) - OneRepublic

46. Home - Michael Bubl?br/>47. Shut Up and Drive - Rihanna

48. Gimme More - Britney Spears

49. Let Me Think About It (Club Mix) - Ida Corr vs. Fedde Le Grand

50. No U Hang Up - Shayne Ward

WOW ALICIA!!

Looking good for Alicia :o

Not surprised by your comment seeing your sig.

 

Do I have to remind you the GA #1's? 2 out of 3 are from charity singles. (Let's not discuss their quality...) The other one is a single released from the final of the most watched programme in the UK at the time.

 

So, please, stop talking of selling thanks to charity and hype...

oh my, thats 1 of the best posts i have ever seen.

 

wow, at kylie an the spices climbing high, and at the sugas holding on

It's good to see Alicia doing so well, now there's a girl who knows how to put over a song, she knows exactly how to deliver the goods.

Not surprised by your comment seeing your sig.

 

Do I have to remind you the GA #1's? 2 out of 3 are from charity singles. (Let's not discuss their quality...) The other one is a single released from the final of the most watched programme in the UK at the time.

 

So, please, stop talking of selling thanks to charity and hype...

 

Haha brilliant :lol:

Couldnt have put it better myself.

 

westlife.... down...

Fair do's with the Girls Aloud comments, but they have still achieved numerous Top 5 / Top 10's under their own steam, a few with first week sales which would be comfortable No.1 hits if released in a less busy week. Anyway...

 

Spice Girls climb to 14 on iTunes, Kylie sticks at 11

Not surprised by your comment seeing your sig.

 

Do I have to remind you the GA #1's? 2 out of 3 are from charity singles. (Let's not discuss their quality...) The other one is a single released from the final of the most watched programme in the UK at the time.

 

So, please, stop talking of selling thanks to charity and hype...

 

Huh? I have never said that 'Walk this way' was a true succes, I'm the first one to say it was all about the Comic Relief hype.

But you're a bit out of subject. I was talking about the Spice Girls, and the fact I'm a GA fan doesn't mean I have no right to comment a SG song. I know that GA will NEVER have the worldwide success and appeal of SG, I'm just saying that the new SG single is bland and very poor for pop icons, that's my right to think it, no?

 

And f1mad, you're just a sad f***er, everytime someone disagrees with me, you're like "hurrah you're the best haha he's a sad tosser mother f***ing c**t"... GET A LIFE and just stop replying or quoting or talking about my posts, and everything will be fine.

Edited November 7, 200717 yr by Bertie87