Louis may pull out of tonights show. Obviously perfectly understandable decision.

 

Robbie should sit in for him. ^_^

Why is he pulling out? I'm so dumb... as proved by all the Danyl stuff last night.

Why is he pulling out? I'm so dumb... as proved by all the Danyl stuff last night.

 

He is the manager of the late Stephen Gately

Rachel Absolutely stunning. Very Rihanna looking that's what you can't deny but on vocals she's completely different. For the first live performance of the whole season that was really impressive. 8.5/10

 

Kandy Rain Poor girls. They don't stand a chance here. The performance was dire, so as their self-confidence. f*** everybody. Just go out there naked if you want and sing. 4/10

 

Olly That was a disaster. Meh. Don't really have much to say because i already forgot hisperformance. :/ 3/10

 

Rikki Amy Wino's song. <3 For that only he deserves extra points. But that was an okay first time on live shows for him. I don't see him being in the Top 5. 5/10

 

Stacey God i love her. She's HILARIOUS. And a real talent. The best performance of the night. 9/10

 

Miss Frank Oh dear, didn't like it at all. They weren't a 'group' this time, at least it's my opinion. But that's a beginning, i have no doubts they will kill it later. 5/10

 

Jamie I noticed he never does his best in the beginning of his performance leaving everything for last. It sometimes doesn't work unfortunately. Like Robbie does the best he is capable of right at the beginning keeping this level until the very end. That's the true attitude. He was the favourite of mine to win this show, now i think he won't. 5.5/10

 

Lloyd Actually I LOVED his voice in this song. Ok, maybe he was clumsy in those moves but he's 16 for God's sake. I also love his voice. Very James Morrison that is pretty rare for thge music scene. 5.5/10

 

Lucie I hated this song before the performance, i still do after. Did NOTHING for me. If she's singing all the ballads there's no way Lucie's surviving the next rounds unfortunately. The lovely girl but the generic voice. Leona>>>>>Lucie. 4/10

 

John & Edward Oh dear. Just OMFDEAR. -19/10

 

Joe Oh God, that was f***ing incredible! I was following his facial movements all the performance, he REALLY is great. The best performance of the night (tied with Stacey's). I hope he goes to the final. A.M.A.Z.I.N.G. 9/10

 

Danyl He was so uncomfortable from the beginning, like somebody is going to shoot him at the stage or he's just found out that he has been adopted. Vile. But nevertheless he's gonna win the whole thing. The DUSK OF X-FACTOR. 1/10

 

-----------------------------------

 

Ok my rankings:

 

1. Joe

1. Stacey

3. Rachel

 

---------------- (the absolutely endless space here)

 

4. Lloyd

5. Jamie

6. Miss Frank

 

----------------

 

7. Rikki

8. Lucie

9. Kandy Rain

10. Olly

 

----------------

 

11. Danyl

12. John & Edward

Last night was under false pretences, it was supposed to be "Idol's Night" and the idea that Kandy Rain were bought up on Robert Palmer's Greatest Hits or Miss Frank spent their teenage years worshipping the Jackson 5 or Danyl's all time hero is Jennifer Hudson is well far fetched and Leona hasn't been around long enough to be the all time idol of an 18 year old girl so they should not insult the intelligence of the public by calling it Idol's Night

 

 

Last night was under false pretences, it was supposed to be "Idol's Night" and the idea that Kandy Rain were bought up on Robert Palmer's Greatest Hits or Miss Frank spent their teenage years worshipping the Jackson 5 or Danyl's all time hero is Jennifer Hudson is well far fetched and Leona hasn't been around long enough to be the all time idol of an 18 year old girl so they should not insult the intelligence of the public by calling it Idol's Night

Jennifer Hudson hasn't been going that long either has she? :unsure: I think Leona's been going a little longer but not sure...

It was an excuse to use Robbie songs without it being a Robbie week.

Edited October 11, 200915 yr by Sugababes' Steve

Dannii just said:

 

My thoughts go out to Andrew Cowles, and the boys Ronan, Keith, Shane and Mikey. Louis glad you could get there to be with them xXx

 

So presume that means he isn't gonna be on?

Dannii just said:

So presume that means he isn't gonna be on?

 

Depends when he went really, Majorca on a private jet would be like 90 mins each way so if he went early he could still be back for tonight, would guess Cowell will have lent him his plane

 

I don't see really what Louis can do out there really, he is not a doctor or coroner or anything would just be a case of "sorry about your loss guys :( "

Very true. It's highly likely he'll be back in time if I headed out this morning.

 

I dont quite get why the boys have all rushed out there tbh. Like you say, they cant really do anything.

It's just a case of being there for the family, seeing as he was apart of their lives. Also it's all about respect.

 

If none of them went, everyone and the press would be saying they were disrespectful etc... They've only done what 99% of everyone else would do if it was one of their friends...

He is the manager of the late Stephen Gately

Of course! How stupid of me.

Confirmed he won't be appearing by his publicist. No word if itll be 3 judges or a replacement yet.

POOR Kandy Rain. They are doomed now surely?

TBH it looks like a group is definitely gone.

Stacey was by far the best. John and Edward by far the worst imo.

Apparently John & Edward want to get "jiggy" with Kandy Rain :manson:

 

They're too good for them......actually everyone is too good for them. :puke:

Rachel - She's got good vocals, just needs to expand her voice more. Try hitting some crazy notes like Beyonce does, that way it'll appear to be more energetic. I think the song choice was a good one though. 7/10

 

Kandy Rain - Boring, predictable. Hopefully they'll go. 1/10

 

Olly Murs - Am I the only one who thinks he's the most un-original singer on there? It wasn't a bad rendition however, he just needs to stop trying to be Stevie Wonder/Jay Kay. 6/10

 

Rikki - WHAT'S WITH THE EYEBROW?! It fukks me off. He's got a bit of an old mans warblers voice, I don't think it comes across as that appeal, especially with someone so young. I'd be surprised if he lasted long. 3/10

 

Lucie Jones - She's got a nice voice, and you can tell she's got more to prove. Not to bad. 8/10

 

Joe McElderly - What's with all the love? To me it sounded flat, and came across as limp, especially those big-eyed facial expressions. -.- 2/10

 

Stacey - By far the best one in there. Her vocals aren't the best, but she's always a surprise. i.e. her first audition she sung Louis Armstrong, then Coldplay, which she pulled of well. Thank god she hasn't so far done any Mariah/Whitney/Celine tracks. 9/10

 

Miss Frank - By FAR (vocally), the best UK girl group there is (I mean, c'mon. Can the Sugababes or The Saturdays sing like that?). They've all got real good voices, harmonize well, made an old song current etc. etc. Hopefully they'll go far. 9/10

 

Jamie - You can tell who Simon wants to win. A high budgeted performance which wasn't really needed, the back screen, fireworks, band (if they where actually playing, I would be surprised if they where). His vocals are good, he just needs a better song next time. 4/10

 

Lloyd - Even more limp than the Joe guy. The vocals where incredibly pitchy, which is a shame cause he's got a nice tone to his voice. Wasn't necessary the wrong track, he should have killed it, he just didn't sing it well. 3/10

 

The Twins - 0/10

 

Danyl - He looks like Prince, sings like Anastacia. A weird combo. Tbh, I found this performance more cringeworthy than the twins. Ridiculous song choice, he could've easily done Maroon 5 and been just as good. And LOL at Dannii. :rofl: I thought she was drunk for a minute there. :lol: 2/10

My rank of the performances:

 

01 Stacey

02 Joe

03 Lucie

-

04 Rachel

05 Olly

06 Miss Frank

-

07 Danyl

08 Jamie

-

09 Rikki

-

10 Lloyd

11 Kandy Rain

12 Jon & Edward

 

Very surprised by Joe. Stacey is sensational. I'm torn now because I want her to win but I have money on Danyl, Lucie and Rachel!

Jamie - You can tell who Simon wants to win. A high budgeted performance which wasn't really needed, the back screen, fireworks, band (if they where actually playing, I would be surprised if they where). His vocals are good, he just needs a better song next time. 4/10

 

I love the song, massive fan of glam rock but Jamie was just embarrassing looked more like Gary Glitter out there than Marc Bolan, was pathetic attempt at glam rock not a patch on Bolan, Noddy Holder, Brian Johnson, Gary Holton, Brian Connolly and so on, it was just p*** poor Stars In Their Eyes/karaoke to me

 

There is just nothing to his voice that does anything for me, went from dull to shouty

Edited October 11, 200915 yr by B.A Baracus

I didn't understand that Dannii's comment about 'changing gender'. Can anybody please explain? :(