Jump to content

Girls Aloud V Sugababes 150 members have voted

  1. 1. WHO IS THE BETTER GIRLBAND

    • Girls Aloud
      70
    • Sugababes
      78

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

the vote is equal now so i think close it as it shows both bands are like equally,i personnaly prefer Girls Aloud but i do enjoy some of sugababes stuff also,both bands have alot of the same fans and also different fans but but liked in high measures
  • Replies 285
  • Views 11.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Girls Aloud.

 

No Good Advice, The Show, Biology, Money, & Sound Of The Underground are all AMAZING. :wub:

I still haven't heard 'Call The Shots' :o

WHAAT :D

LMAO, of course you are missing something ^^

Its a brilliant song, a Girls Aloud classic :P lol

call the shots is brilliant you just have to get to hear and i recommend you buy it its def up there with there best tracks to dat

Call The Shots is easily one of their greatest! :o

 

I'm seeing both acts live soon. Musically for me its Sugababes, but touring is GA. f***ing spot on!

You're not missing much IMO.
He really is, such a great mid-tempo track from the girls. And the fact that its in the top 5 biggest selling GA songs of all time speaks for itself!
Cor blimey! This must be one of the most popular poles! How long is this gonna go on for?
Sugababes are a good band who produce some good music but they will never have the personality or charm that girls aloud have.

 

Girls aloud will be remembered more than the sugababes and will always be much more respected for consistently having an edge rather than moving from hole in the head to pretty bland pop like change and about you now.

 

People often dampen GA's reputation because of album sales etc but its about so much more than that.

 

So for me, its GA all the way!

 

Will GA be remembered more though? A lot of their key tracks are just re-hashes of their past triumphs. Wake Me Up, Sexy No No No, Something Kinda Oooh (they need a new producer)....I don't think a lot of their tracks are really all that distincitve from each other, whereas Sugababes track generally have all had their own identity.

Edited by Shoat

because Follow Me Home was a fantastic single choice <_< especially when they had Ace Reject on the album! :thumbup:

 

Ace Reject would have been better, but I'm not convinced Follow Me Home was a bad choice either. I think they'd sold enough of the album at that point that any fourth single was going to fare badly.

Will GA be remembered more though? A lot of their key tracks are just re-hashes of their past triumphs. Wake Me Up, Sexy No No No, Something Kinda Oooh (they need a new producer)....

 

Nah Xenomania work just fine!!! much better than getting someone like the beatmasters and betty boo in again

I voted Sugababes but I do like Girls Aloud, just think overall Sugababes have done better songs.

Sugababes.

 

I like Girls Aloud too.

Will GA be remembered more though? A lot of their key tracks are just re-hashes of their past triumphs. Wake Me Up, Sexy No No No, Something Kinda Oooh (they need a new producer)....I don't think a lot of their tracks are really all that distincitve from each other, whereas Sugababes track generally have all had their own identity.

 

 

But that would come from working with a variety of producers.

 

They always have different co-writers and producers on an album. Like TIMW had A LOT of Dallas Ausitn, where as change has a lot of different producers.

 

Plus, if i go to see a band live i'd rather they sang in key and in tune instead of dancing with weaker vocals (IMO)

On a girls aloud tour, you dont care what they sound like as the whole place is just buzzing.

 

They are definately the best act ive seen on tour but hell i dont need to say that, the ticket sales have proven it.

 

GA will always be remembered more than the sugababes because they have personality. The sugababes are just about good music and good music is coming out all the time.

Edited by Robintime11

On a girls aloud tour, you dont care what they sound like as the whole place is just buzzing.

 

They are definately the best act ive seen on tour but hell i dont need to say that, the ticket sales have proven it.

 

GA will always be remembered more than the sugababes because they have personality. The sugababes are just about good music and good music is coming out all the time.

 

Really? Cheryl and Sarah aside, when have any of the other three girls ever displayed a strong personality?

 

And frankly if I'm going to go to a music concert, it'll be the MUSIC I care about.

 

And did I miss the announcement that Girls Aloud are the #1 biggest selling live act? Because otherwise how would "the ticket sales have proven it"?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.