Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

Just rank them peeps, here is mine

 

01 Confessions On A Dancefloor

02 Ray Of Light

03 Erotica

04 American Life

05 Madonna

06 Like A Prayer

07 True Blue

08 Like A Virgin

09 MDNA

10 Rebel Heart

(I'm Breathless)

12 Hard Candy

12 Bedtime Stories

13 Music

  • Replies 31
  • Views 3.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

01 Confessions On A Dancefloor

02 Ray Of Light

03 True Blue

04 Music

05 Like A Prayer

06 American Life

07 MDNA

08 Like A Virgin

09 Rebel Heart

10 Erotica

11 Madonna

12 Hard Candy

13 Bedtime Stories

 

It gets a little blurred after #7 (which just continues to grow on me, and will soon overtake 'American Life'). Every one has special moments in, and i still enjoy listening to 'Bedtime Stories' despite it taking the wooden spoon.

1) True Blue

2) Ray of Light

3) Like a Prayer

4) Erotica

5) Like a Virgin

6) Confessions on a Dancefloor

7) Music

8) Madonna

9) American Life

10) Rebel Heart

11) Bedtime Stories

12) Hard Candy

13) MDNA

Edited by Joe.

Amazing:

01 Confessions on a Dancefloor

02 Like a Prayer

03 Ray of Light

04 Hard Candy

05 Bedtime Stories

06 Erotica

 

Good:

07 American Life

08 Rebel Heart

09 True Blue

10 MDNA

 

Okay:

11 Like a Virgin

12 Music

 

Terrible:

13 Madonna

Way to early to include rebel Heart it's been released for less then 24 hours

01 American Life

02 Hard Candy

03 Music

04 MDNA

05 Rebel Heart

06 Confessions On A Dancefloor

07 True Blue

08 Ray Of Light

09 Erotica

10 Like A Virgin

12 Bedtime Stories

12 Like A Prayer

13 Madonna

  • Author
Way to early to include rebel Heart it's been released for less then 24 hours

Or about 6/7 weeks for some of us (or indeed almost 3 months if we count demo versions)

Excellent:

 

1 Slay of Light :wub:

2 Erotica

3 Bedtime Stories

90s Madonna >>>>>>>>>

4 American Life

5 Music

6 Rebel Heart

 

Very good:

 

7 Like a Prayer

8 Confessions on a Dance Floor

 

Good:

 

9 Madonna

 

Fair:

 

10 Hard Candy

11 MDNA

 

Poor:

 

12 True Blue

 

Deplorable:

 

13 Like a Virgin

I really had to think about when I first listened to them and how much I loved them at the time:

 

1) True Blue

2) Ray Of Light

3) Like a Prayer

4) American Life

5) Confessions On A Dancefloor

6) Rebel Heart

7) Madonna

8) Erotica

9) Like a virgin

10) Music

11) Bedtime Stories

12) Hard Candy

13) MDNA

 

I really had to think about when I first listened to them and how much I loved them at the time:

 

1) True Blue

2) Ray Of Light

3) Like a Prayer

 

Same top 3 as me <3 I'm surprised how low down True Blue is on some people's lists.

  • Author
True Blue is an album of almost wall to wall great songs, BUT as an album it doesn't really work for me as anything more than a collection of great songs. They all sound similar of course, but it's not got the variation of much of her later work in terms of sound/style/content, especially not the 2 albums hat follow it (and Ray of Light of course).
True Blue is an album of almost wall to wall great songs, BUT as an album it doesn't really work for me as anything more than a collection of great songs. They all sound similar of course, but it's not got the variation of much of her later work in terms of sound/style/content, especially not the 2 albums hat follow it (and Ray of Light of course).

 

I can agree with you on it sounding like a collection of songs; to me it doesn't sound like a usual Madonna album (and not in a positive way), and I think it feels quite empty. However, for me I have to say that I only think Papa Don't Preach, Open Your Heart, Live to Tell and La Isla Bonita are worthwhile, making the remainder of the record fairly pointless. I don't think it has a lot to offer and Like a Virgin is even weaker; I only enjoy three of its ten tracks.

 

I hope I didn't piss any 80s fans off. :P To me her 90s records and much of her 00s work is so superior that it's not even up for discussion, but I guess LAV and TB are very nostalgic and memorable for many older fans.

Here's mine. I'm 55 and have been a fan since she started.

 

1. Like A Virgin

2. Music

3. True Blue

4. Like A Prayer

5. Confessions On A Dancefloor

6. Bedtime Stories

7. Rebel Heart

8. MDNA

9. Ray Of Light

10. American Life

11. Hard Candy

12. Madonna/ First Album

13. Erotica -

Edited by Common Sense

I'm slowly getting through her albums, not done yet but this is them all so far:

 

1. Confessions on a Dance Floor

2. Music

3. Ray of Light

4. True Blue

5. Like a Prayer

6. Rebel Heart

7. Like a Virgin

8. Madonna

 

I can't say I've disliked any of these though! Rebel Heart would probably stand a chance of being higher if it were a bit shorter with less filler.

This is really quite difficult, I've loved most of her albums at some point or another even if I can see in retrospect (and with less loon tinted glasses on) that some aren't really all that. But I'll settle with something a little like this...

 

 

Like a Prayer

Ray Of Light

American Life

Confessions on a Dance Floor

Music

True Blue

Rebel Heart (a somewhat trimmed down version)

Bedtime Stories

Erotica

Hard Candy

I'm Breathless

Madonna

Like a Virgin

MDNA

 

1. Ray Of Light

2. Confessions On A Dancefloor

3. Like A Prayer

4. Madonna

5. Erotica

6. Like A Virgin

7. True Blue

8. Rebel Heart

9. MDNA

10. Music

11. American Life

12. Bedtime Stories

 

 

13. Hard Candy

 

MDNA is decent (if you trim the fat), the next 3 have their moments but Hard Candy is honest to god one of the worst albums I've ever listened to. Utter monstrosity.

 

Rebel Heart could climb to 5th/6th in time maybe.

Edited by mr_aly

I added up the scores of the ten lists including all thirteen of her studio albums, and got the following list (from favourable to least favourable; maximum score 130):

 

1 Ray of Light 108

2 Confessions on a Dance Floor 101

3 Like a Prayer 94

4 True Blue 84

5 American Life 81

6 Erotica 71

7 Rebel Heart 70

8 Music 69

9 Like a Virgin 57

10 Bedtime Stories 48

11 Madonna 47

13 Hard Candy 43

13 MDNA 43

 

Hard Candy received more higher scores than MDNA. Bedtime Stories being so low, and True Blue being that high, makes my eyes sore.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.