August 7, 200915 yr It's quite close between them all but I'd go like this - 1.Mariah - Obsessed 2.Shakira - She Wolf 3.Whitney - Million Dollar Bill 4.Madonna - Celebration although I think Madonna will probz do the best and Mariah the worst :(
August 7, 200915 yr 1.Mariah - Obsessed 2.Shakira - She Wolf 3.Madonna - Celebration 4.Whitney - Million Dollar Bill Madonna will be the biggest chart-wise though. :D
August 7, 200915 yr Madonna is the only diva in there... and 'Celebration' is the best track she has released since 1994's 'Secret'.....
August 7, 200915 yr Chart wise it'll go #01 Celebration #04 She Wolf #09 Obsessed #12 Million Dollar Bill
August 7, 200915 yr Madonna is the only diva in there... and 'Celebration' is the best track she has released since 1994's 'Secret'..... :rofl: I was nearly going to say the opposite but restrained myself :kink:
August 7, 200915 yr RATINGS: 10.00 - 'Obsessed' 09.50 - 'She Wolf' 08.00 - 'Million Dollar Bill' 05.00 - 'Celebration' (GENERICORAMA)
August 7, 200915 yr 10 She Wolf 7 Celebration 0.00000000000000000000000000000000001 Obsessed Not heard MDB Edited August 7, 200915 yr by B-slice
August 7, 200915 yr Shakira without any doubt. Critics are lauding over it, everyone on the internet seems to love, awesome new style that she hasn't really gone into before [apart from PI/LDLI] - best song of the summer, and Whitney & Mariah are pretty sub-par.No idea what "Celebration" is but I don't really care to.
August 7, 200915 yr Celebration #1 She Wolf #1-3 I think there's stronger songs out atm, but Shakira already has 2 #1's under her belt, so she's obviously got a big fan base Obsessed #6 Most of Mariah's stuff these days charts in this region, so I'd expect this to do the same Million Dollar Bill #15 Will be quite hyped, but I can't see it going top 10, the album will probably be big though
August 7, 200915 yr Author All four of these songs are so good. It's quite rare you get a year where all of the diva comebacks are great. I'm not even sure if 'Diva' is correctly used in this context. To me, it means a female singer with a big ego. I wouldn't apply that to Shakira, I definitely *would* to Mariah - but only to a lesser extent to the other two. A 'lesser extent' to Whitney? She has or did have an ego that would put Kanye West to shame! To me - Whitney seems the only one that is a comeback! The others have only been gone five minutes! Shakira has been gone three years! I did use the term loosely though.
August 7, 200915 yr She Wolf! Shakira is just hilarious. Not only is she doing something new and out of the box [unlike the others], it's a damn good song that is catchy as hell from the wolf howling to the use of the word of lycanthropy. Madonna's is OK but it's not really stand out and I do like Whitney's. As for Mariah it sounds like something you'd save for 3rd or 4th single at most. She was so good in the 'Mimi' era but she seems to just be releasing boring, flat tunes now. It'll sell regardless though... Mariah 05/10 [Chart 8-15] Madonna 08/10 [Chart 1 or 2] Shakira 10/10 [Chart 2-5] Whitney 07/10 [Chart 11-20]
August 7, 200915 yr She Wolf! Shakira is just hilarious. Not only is she doing something new and out of the box [unlike the others], it's a damn good song that is catchy as hell from the wolf howling to the use of the word of lycanthropy. Madonna's is OK but it's not really stand out and I do like Whitney's. As for Mariah it sounds like something you'd save for 3rd or 4th single at most. She was so good in the 'Mimi' era but she seems to just be releasing boring, flat tunes now. It'll sell regardless though... Mariah 05/10 [Chart 8-15] Madonna 08/10 [Chart 1 or 2] Shakira 10/10 [Chart 2-5] Whitney 07/10 [Chart 11-20] YOU MUST DO 10 HAIL MARIAH'S TO BE FORGIVEN FOR YOUR SINS. THX. :heart:
August 7, 200915 yr I can't actually believe that Mariah is leading (by a margin at that!), everytime Mariah is polled against anybody she's usually last by a country mile. :lol:
August 7, 200915 yr She Wolf >>> Obsessed > Celebration >>>>>> Million Dollar Bill. Celebration will get to #1 in the UK. Shakira could get #1 but will properly be top 3. Mariah will get to around #8 or #9 and Whitney will get a top 15 hit.
August 7, 200915 yr Madonna's is best imo, it was on in town like 3 times last night was great to dance to :lol: Shakira's just seems silly I like it but I really can't see it catching on :unsure: Mariah's & Whitney's I reckon will both perform simularly to one another as their both not amazing but are quite good ^_^
Create an account or sign in to comment